Qiongli 2.4.0 — traceable research, substantive writing and Plugin reliability
Current work continues in the November 13 long-material observation. Earlier sections retain their historical candidate identities and decisions.
- Status: the maintainer authorizes continued development through release readiness on October 5, then confirms isolated AGY login and remote source synchronization, the required PR, Native CI and four-target CLI/Cargo qualification on October 6. Publication and main cutover remain separate. Subsequent writing-quality feedback selects the bounded content increment recorded below; it does not approve the pending AGY scope proposal. The latest instruction makes source-traceable literature work and writing the main 2.4.0 outcome and authorizes planning plus local implementation. On October 7 the maintainer explicitly requests completion of claim splitting and saved-writing recovery, release preparation and publication-task dispatch, then an end to the conversation without follow-up monitoring. This authorizes the required remote synchronization, reviewed main cutover, tag and release dispatch. The maintainer also explicitly approves the prepared experimental Antigravity scope: retain its failed strict gates for later promotion while keeping Codex, final-source package and upgrade checks mandatory. That release task was dispatched at
fa5d1537without subsequent monitoring. The next bounded request addresses AGY's crowded Skill list; its local fix and checks are recorded below without a new publication or live-session claim. - Candidate version:
2.4.0, reflecting the additive Antigravity adapter and improvements to existing research workflows. Canonical version inputs are synchronized ine4b05659; this does not establish publication or readiness. - Local baseline:
186d18751a272c8fffbc0c871b061068093221e6on2.x. - Direction: master roadmap.
- Task state and acceptance: existing ledger.
- Prior observations: October 5 execution record.
Release outcome
A user can retain how literature was found, summarize inspected evidence, write fluent and substantive source-supported prose, and trace a consequential claim back through its evidence records to the exact saved passage and source version. Reviewed work and its bindings survive a fresh session; missing, changed or uninspected evidence stays explicit. Each advertised result has evidence for the actual installed candidate, including background citations and explanatory notes. Codex remains the primary research Host; Antigravity receives a separately qualified local CLI adapter. Existing models and project-write authority remain with their current owners.
The proposed release includes the already implemented AGY adapter (ff62b06a) and baseline evaluator (bcec1b0f). These are integration inputs, not new work to repeat. Their remaining gates are retained alongside the main outcome below.
Current execution priority — source-traceable literature and writing
Start from local 3d83bbf7. The writing-guidance increment is implemented; its synthetic observations do not yet qualify a real manuscript. Existing search logs, notes, reading matrices, claim ledger, Graph, source packets and saved-file read/list services retain ownership. The Graph resolves registered records; that is not a native PDF viewer or proof of source support. No second evidence database, vector index, review-status vocabulary or automatic approval is added.
| Order | Deliverable and existing owner | Exit evidence |
|---|---|---|
| A — exact passage readback, first implementation | Extend the saved-document reader with an optional JSON pointer into a known saved source packet. Preserve file hash/revision bindings and raw reads; connect the locator to existing note and ledger guidance. | CLI and Full MCP return identical decoded UTF-8 passage windows. Escaped text, repeated passages and array packets retain distinct locations; invalid selectors, stale hashes/revisions and unsafe files refuse. |
| B — bounded passage discovery | Search text within explicitly selected saved sources through the same project/read ownership. Return inspectable candidates, exact locators and surrounding context, distinguishing no match, multiple matches and incomplete access. | Find an actual phrase despite JSON encoding; preserve every relevant match within declared bounds and continuation. A translated/paraphrased query or absent match cannot manufacture a quotation or establish absence from an unread paper. |
| C — manuscript-first claim detection, traversal and review | Inspect the actual requested draft, including body sections, captions and notes, and identify independently checkable claims even when absent from existing records. Connect exact manuscript spans through current claim IDs, ledger rows, notes and retained sources; inspect supporting/conflicting evidence separately. Apply the shared prose, explanation and note rules during writing. | Draft/review actual body text and recover its source locations. Distinguish results, synthesis and inference; preserve unmapped claims, missing bindings and identity/version conflicts. Check semantic support separately from explanation, paragraph continuity, language and useful note placement. Tool readback alone does not pass either writing judgment. |
| D — summaries, synthesis and change tracking | Reuse reading matrices/summaries and manuscript claim maps for cross-paper comparison and writing. Preserve source versions, search/retrieval failures and prior reviews; identify affected claims when material changes. | A summary and LR maintain the same identities through background, analysis and notes. Changed sources trigger bounded re-review; old evidence and unrelated verified work survive. |
| E — installed journey and final candidate | Exercise search provenance → inspected passages → reviewed notes/synthesis → manuscript claims → reverse lookup → fresh-session recovery through existing installation and write owners. | Frozen public/synthetic inputs, complete actual outputs, exact candidate/source bindings and reviewed support judgments. Requalify final-source packages and retained upgrade/Host gates before readiness. |
Implement A first, then B/C on the settled locator interface, followed by D/E. Local A/B and the Host-guided C/D increments are recorded in sequence below. C starts from actual manuscript prose under the maintainer's clarification; its synthetic observations do not establish installed or real-manuscript quality. D extends that path through synthesis and actual changed-source prose revisions. These focused checks do not complete E or the final release gates. For A, json_pointer selects only an observed string field from a content-addressed source packet. Offsets refer to decoded UTF-8 text while SHA-256 still binds the whole saved JSON file. Preserve native page/section/segment metadata in that packet; do not label a JSON byte offset as a PDF page or fabricate printed page numbers. Unknown/malformed pointers and non-string values refuse without fallback. No-selector requests and old response fields retain their existing meaning.
Use source-specific negative cases throughout: abstract-only access, conflicting outcomes/denominators, changed or missing packets, duplicate passages, absent supplements and unverified locations. Review each material claim in the selected scope, including claims absent from a supplied ledger. An exact text match does not itself establish semantic support, source authenticity or search completeness.
The first local slice adds no live search, private-library access, project-data mutation, installed-Host update or model invocation. Subsequent live batches keep their declared public/synthetic scope and current authorization boundaries. One requested gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier handles focused checks and reviews; do not change configured user models. Record checks and remaining work once per integrated increment under CLI-405/410; preserve all task states and accepted evidence. The pending AGY scope decision and publication authority are unchanged.
Starting evidence
| Observation | Consequence for this plan |
|---|---|
| Three installed-Codex cases: structural 2/3, complete reviewed passes 0/3 | Establish actual guidance use, fix the short paragraph, and keep fixture changes outside observation windows. This does not mean all three answers were academically wrong. |
| AGY install/update, Skill entry reads, 35-tool discovery and a native return observed | Preserve those scoped results; capture the full returned payload and finish the Host observation normally before claiming a clean session pass. |
| AGY validation required several driver corrections; the final Host exited -9 after returning a result | Exercise the driver offline, distinguish tool outcome from driver/process outcome, and retain failed attempts. |
| Literal Skill section coverage is 70/82 | Review the relevant flags in context. The count is not a semantic quality score or a requirement to add boilerplate to every file. |
Detailed hashes, candidates, approval scope and failures remain in the prior execution record. This draft does not relabel that evidence or monitor the previous release.
Retained foundation and release slices
1. Make observations repeatable — required
Extend the existing research-journey capture/review owner and Evaluation Truth V1. Keep native installation, Host trust and project preview/approval/CAS with their existing owners; do not introduce a second evaluator or a custom approval API.
- Freeze candidate, content, prompts, input files and fixture state before a run. Keep per-run manifests immutable; do not overwrite an old candidate's manifest.
- Prefer supported structured Host events/results. Capture complete MCP call arguments, returned payload and error state, with matching call identities. A model's account of a result or a terminal's collapsed object is insufficient.
- Record normal completion, denial, timeout and forced termination separately. Preserve configuration/project snapshots and cleanup results even on failure.
- Limit terminal interaction to the necessary normal trust/approval workflow. Test recorded menus, wrapping and completion/cleanup cases offline before a live run; never grant broader permissions to satisfy a test.
Exit evidence: the retained failure fixtures exercise the corrected driver, and one bounded AGY status call has a complete result, normal or explicitly controlled graceful shutdown, and verified cleanup. Unavailable capture capabilities remain explicit gaps. Existing offline work can proceed while live evidence is pending.
2. Improve the three core Plugin tasks — required
Trace each observed defect to its owner before editing. Initial review scope is content/workflow/SKILL.md, content/workflow/workflows/paper-read.md, content/workflow/workflows/academic-write.md, their referenced B/F contracts, and canonical extraction/retrieval Skills under content/skills/B_literature/. Regenerate distribution payloads through the existing materializer after changes.
| Task | Required behavior |
|---|---|
| Explain supplied paper material | Ground central claims and numbers in visible sources; distinguish supplied excerpts from full-paper access, reported findings from interpretation, and allocation units from analysis units. |
| Write a bounded paragraph | Deliver the requested text, length and format; define the counting convention before review, preserve claim strength and citations, and avoid unsolicited project creation or saving. |
| Resume reviewed saved work | Recover current revision and receipt-backed document bindings from the project ID; read through available native tools, report changed/missing sources and preserve old history. |
Investigate missing guidance evidence before assuming that Skills were not loaded: supported Host injection and explicit file reading can be different mechanisms. Bind whichever mechanism was actually observed to the relevant content version. An unsupported resources/list call does not justify a new resource API merely to turn the test green.
Exit evidence: new captures of all three fixed baseline cases pass their required structural and named answer-review checks, including guidance use. Required unreviewed checks are not passes. Old failures stay in the original denominator; these cases establish a bounded regression result, not broad academic acceptance.
3. Qualify persistence and limited generalization — required
Use one isolated public/synthetic project for an explicit sequence: reviewed reading note → exact write preview and approval → verified persistence → new session → project-ID recovery → source-supported paragraph. Reuse existing storage and revision/CAS services. Test stale revision, source drift, missing files and denied approval; retain existing text and history in every refusal. This persistence journey is separate from direct read-only paragraph requests.
Freeze at least three small held-out cases before execution: limited/abstract-only access, conflicting numerical or unit evidence, and changed-source continuation. Require all declared checks, retain the fixed denominator and review complete answers against supplied sources. Cases used to tune guidance become regression cases; retain fresh held-out evidence before claiming generalization. This small sample cannot establish expert or cross-discipline validity.
Exit evidence: the save/restart journey and held-out required checks pass under their named scope. AGY receives a bounded read/recovery compatibility observation after its status-call capture works; it does not imply simultaneous multi-Host writes or repeat the complete academic matrix on every Host.
4. Deliver the version and preserve upgrades — required
Qualify a frozen candidate with the existing release owner. Include AGY's native Plugin layout, source-retention requirement and trust/fresh-session instructions in release notes and the Host support matrix. Distinguish source export, registration, MCP discovery and an actual successful call in user-facing status.
Check the 2.3.0 → candidate upgrade and retained Codex/Claude/DeepSeek behavior; preserve user models, workflow variants, research data and receipt-backed refusal of unmanaged or changed installations. Diagnose unsupported Host/platform scope explicitly instead of inferring it from a CLI build.
First extend tooling/scripts/native_registry_upgrade_check.py with explicit predecessor selection: its current pip/npm checks select historical 1.17.0/2.1.1 versions and cannot yet establish a 2.3.0 upgrade. Preserve the old defaults and negative cases, bind the selected predecessor and candidate artifacts, and report an unavailable predecessor as an unqualified check rather than silently substituting another version.
Use the existing four-target CLI distribution and archive/npm/wheel/Cargo gates for the final source. Target-native CLI packaging and live AGY qualification are separate claims. Remote qualification, push and publication use their existing authorization boundaries; this plan launches none of them.
Cost, scope and sequencing
One gpt-6.1-sol / low subagent performs bounded independent verification, as requested. Existing Host models remain configured; a verifier model is not a directive to replace AGY's model. No Astra extra-high verification is planned. Use offline tests before live calls, declare each live batch and its limits, and reuse evidence while its inputs remain unchanged. The October 6 maintainer grant authorizes the planned public validation with the existing Codex login. Use an isolated profile and temporary link, remove the link in finally, and never inspect credential contents. Earlier exhausted grants remain historical; do not request the current authority again merely because a prerequisite or batch finishes.
Report actual input/cached/output tokens, tool calls, failures and elapsed time when available. Compare identical tasks and model settings, keeping quality as a condition of any efficiency claim. Do not promise a token reduction percentage or compare different Host/model runs as a controlled benchmark.
Follow the current A–E priority above while retaining these foundation and release obligations and their original failed observations. Prepare release documentation alongside implementation; qualify final artifacts only after the required behavior is stable. Independent development can proceed while a separate external evidence gate waits.
Defer additional Hosts, Desktop expansion, a new Graph or Agent orchestration layer, concurrent multi-Host writing, a broad 82-Skill rewrite, and new provider integrations. These would need a separately selected outcome.
Execution continues under existing CLI-405 (journey/quality), CLI-409 (AGY) and CLI-410 (release) ownership and existing evaluation contracts. This draft adds no task IDs, changes no task state/dependency/accepted evidence, sets no release date, and does not authorize publication. The subsequent maintainer instruction authorizes local implementation through the existing development loop.
Planning-only validation
The requested gpt-6.1-sol / low review passes the seven program-roadmap tests, generated-index consistency and whitespace checks. The ledger is byte-identical to the baseline: all 249 task definitions and 46 accepted records are unchanged. No native build, live Host observation or release check is run for this draft.
October 5 — first authorized implementation increment
Local implementation starts from 2813426f on a feature branch. This increment implements the offline portion of slices 1 and 2; neither slice's live exit gate is declared complete. No task state, dependency or accepted record is promoted.
e167f4bd extends the existing installed-Plugin adapter:
freezeandsealcreate new input/final manifests exclusively, checking frozen source/prompt/installation/catalog bytes and refusing drift or overwrite. These local snapshots are not a lock on live fixtures or authenticated dates.- Actual completed calls retain IDs, event indexes and argument/result/error hashes. Empty/malformed payloads and conflicting error flags cannot satisfy required reads. The installation can bind its exact MCP server name; this does not implement an AGY-to-Codex event converter.
- Tool results remain separate from process/turn completion. Timeout, denial, cancellation, forced exit and incomplete turns retain usable call observations while the case remains unsuccessful. A truncated final JSONL line cannot pass.
- New catalog requirements bind installed guidance snapshots to complete command output or independently retained Host context, plus a separate usage review. Model prose alone cannot establish loading. Context provenance still requires inspection; no unsupported Host export capability is assumed.
- The source paragraph gets an executable whole-answer 250–350 character rule, with non-whitespace Unicode counting and registered anchor-citation exclusions. Semantic review cannot override a failed length check. Historical catalogs, observations and reports retain their original scope and bytes.
f825c60f updates only canonical workflow guidance: use available complete Host guidance or supported installed-file reads; check the final requested prose's length; distinguish sample, allocation, measurement and analysis units; retain source discrepancies and excerpt-only limits. Existing project-ID/binding/read, preview/approval/CAS and configured-model behavior remains with its owners. These instructions address observed risks but do not prove new model behavior.
The requested gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier reports:
| Check | Observed result |
|---|---|
| Focused regression modules | 77/77 pass: Plugin baseline 20, journey observations 11, journey cases 3, routing probe 10, V1 evaluation 14, research-standard validator 19. |
| Original short-paragraph reproduction | Original answer SHA-256 87fc5ef8048b681b30d18a06916e6efae5909f9aa1503be9c9f7f14b74c84b3f counts 227 under the new declared rule and fails 250–350. Original capture/catalog/reports are unchanged. |
| Capability contract | python3 scripts/validate_capability_contract.py passes. |
| Content materialization | Existing build_materialize_source and fail_if_symlinks pass; all four changed canonical files match generated portable bytes. |
| Review | No remaining blocking finding; staged whitespace checks pass. |
The materialized package is retained at /tmp/qiongli-quality-portable-content-p7oe7_6f/source/qiongli-workflow; its local verification record SHA-256 is 54eada462ed4561adcb7f1ef2ab1f3b8f59662a861baad551d09d7bb7114a4dc. An earlier full --target plugin materializer invocation selected the retained Lite build and was stopped/reaped with exit 130. Its partial output remains at /tmp/qiongli-plugin-quality-offline-20261005-verifier-01; it is not a passing Plugin package check. The content-only owner subsequently supplies the required bounded evidence without a Rust build. The first regression run also exposed a test expectation error (a shared invalid guidance hash affects all three cases, not one); correcting that expectation did not weaken the production check.
At integration, all seven program-roadmap tests and generated-index consistency pass. All 249 task IDs/states/dependencies and 46 complete accepted records remain unchanged; only CLI-405 gains this progress record and the current plan link.
No new model or Host session, credential reuse, user installation/configuration change, native candidate build or publication is performed. Existing live 2/3 structural and 0/3 complete baseline results remain historical failures/gaps. The next increment is the retained AGY driver's offline permission/wrapping and shutdown fixtures plus full transport-result capture. Then freeze the changed installed candidate and public fixtures for newly scoped live observations, including the three Codex tasks with the declared counting convention. Their evidence enables slice 3's save/restart and held-out cases; release/upgrade qualification remains later work.
October 5 — bounded AGY capture and cleanup increment
The maintainer requests the next step after b60518bf. Implementation 1ae2bbdd, followed by scoring-identity fix 0cac3641, adds evals/research_journey/antigravity_observation.py under the existing journey owner. It prepares one new capture directory for an exact read-only status request, binds installed identities, command, selected Qiongli environment and fixture/configuration snapshots, and spools full raw stdout/stderr to disk. It neither replaces the user's model nor writes trust/permission settings, links credentials, resumes a conversation or retries a denied call.
The adapter consumes AGY's own stream events and uses the existing V1 runner for behavior checks. Matched invocation steps, native envelope bytes and Host/process completion are distinct observations. Full status evidence requires the existing status schema plus matching MCP content/structuredContent; short tool summaries, bare status objects and model descriptions cannot fill missing output. A Host's SUCCESS status or process exit zero cannot erase a denied action.
The old PTY driver lowercased invocation paths, depended on a recent terminal buffer after the final answer and hashed a reset buffer across restarts. A new current-screen checker preserves JSON path case and exact arguments while recognizing the single-use permission choice; it never sends approval keys. The print driver uses one process and hashes its entire saved stream, with SIGTERM-before-wait, bounded SIGKILL fallback and child reaping on timeout or exceptions. Remaining members of its owned POSIX process group are reported; other-session descendants remain outside that guarantee. The temporary old drivers and captures are unchanged, and no repaired live interactive run is claimed.
The requested gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier passes 56 unique focused checks: 22 new AGY observation cases, 20 existing Plugin baseline cases and 14 V1 cases. The final nested-JSON and scoring-identity fixes rerun only the AGY module; unchanged baseline and V1 results are reused. Coverage includes full synthetic envelopes, denied calls with Host success, summaries/missing output, duplicate/foreign/truncated events, wrapped/case-sensitive arguments, actual fake-child normal/timeout/kill/exception cleanup, signal-exit races, missing/drifted snapshots, exact command/environment bindings and refusal to overwrite an existing capture.
Initial validation/review exposed missing-snapshot booleans, false == 0 exit comparison, inconsistent selected environment, nested duplicate JSON keys and missing installation-identity validation when scoring a resealed capture; all now refuse success with regression coverage. A mock's one-shot exception caused a test-only StopIteration and was corrected to model the repeatable process-disappearance race. Final code review has no blocking finding and staged whitespace checks pass. All seven roadmap tests pass; the ledger retains 249 tasks and 46 accepted evidence records without state or dependency changes.
The existing real headless record at /home/hermes/qiongli-codex-continuity-yqk33pu3/agy-session-1jd6tkog/events.jsonl is replayed read-only, SHA-256 31214c12927530d5746ed5976f18558640565570d1b09daffc1e44c1106f9b46. It reports Host SUCCESS and num_turns: 1, but its response is empty, one action is denied, and the matching MCP step has no output. The adapter retains those facts and refuses a pass. Earlier file-read steps also mean this historical session is not the new exactly-one-tool status scope. No historical observation or failed attempt is promoted into a live success.
Installed agy --help and the official headless documentation confirm the structured-output interface, not that the local Host exposes the required full MCP envelope. This turn runs no new model/Host session, permission or login change, native build, installation or publication. The live slice-1 exit gate remains open: a normally authorized actual status invocation must provide complete output and clean shutdown on the named installed candidate. If only a summary is available, retain that capability gap without broadening permission or substituting another result. Independent preparation of the fresh installed-Codex three-case baseline can proceed; its earlier three-call login reuse grant remains exhausted. Save/restart, held-out and upgrade qualification remain later increments. CLI-409 owns this progress; task states, dependencies and accepted evidence remain unchanged.
October 5 — fresh installed-Codex candidate and frozen inputs
The next bounded increment prepares the corrected three-case baseline without starting another model observation. Commit 8618fb44 refreshes only the embedded content lock through the existing native generator. The package still reports 2.3.0: this is a development candidate, not a version bump or release.
| Identity | Exact observation |
|---|---|
| Native source | 8618fb44ee43ccc2b9b1380039fb45f0745d8ee2 |
| Content source | 7bbcb171914a9515e14372e7d69d76b9a2255d80 |
| CLI SHA-256 | cbd45851208c0ccb2afe3d9157f2dea139a347c8b18992041415fea6a6cd88cc |
| Embedded pack SHA-256 | caecff2f211cf7174dfb16ed064dd2329ab6589ef55325e24174ee910e9a126c |
| Installed Plugin receipt SHA-256 | f8c64fbe38315f442b369f0cc5e10875b7959d1afcbbefe4401808ec209bbc04 |
| Frozen input manifest SHA-256 | 01b799b2e56b7e585847a6c4228bcd3b18ff0f89ba8fc75fa3f3771ed07060b5 |
The requested gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier regenerates the 446-entry pack and passes the closest lock round-trip/source-drift test. The CLI-only build uses Rust 1.97.0, --profile test --locked --offline, and the exact native source stamp; it finishes in 210 seconds. Native snapshot confirms that stamp. No Desktop, retained Lite package, target-platform distribution or release gate is run. Build logs and the build receipt remain under /tmp/qiongli-codex-quality-next-9rubrmze.
The existing preview/apply owner exports a new Plugin, and Codex 0.160.0's official manager installs/enables qiongli@quality-next under the isolated root /home/hermes/qiongli-codex-quality-next-9rubrmze. Its export, marketplace copy and installed cache match all 468 receipt-listed file bytes and modes; the binary and receipt match too. Lite 15 / Full 35 discovery is directly checked without a model. The three modified workflow/reference files match canonical bytes. The installed root Skill matches the complete native projection: canonical Skill plus the existing Codex adapter and shared Host guidance.
Public fixtures are completed before freezing or any model call. New project prj_0d75b7cffdc8f871ab0f5afe56d6a624 reaches revision 4 through the existing capture intake, exact consolidation preview, model review, dual approval and CAS owners. Its note explicitly labels the reused historical answer; neither that answer nor its old Skill-read failure is a new model result. The original public source packet is unchanged. Only the separately labelled synthetic packet receives the deliberate changed-source marker. Two current documents read back byte-for-byte; changed-source and stale-revision reads refuse, with project/config bytes preserved throughout those negative checks.
The new catalog, installation identity, source registry/packet, complete installed guidance, three prompts, prepared-state/run-scope records and three reviewed local scripts form 16 frozen input files. The paragraph prompt declares the exact whole-answer 250–350 counting rule. Known installed guidance paths are supplied for explicit supported file reads; this does not test automatic Skill discovery. The continuation prompt supplies the new project ID but no current revision, document path/hash or saved body. It permits guidance-file reads while requiring research-document recovery through the native read-only MCP tools. All three cases remain unattempted; there is no final capture manifest, answer, usage measurement or new academic pass.
The temporary driver reuses the tested process-group cleanup owner, keeps full on-disk events/stderr and process/preservation receipts, refuses retries or input and cache drift, and leaves missing guidance evidence unsuccessful. A spawn failure retains a null actual exit code and its process receipt; the existing scorer marks that case unavailable rather than inventing a timeout. These three scripts pass syntax checks and independent static review; the driver has not been exercised with a real model in this increment.
Preparation failures remain in the local logs: an initial check incorrectly compared the projected root Skill to canonical bytes alone; a reused variable reported a byte count instead of 468 cache entries; serializing a Path interrupted the first source-preview binding record after native preview. The checks and metadata are corrected without repeating installation or applied transactions; the original outputs and partial binding are retained. The unsafe shared /tmp ancestor was identified during review before installation, so durable native outputs use a new private home directory under existing path policy.
No authentication file is read, copied or linked, no model is called, and the real user installation/model/configuration is unchanged. The earlier three-call login grant remains exhausted. The next live batch, if newly authorized, is exactly these three public-material cases on gpt-6.1-sol / low, once each and at most 180 seconds per case, with only the three named native read tools approved in the isolated invocation. Temporary login linking and cleanup require that new grant. Preserve the prepared inputs until the decision; failure or unavailable guidance remains in the fixed denominator. The AGY full-output/clean shutdown gate and the later save/restart, held-out and upgrade gates stay open.
At integration, the same verifier independently checks every frozen input, current fixture/config snapshot, exact current-document readback and retained negative result, and confirms the old 24-file capture is unchanged. Seven program-roadmap tests, index consistency and whitespace checks pass. All 249 task IDs/states/dependencies and 46 complete accepted records remain unchanged; only CLI-405's progress text changes. Independent diff review has no blocking finding. These local checks do not promote installation, academic or release acceptance.
October 5 — authorized Codex observations and Host blockers
The maintainer's new temporary-login grant covers the prepared three public cases, once each, at most 180 seconds each on gpt-6.1-sol / low. All three calls are now used; there is no retry or remaining model-call authority in this batch. Codex uses a temporary authentication symlink in the isolated profile. Both wrapper attempts remove it in cleanup; the coordinator and the same lightweight verifier independently confirm the authentication path is absent. The driver and verifier do not inspect, copy or record credential contents. User configuration and all prepared project/configuration snapshots remain unchanged.
The original frozen driver fails before any model call: its preflight passes a UTF-8 string to a bytes-only SHA helper. Preserve that failure and the original captures directory. A new captures-driverfix-1 uses the existing text-hash owner, with unchanged source, prompts, catalog, installation and fixture inputs. Its correction receipt binds the predecessor freeze and zero prior model attempts. The verifier reproduces the original TypeError and exercises the full corrected preflight/capture/seal/load path offline with three fake process results. This includes all 468 installed entries and modes, script hashes and fixture snapshots; no authentication or model is used by that smoke check. The deliberately absent fake guidance is not counted as a pass.
Evidence remains under /home/hermes/qiongli-codex-quality-next-9rubrmze:
| Record | SHA-256 |
|---|---|
Corrected 17-file input freeze, captures-driverfix-1/frozen-inputs.json | e1ceec150bed75812a1cdf02b3abbb506dfa0d15168e92ce9bdfdd1865c5627a |
Sealed 42-file capture, captures-driverfix-1/manifest.json | ed52402a78033107ea3bcaf0e08ee99205bbaddec12069e9e2118c3c4e3a428b |
Complete answer review, review-completed.json | 634cacc8faec58271594e525c0ec54cf082e8996f47762560e857f8e6896388f |
Score, offline-score-driverfix-1/summary.json | 8e1e669ea2571843229d730608d2851ea4283d0f2206ba968dd86c393e0b4288 |
The candidate retains the exact source, binary, pack and receipt identities in the preceding section. The initial unreviewed answer record is retained beside the completed review. Reviewer identity is explicitly the requested model verifier, not a human reviewer. Raw events, answers, complete matched call/error payloads, invocation arguments, process outcomes and preservation receipts are bound by the final manifest. Authentication lifecycle receipts remain in logs.
| Case | Structural / complete reviewed | Observed result |
|---|---|---|
| Paper explanation | fail / fail | Main research claims, units and limitations pass source review; the 265-character recommendation meets its bound. The answer claims 11 supplied anchors where there are 10, and no complete guidance-load evidence is captured. |
| Source paragraph | fail / fail | Returns only a 153-character failure explanation, not the required 250–350-character research paragraph. Required claims and guidance evidence are absent. |
| Saved continuation | fail / fail | One matched qiongli_project_read call fails with MCP tool call requires approval, but approval policy is never; no bindings or document bodies are recovered. The answer discloses this and does not substitute the historical note. |
Structural and complete reviewed totals are 0/3, retaining all three cases. The two undelivered tasks do not receive substantive source-fidelity passes. Actual Host usage and driver elapsed time are:
| Case | Input tokens | Cached input | Output tokens | Reasoning output | Tool calls | Seconds |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paper explanation | 36,301 | 24,576 | 1,837 | 93 | 0 | 56.46 |
| Source paragraph | 35,861 | 29,952 | 294 | 47 | 0 | 14.20 |
| Saved continuation | 66,848 | 39,936 | 790 | 39 | 1 failed | 25.83 |
All processes exit zero normally, with no timeout, parsing error or surviving owned process group. Process completion is separate from task success. These incomplete tasks support no token-efficiency claim. There are no command-read events in the captures. All answers describe a bwrap loopback failure, but those statements are model self-reports, not recorded command results. No supported Host injection record supplies the missing complete guidance either. Known installed paths were supplied, so automatic Skill discovery is untested.
Offline diagnosis uses no model, credential link or changed permission policy. Installed Codex's local help/schema and the official Plugin policy documentation identify per-Plugin/server/tool configuration as the existing policy owner. The actual invocation's quoted dotted keys are a possible explanation for the observed read-tool denial, not a confirmed parser defect or effective-policy readback. Both quoted and unquoted app-server probes stop before config/read, reporting that the Linux sandbox needs access to create user namespaces. Separate codex sandbox attempts stop at permission-profile configuration validation; /usr/bin/true never executes. These diagnostic logs establish those startup limits, not a successful command-level reproduction of the model's error. No sandbox restriction is weakened and no speculative product fix is made.
The next bounded increment must establish Host execution prerequisites before another authenticated observation: demonstrate a real read-only command in a supported sandbox and inspect the effective policy for exactly the three native read tools through the supported configuration owner. Exercise that preflight before freezing a new batch; failure must stop before model invocation. Only then request a newly scoped live batch and capture actual guidance use and successful recovery. Preserve this failed batch and review the anchor-count defect without treating undelivered tasks as evidence of a guidance regression. The AGY full-output/clean-shutdown, save/restart, held-out and upgrade/release gates remain open. CLI-405 owns this record; no task state, dependency or accepted evidence is promoted, and no push, publication or release monitoring occurs.
At integration, the same verifier passes all seven program-roadmap tests, generated-index consistency, whitespace and the fast native boundary check. All 249 task IDs/states/dependencies and 46 complete accepted records match 4a59da78; only CLI-405's blocker changes. Independent review verifies the original and corrected freezes, the old 24-file capture, the new 42-file seal, current fixture preservation and login cleanup. The final diff has no blocking finding; these checks validate the evidence record, not the failed live tasks.
October 5 — 2.4 candidate implementation and prerequisites
The maintainer now requests continued development through 2.4.0 release readiness. 13548357 adds a credential-free Codex sandbox preflight under the existing journey/process owner and explicit package predecessor qualification. The preflight creates a separate empty home, disables network, grants only read access to selected public guidance, compares complete output and stops at the first failure. Version, process cleanup, unchanged guidance/configuration and absence of authentication are recorded. It cannot satisfy effective Plugin policy or actual model-guidance evidence and launches no model.
The upgrade owner preserves historical defaults and adds --predecessor-version 2.3.0, using the shared SemVer/PEP 440 projections. It binds selected versions and predecessor/candidate hashes, refuses ambiguous or changed inputs before installation, and retains non-success receipts when a predecessor is unavailable, metadata is wrong or retained fixture bytes change. The four-target workflow adds a separate 2.3.0 check and uploads failure receipts. Review catches and repairs an overbroad duplicate-suffix refusal: multiple Cargo archives remain valid while multiple wheels/npm candidates are ambiguous.
Canonical version/content commit e4b0565992aa259017e7240d7952e6c77272220b sets 2.4.0 through sync_versions.py, adds checked source-coverage guidance, candidate release notes and bilingual development Host matrices. Historical accepted matrices remain unchanged. The generated 446-entry pack binds that content source, content-root hash 51a12b8595402b025bb853f33cf9aee7ab99fbdca3a63b1258c0a3e797f7caec and pack hash 2693f17ff7bd1aeea4576aeecb0554f9c6a22003e49bb3decfb0db909473315f. The candidate is unpublished; these changes do not turn the earlier 0/3 result into a pass.
The same gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier passes 70 focused tests: 11 upgrade, 8 sandbox-preflight, 14 registry/package assets, 20 branch/workflow, 16 version and one native content-lock/source-drift test. Capability validation, the actual v2.4.0 tag/version contract and native formatting pass. Initial missing release notes and stale pack failures are retained, then resolved through their canonical owners; only affected checks are rerun. Fake executable tests exercise actual process execution, failure-stop behavior, content/config drift, isolated environment and timeout/forced-cleanup cases. They establish no live Host pass.
The real no-login preflight at /tmp/qiongli-codex-preflight-real-zu4epp9i/result/preflight.json passes version inspection, then stops at the sandbox command with bwrap: loopback: Failed RTM_NEWADDR: Operation not permitted. Guidance reads never start and authentication remains absent. Earlier direct diagnostics at /tmp/qiongli-codex-readonly-prereq-o2_fjyze also use a valid named permission profile and independently reproduce the failure; effective policy remains unavailable. No old model self-report is retroactively relabelled a tool event.
For package qualification, the previous container's missing crun runtime state prevents exec; an attempted new runroot also conflicts with the existing storage database. Both are retained failures, not reasons to reset old state. A new ordinary rootless container using the established storage/runroot pair successfully reports glibc 2.35, without extra capabilities or credential mounts (/tmp/ql24-podman-paired-o9g_6hex/receipt.json). A separate candidate environment can therefore be prepared while preserving all 2.3.0 artifacts. This probe alone is not a release build, package audit or Codex sandbox pass.
Next qualify the clean 2.4.0 candidate with the existing release owner and the explicit 2.3.0 upgrade check. Separately establish actual Codex sandbox/policy prerequisites before preparing a newly authorized live batch. Installed-Codex regression, save/restart/held-out cases, AGY full-output/clean shutdown and final four-target qualification remain required. No previous credential grant is extended and no remote synchronization or publication is performed.
At integration, seven additional roadmap tests, generated-index consistency, whitespace and the native boundary guard pass. The final independent diff review has no blocking finding. All 249 task IDs/states/dependencies and 46 complete accepted records match the prior 2.x; only CLI-405/410 blocker text changes. The 77 focused test passes qualify these local changes, not the open live Host or release-artifact gates. Subsequent package evidence must bind its own clean native source, separate from the content-source identity above.
Exact runtime access correction
A separate rootless-container probe finds the bundled sandbox helper only when the complete public Codex installation is mounted read-only; mounting its bin directory alone had omitted that helper. The next probe then reports the exact Codex executable unavailable inside the minimal sandbox. The preflight now grants read access to that resolved runtime file as well as the selected public guidance. It does not expose the executable's parent directory, alter network policy or add write permission. Nine focused preflight tests and the boundary guard pass, including an independent parsed-TOML assertion of the exact allowed files. A later standalone nested probe times out before providing successful command evidence; this correction is not declared a live sandbox or policy pass.
Local package qualification starts separately on clean native source 84bc10791e8ee933ccfcba579b20c2976a9bea0d. Its results must keep that identity despite this subsequent observation-helper correction. Large tooling-image copies are stopped without promoting their incomplete output. A separate container uses the existing public tooling rootfs as a read-only overlay lower; new source/output mounts preserve the old release. The repository's disposable Rust incremental intermediates are cleared to restore build space; source, target executables, archived releases, logs and research data are retained.
October 5 — local 2.4 package qualification
The same gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier runs the existing release owner on clean native source 84bc10791e8ee933ccfcba579b20c2976a9bea0d, in the separate Ubuntu 22.04 rootless overlay described above. This is Linux ARM64 evidence, not four-target or final-head qualification. The later 025fe931 correction changes observation tooling/tests and records; it does not change these native or content bytes, and the receipts keep their original source identity.
The successful command is:
./scripts/release_ready.sh --cli-github --version 2.4.0 \
--staging-dir /tmp/qiongli-2.4-delivery-20261005/linux-arm64-glibc235It exits zero with 46 CLI and nine MCP tests, strict headless Clippy, formatting, version checks, glibc 2.35 wheel audit/repair, empty-PATH archive smoke checks, isolated npm/wheel installs and aliases. Lite/Full discovery remains 15/35. Codex/Claude native Plugin archives pass their package checks, and the npm DeepSeek projection retains 22 Skill entries and 35 MCP tools. These checks do not run those Hosts' model sessions. The packaged native binary SHA-256 is 604b55828e612d621d8e3efee19ea6efa983b5e24c531dd4d8e9c1eb1da4393a; content source remains e4b05659 and pack 2693f17f as bound above.
Evidence under /tmp/qiongli-2.4-delivery-20261005:
| Record | SHA-256 |
|---|---|
linux-arm64-glibc235/assets/release-manifest.json | 30f25882db0ddf7a9b9fdccffd10c4df4abfa660deb727f9e58321f37c772b59 |
linux-arm64-glibc235/assets/SHA256SUMS | cc21d7aac489ffb68e2938e5d2f5d031e5cfce2f499e327db544f13bac0597ca |
linux-arm64-glibc235/install/install-check.json | dd77e41115377dca02e3b21415d009242c753a66d482c7554c2af0e3902ed376 |
upgrade-2.3.0/registry-upgrade-check.json | 37824177c345ec3cebe32674706ed0cebe3274fcbd85056b0e09c62daf7618d9 |
cargo-source/registry-packages.json | 86824e689b448ac5c383a2573f738f46911da0a4d1571093bef32437a67e3318 |
cargo-install/install-check.json | 2f9946732b52f6c598c42e790697ae6ced1217e240462e19087f8952374272a8 |
The explicit upgrade owner downloads real public pip/npm 2.3.0 packages, verifies the installed predecessor version and upgrades each isolated install to the local 2.4.0 candidate. Both pass native checks and retain all three synthetic research/configuration canaries byte-for-byte. The receipt binds both predecessors and candidate packages; no fallback version is used. This qualifies package replacement and those fixtures, not arbitrary project-format migration.
The archived CLI also performs the native preview/confirmed export into the isolated public directory /home/hermes/qiongli-2.4-qualification-q1xw4df7/packaged-agy-us44741u. Its AGY Plugin has 22 Skill entries; all 467 receipt entries, file bytes and directory/file modes verify. Installation receipt SHA-256 is 2f9b5cb1d16f7009ad69b1af8bc97011a1f2f0abb0ccd9182933583710406459. The exported executable directly completes Full stdio MCP initialization, 35-tool discovery and a matched qiongli_config_status call (ID 3), with full raw output retained. Discovery stdout SHA-256 is da9d75eb4412b369bb67a9d3962541cf6f86ec95e97990a196e89fc215df0974; status-call stdout SHA-256 is e600eaa8471c969ad699e4a026bb21f1f66e5b59cc3bcd77c319cb2b3ac81bd5. Official AGY registration is declined at its separate step. There is no new Host session, authentication reuse, model call or change to the user's profile. This direct native call does not fill the AGY complete-Host-result/clean-shutdown gate; the bilingual development matrix explicitly preserves that distinction.
Earlier container/runtime, rootfs argument-order and interrupted image-copy attempts remain retained failures. The corrected release process is recorded in release-process-corrected.json; no failed attempt or old release output is overwritten or counted as a pass. Cargo source archives/install are recorded by their existing owner: ten archives pass staging and archive validation, then an actual release build/install from those archives passes for both qiongli and ql, with version 2.4.0, invalid-command refusal, Lite 15/Full 35 and the same content-pack digest. The archive compilation takes 6m33s. All five release asset checksums independently verify and the qualification clone remains clean at 84bc1079. Cargo results cover this local target; no registry publication or installation from a published 2.4.0 package is claimed.
Release status remains Not ready. Before another authenticated Codex batch, a supported environment must pass the credential-free sandbox check and expose the effective permissions of exactly the three native read tools. Then obtain a newly scoped login/model grant, freeze the installed candidate and rerun the three required tasks. Save/restart and fresh held-out cases follow their required baseline gate. AGY still needs its bounded complete-result/clean-shutdown and read/recovery observation. The final frozen source also needs the existing four-target distribution and Cargo qualification under separately authorized remote synchronization/CI. No push, tag, publication or announcement occurs.
At integration, the same verifier reports no blocking finding in this six-file record and independently matches all six package receipt hashes above. Seven roadmap tests, generated-index consistency and whitespace checks pass. All 249 task IDs/states/dependencies and 46 complete accepted records match 025fe931; only CLI-409/410 blocker text changes. No unchanged native, package or model checks are rerun merely for the documentation integration.
October 6 — existing login authorized, sandbox prerequisite still blocked
The maintainer explicitly authorizes using the system's existing Codex login for validation. This supersedes the need for a new login grant in the October 5 next-step record. Use an isolated profile and temporary authentication link, without reading, copying or logging credential contents; remove the link after use. The first model batch remains the three public baseline tasks, once each, at most 180 seconds each on gpt-6.1-sol / low. Those operational bounds do not expire the maintainer's authority for the same planned public validation; no repeat login-permission question is needed merely because prerequisites are repaired. Private research, real profile/permission changes, push and publication remain outside this grant.
The same lightweight verifier runs the existing credential-free preflight once from clean 2.x source 9dfad782. Installed Codex remains 0.160.0, executable SHA-256 50b06603bdcdac39b714f5c3e68583c002b8ad8779ebfdaaf4932ff016b379c0. Version inspection passes, but the normal read-only sandbox's /usr/bin/true exits 1 with bwrap: loopback: Failed RTM_NEWADDR: Operation not permitted. Guidance reads and effective Plugin-policy inspection do not run. Both command processes are reaped with their groups gone; guidance and configuration remain unchanged and the isolated authentication path is absent. Zero model calls or authentication links are made. This is a prerequisite failure, not a new failed three-case model batch and not an authentication failure.
Complete commands, stdout/stderr and cleanup are retained at /tmp/qiongli-codex-oct6-preflight-14u3ong_/result/preflight.json, SHA-256 40e26f4b40a80b02600264215590e849e524ced5656edfed573fd5ba5b50c8af. Sibling kernel-clues.json records read-only environment clues, including AppArmor user-namespace restriction enabled and the inspecting process's zero Seccomp/NoNewPrivs flags. These do not establish the cause of the loopback denial. An initial log-read helper used the wrong stderr filename; the verifier then reads the actual stderr.log without rerunning the preflight. All prior evidence is retained and no policy, sysctl or permission is changed.
The next action is a supported Codex sandbox environment or administrator diagnosis of the current execution denial, followed by effective tool-policy readback and the already authorized public batch. Release remains Not ready; earlier Linux ARM64 package evidence and the remaining AGY, save/restart, held-out and final-source four-target gates retain their scope.
At integration, the same verifier finds no blocking issue in this four-file record, matches the new receipt hash and passes seven roadmap tests, index consistency and whitespace checks. All 249 task IDs/states/dependencies and 46 complete accepted records match 9dfad782; only CLI-405 blocker/date changes. No preflight, native package or model check is repeated for this record.
October 6 — repaired sandbox and installed-Codex baseline
After the maintainer repairs the system environment, Codex 0.160.1 passes the credential-free read-only prerequisite and complete public guidance reads. Its executable SHA-256 is fbbaec80443919f86dd63648a0b62759cf6f1d0e09310602fde96885e0bceb3e. This observes a working environment; it does not establish which administrator change or the simultaneous Host upgrade resolved the old 0.160.0 failure. No agent changes system security. The first fresh preflight is retained at /home/hermes/qiongli-codex-repaired-preflight-h8hn_puw/result/preflight.json.
All three cohorts below use official isolated qiongli@quality-24 installation, verified 468-entry native exports/caches, Lite 15 / Full 35, the same ten public source anchors and the same fixed catalog. Each task runs once per cohort with gpt-6.1-sol / low, at most 180 seconds. The effective TOML is read back before execution, including the model-bound configuration: only project read, document list and document read receive explicit approval, the named filesystem profile is read-only, and its command network is disabled. Each cohort independently passes credential-free command/guidance checks and a mocked capture/seal before its temporary authentication link is created. The link is removed in finally; the driver and verifier never inspect, copy or log credential contents. Every actual model process exits normally, its owned group is gone, complete guidance reads are bound to successful command output, and project/configuration bytes are preserved.
| Cohort / external directory | Native source / content source | Structural / reviewed | Retained finding |
|---|---|---|---|
B: /home/hermes/qiongli-codex-24-public-039cxrz1 | 84bc1079 / e4b05659 | 3/3 / 2/3 | Paragraph adds within-year standardization not specified by the source. Paper explanation honestly reports a failed optional read after guessing the assessor's directory. |
C: /home/hermes/qiongli-codex-24-guidance-_pl2zzbr | b8bc6175 / 8889fe73 | 3/3 / 2/3 | Paragraph and Skill paths are corrected. The paper handoff incorrectly claims eleven unique source anchors instead of ten. |
D: /home/hermes/qiongli-codex-24-coverage-n_qq8vl1 | 85758cac / f26ee4a5 | 3/3 / 3/3 | Complete answer review passes all declared checks; prior failures remain unchanged. |
8889fe73 gives paper reading the correct installed-root paths for extraction and critical appraisal. The shared writing contract now preserves the source's methodological resolution: a familiar transformation does not establish its unreported grouping, parameters or implementation. f26ee4a5 changes the reading handoff default to identified read/unavailable scope; numerical coverage is only included when requested and derived from enumerated unique sources. Neither change embeds the regression answer. The first change passes 33 affected contract/resource checks, the capability validator and exact portable projection; the subsequent reading-only change passes seven affected checks and exact projection. Unchanged writing/capability checks are reused.
The existing generator creates each 446-entry lock after its canonical content commit. The final local Host candidate is:
| Identity | Value |
|---|---|
| Native source | 85758cac79dc1b5248099fe9194529fd789a75df |
| Content source | f26ee4a591a7fc449b5352540ff226117ce2042e |
| CLI SHA-256 | 2aa5079d4b11464dc8e0df093642cc16707413f7f95090475eb050ec82dd3898 |
| Content pack SHA-256 | 1d84ed12b46eb7153f3ff38b440950e524e4e6834e625cc173acc049cc814397 |
| Plugin receipt SHA-256 | cc3bfb8c36d66d2b73cd3e07bdcaf48c0621c47f5f7635c54dfb660c18245ee9 |
| D frozen inputs SHA-256 | ba8867e1efc6a299de19d402254012058d4c48bbd04d4a627beaf702ca4cdf58 |
C and D use pinned Rust 1.97, locked/offline CLI-only test profile builds for Host observation. They do not inherit the earlier 84bc1079 glibc 2.35 release qualification. An initial C build command mistakenly requested a nonexistent cli feature and exited 101 before building; the corrected no-default-features command succeeds. The original command error remains in the build handoff. No unchanged release suite is rerun for these scoped content fixes.
Each directory retains captures/manifest.json, review-completed.json and offline-score/summary.json, respectively bound by:
| Cohort | Sealed manifest | Complete review | Score summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| B | c21e587733e7ca424378efb3a627e1e588a1041d0eb349659a0c037d19498611 | d5b8445c0e2912d350b733b13ddcd677341e337646934df409c7890ad6a1245c | 6e14d41f1ff8ffa41907f3a0078333ed9ec630a6fa5ed921bf2f76ffb8c53a68 |
| C | 2592f3c44a3c943d733096936e43ff97b9ac2fa50a2e3c17ce79faf83cb4d826 | b0770092204e479c2eb79691a8eb74e6cf5701eae04b27cb617962dd073f233f | 4bb35496421b076e06d00ed2b166d2bd86504bd0a8b34baa5baea8c5acfe65d3 |
| D | 1267f28d39e6a922c5ed0b901cf2867c97205613ffd036f5c3fd2d02d9622d98 | 84046abfb0f1825fb76925ba23d3528811549e40d00e1edfcb64ab1224e9f656 | b79465780b623026a1150b448c0da9070bc45d9e83d8c22d592abcc546acef71 |
The same lightweight verifier reviews every substantive answer span against supplied sources. D's recommendation is 277 characters and direct paragraph 266 under their declared rules. Its saved continuation makes four actual native calls, recovers revision 4 and reads the two current bodies (7,117 and 10,308 bytes) exactly; the synthetic changed packet has no usable read arguments and is skipped. Preparation independently rejects changed bindings and stale revision reads without altering fixtures. This uses a prepared historical note, not a new model-note save/restart journey or complete B2 reading.
| D task | Seconds | Input / cached / output tokens | Completed calls / failed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paper explanation | 72.646006 | 70,353 / 49,280 / 2,454 | 7 / 0 |
| Source paragraph | 36.852149 | 112,830 / 81,664 / 1,267 | 2 / 0 |
| Saved continuation | 57.455549 | 188,244 / 149,248 / 1,859 | 7 / 0 |
Original B/C metrics remain in their score reports. B first permits pure in-memory paragraph counting; D generalizes this to checking supplied material and delivered text without additional file reads, writes or network. This is an operational prompt correction, not a demonstrated cause of C's counting error. The changed content, prompt, Host and candidate identities prevent a controlled performance comparison. Supplied installed guidance paths make this a bounded usage regression, not an automatic Skill-discovery qualification.
Slice 2's fixed installed-Codex regression exit is now observed for D. Next use a newly reviewed actual answer for the separate native save/restart journey, then run the three fresh synthetic cases whose source/request/reviewer criteria are frozen at /tmp/qiongli24-heldout-materials-7ji7r5dq (material manifest SHA-256 651a95679468a0e0f9af0153a58346c56d6fd294f388f4397c364a8b257e0c77). Their cases have not run or supplied guidance-tuning evidence. Final fixture, installation and prompt bindings must be frozen before those observations. AGY complete-output/clean-shutdown/read-recovery and final-source four-target package/Cargo qualification remain open. Release remains Not ready. No push, tag, publication, real profile/model change or acceptance promotion occurs.
At integration, the same verifier matches all nine cohort manifest/review/score hashes and confirms each authentication link is absent. Seven roadmap tests, generated-index consistency and whitespace checks pass. All 249 task identities, states and dependencies, 46 complete accepted records and all existing evidence fields remain unchanged from 2.x; only CLI-405/410 blocker text and CLI-410's date change. No unchanged native, package or model checks are rerun for this documentation integration.
October 6 — new-note persistence and fresh synthetic cases
The unchanged installed-Host candidate 85758cac / content f26ee4a5 / pack 1d84ed12 now passes the separate save/restart journey and three previously unobserved synthetic cases. These reuse the installed-Codex regression's exact CLI bytes, official installation owner, read-only policy, Codex 0.160.1 and gpt-6.1-sol / low. Each model case runs once, for at most 180 seconds; no result, criterion or fixture is changed to obtain a pass. Complete guidance reads, normal process completion, group cleanup, preserved project/configuration bytes and temporary authentication-link removal are verified for all four cases.
Actual reviewed answer saved and recovered
/home/hermes/qiongli24-new-note-restart-lusj0r5h retains a new isolated project, prj_06f5b05814e4b3d0bd0de361d3fa8e43. Reviewed native transactions save the independently reviewed actual D paper-explanation answer verbatim, with its answer/review/manifest provenance, through source capture, exact preview, academic review, approval and revision/CAS. This is an actual answer save, not a claim that the read-only model performed the write. Source and note saves advance the new project to revision 3. Missing-approval attempts for both writes are refused without mutation; temporarily missing source bytes cause read and note-preview refusal, then are restored exactly before a fresh approved preview. Stale revision-2 reads are refused. The original D fixtures remain unchanged.
A fresh session receives only the project ID and installed guidance locations, with no research paths, hashes, revision or body snapshots. Seven successful native calls obtain project/list/read results, including complete byte-matched 8,450-byte note and 10,308-byte packet bodies; duplicate reads remain in the metrics. Three guidance command calls bring the total to ten, with zero failed calls. The 44.230030-second run reports 263,669 input, 197,760 cached and 1,401 output tokens. Its 256-character paragraph passes the declared 250–350 rule and all six independently reviewed answer spans. Structural and reviewed results are both 1/1 through the existing trace/span and Evaluation Truth V1 owners.
Two offline verification mistakes remain retained: an initial helper expected blocked JSON instead of the actual missing-source preview's exit 1; another incorrectly required optional MCP structuredContent despite complete JSON in content. Only the helpers were corrected; no model case was repeated and the source-restoration finally block preserved the original bytes.
Three frozen synthetic cases
/home/hermes/qiongli24-heldout-8os90b1t binds the source/request/reviewer criteria previously frozen at material digest 651a9567, with 35 final input files plus the freeze record and 60 sealed files. Reviewer criteria and the changed-source replacement are withheld from the model. Before final preview/save/freeze, the coordinator removes an extra recovery instruction from the synthetic historical note; the saved note contains provenance, findings and limits. No material or criterion changes during or after the actual batch. The initial preparation's external-file sandbox refusal is retained and corrected using the authorized external write; it is not a model retry.
| Case | Reviewed behavior | Seconds | Input / cached / output tokens | Calls / failed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ShiftBreak2026, abstract only | Preserves 46 volunteers, three workplaces and eight days of observational self-reports; does not infer causal support for a fixed-break policy. | 31.339207 | 61,231 / 44,416 / 963 | 4 / 0 |
| CyclePilot2026, conflicting units | The 314-character paragraph distinguishes six randomized machines from 120 cycles and 58 + 60 valid records; retains −4.2 seconds versus 4.2% as unresolved, with unknown precision. | 31.294074 | 77,549 / 64,384 / 879 | 2 / 0 |
| StreetShade2026, changed source | Three native calls recover revision 3, bindings and the complete current 1,300-byte note. The changed source has no usable read arguments and is not read; 2.5°C is explicitly historical, while the unseen 0.7°C replacement is not adopted. | 38.425721 | 177,246 / 147,968 / 1,066 | 6 / 0 |
Structural and complete independent answer-review results are both 3/3. After saving the original source and note, preparation deliberately replaces only the synthetic packet before freezing the observation. Changed-source and stale- revision refusal checks cause no further mutation. This is one frozen synthetic cohort, not expert, full-paper or cross-discipline acceptance. Having been observed, these cases are now regressions; replaying them cannot establish another fresh held-out result. Supplied installed guidance locations still do not establish automatic discovery. No efficiency comparison against earlier differing tasks is claimed.
Evidence and remaining release scope
Each root retains its complete evidence-summary.json, including exact file paths, source identities, native negative receipts, traces, reviews and metrics. The summaries and principal records are bound here:
| Record | New-note save/restart SHA-256 | Held-out SHA-256 |
|---|---|---|
| Evidence summary | 2e707d399e5607e4a3eba275e16a6125204d83cb2cf2319c46f7707f21e26532 | 8bdfb1766c62df1dd2675d48755fa3be292a1391fd1d8236363924f31b5e74de |
| Frozen inputs | 1473439e30f4372969bf071ff1422baaf5b4bba74005a0a83815880a707b3477 | f9b2af5a1ba9d62c2a335718c9c1c7425f21fc6d204e4f257c5b1879eadb4480 |
| Sealed manifest | 5e10641a49a587112d0cf908e95fd66101e7891daa477f9431994ac23558a8cc | f5512235cdda9f40d1ab508a7bb196179a7fe0f5378a00d6d9c127043f4b3ff3 |
| Complete review | c7ff475e219ff3f9d310550db6f753ed8f71ae8a33ef616358c9e1c1b514d9f7 | 4de0fff3a7463a817e58143c0814e6351226e697ea0a97ddee8193faf8f6b847 |
| Score summary | ca9c70b9b6d1bcc857dfd2d449443db2501d196d42e274a9e6fe4de0bfbd65c7 | 69a400fba86c51527fde601092d27522596cf8fea94ef96d805a223cad5bc8c6 |
| Authentication lifecycle | b92a24e7e40a1c82c1bb722d9eb85b47b4ddcbac8ef989c68c18839507cb6a9f | 8ff5675987987fff457d7dd1bc286488d5c9f75a7acd8054750eb1554d180c72 |
Slice 3's scoped Codex save/restart and held-out exit is now observed. Next close AGY's actual complete-result/clean-shutdown status call and bounded read/recovery, and qualify final-source local artifacts before separately authorized four-target remote distribution/Cargo checks. Older 84bc1079 release artifacts retain their original scope; these test-profile observations do not qualify new packages. Release remains Not ready. No push, publication, real profile/model change, new task state or accepted-evidence promotion occurs.
At integration, the same verifier passes seven roadmap tests, generated-index consistency and whitespace checks, matches all twelve principal hashes above and all 32 files referenced by the two evidence summaries, and confirms both auth links are absent. All 249 task IDs/states/dependencies, 46 complete accepted records and 76 nonempty evidence fields match 2.x; only CLI-405/410 blocker text changes. Final review clarifies the deliberate pre-freeze synthetic source replacement and the native transaction actor. Unchanged native, content, package and model checks are reused; this documentation integration adds no acceptance.
October 6 — current-content local packages and AGY 1.3.0
After local integration, a separate clean 2.x clone at native source c2cae7360667ba722d41f2ca2adb8647fbda8090 qualifies Linux ARM64 in the existing rootless glibc 2.35 environment. It binds canonical content f26ee4a5 and pack 1d84ed12, rather than inheriting the earlier 84bc1079 results. No credential mount, extra container privilege, remote synchronization or publication is used. The source clone is /home/hermes/qiongli24-final-source-6l3po_h5/source and new output root /tmp/qiongli24-final-delivery-meywqu48; the old artifacts remain.
The existing release owner passes formatting, strict Clippy, 46 CLI + 9 MCP tests, archive smoke, glibc/wheel checks and actual npm/wheel installs. The 494.638661-second successful process produces five assets whose actual sizes and SHA-256 values all match the manifest. Codex/Claude archives and the npm DeepSeek projection pass, with 22 DeepSeek Skills and 35 Full tools. The archived CLI SHA-256 is 548909b6649291b0e7f28e155a4271d77dfdb9b77bee4e33e1ef0026d0d0bc57; Lite 15 / Full 35 and the current content-pack digest match across installations.
The separate 470.796946-second follow-up passes actual public pip/npm 2.3.0 upgrades without fallback and retains the synthetic canaries through the existing owner. Ten Cargo source archives validate, then actual installation from those archives passes both qiongli and ql, version, invalid-command refusal and MCP/ content checks. The source clone remains clean. These are local target results, not a published-package install or four-target qualification.
Preparation retains the initial insecure /tmp source-location diagnosis and new clone's inherited group-writable directories; no tests start in either condition. Only newly owned real clone directories have group/world write bits removed, without changing tracked bytes or Git file modes. The first owner run then correctly refuses a detached clone before tests/builds. A local 2.x branch at the same frozen source satisfies that existing guard; no guard or source is changed. Its failed receipt remains separate from the successful run.
AGY package transport and actual Host are separate
The archived CLI exports 22 AGY Skill entries into the new isolated /home/hermes/qiongli24-packaged-agy-t6446ljm fixture. Exported executable bytes match the archive; Full stdio discovery returns 35 tools and a matched ID-3 qiongli_config_status call succeeds with complete raw native output. Official Host registration is deliberately declined at its separate confirmation. This qualifies package/native transport, not an AGY model session.
Separately, /home/hermes/qiongli24-agy-next-nhow8box retains an actual isolated AGY 1.3.0 installation of the unchanged Host-test candidate 85758cac / CLI 2aa5079d. The Host executable SHA-256 is b3df69538e3de96f341c2bd12e5354954ecfb94aa93dabc79f695bc05b386302. Native source export and the official plugin install / enable qiongli each receive their own reviewed confirmation. Installation completes normally in 225.527519 seconds; source/cache bytes, allowed modes, receipt identity and registration/enablement match. The Plugin receipt SHA-256 is 20b9a48f8fcfe92fc46dad4dc5d7e76ac21024ab9669f259c6070afa36f46e9f. The initial invalid source-leaf refusal and canceled valid preview remain. A reused temporary PTY receipt misleadingly names a field cancelled_first_write_confirmation; its raw log records both actual approvals. The packaged-export log instead records source approval then registration denial. These retained labels do not override the actual command/confirmation evidence.
Before one status observation, the isolated settings allow only mcp(qiongli_qiongli/qiongli_config_status) and deny model shell/browser/direct file-read/write actions. Only the new public workspace is trusted. Registered MCP configuration has no environment override; the observer selects the isolated Qiongli configuration/workspace for any native child. The authentication failure does not establish that the Host actually started such a child. AGY's rule does not restrict tool arguments; the existing observer fixes and matches the exact cwd instead. The complete capture/score path is mocked offline before execution. The live invocation uses plan mode, sandbox, low effort and at most 180 seconds, with no model override or permission bypass. Credential files are never inspected, linked, copied or logged; only the official Host may use its normal login flow.
The isolated Host does not obtain silent login. It reports authentication required, waits through its normal 60-second login timeout, then exits 1 after 60.787555 seconds. It reports zero model turns/usage and makes zero MCP calls. The V1 score correctly fails the required Host/result gate; the process is reaped, its group is gone and workspace/Qiongli configuration/settings snapshots match. No login URL is opened, fallback login performed or model attempt repeated. The maintained temporary profile is available for the user's normal interactive login; any subsequent login or observation has its own new evidence. This is a missing authentication prerequisite, not an observed MCP implementation failure.
Evidence and next action
The local output's evidence-summary.json binds all thirteen principal records, all five assets, exact source identities, durations and preserved failures. Its SHA-256 is cea37483179bdcbe792e9468cbb615fdd69f9640568c42e9b55beacadc8e9253. Selected underlying records are:
| Record | SHA-256 |
|---|---|
linux-arm64-glibc235/assets/release-manifest.json | db12965e781acca505b9ae9a4f8a026692998870a083dbf23c87a41e3a05f9e6 |
upgrade-2.3.0/registry-upgrade-check.json | a772c11a33fe2c2204d4e06a79417e5f8e43d60bae542fb9bf3e0facbab5b2ba |
cargo-source/registry-packages.json | 2cf26e5f71319d440e44152dbaf792c758dc8a99519223b7d839df6868167ce2 |
cargo-install/install-check.json | 211dc8024474a7be4174a74cd8c22e2d0759ac664bb440befedd839cf580a27e |
Packaged AGY logs/native-mcp-receipt.json | 43688ce4dc3f7276569f035df92c29a5ee37c67fc83f3a4db94084f1736340fe |
Isolated AGY installation.json | 6735fa78e7068f38548a2e9c3e12dd89cd556c2b4d9b463b42b500217017ac52 |
Isolated AGY status-capture/manifest.json | 126a243f1b57ac486bde724c6808db84645886cb50c0dfe63696e7b8fcacdec7 |
The bilingual development Host matrix now reflects the current Codex scoped passes, separate AGY install/authentication result and current-content ARM64 package checks; historical accepted matrices remain unchanged. Release remains Not ready pending AGY's authenticated complete-result/normal-completion and bounded recovery observations, plus final-source four-target distribution/Cargo qualification under separate remote authority. No push, tag, publication or acceptance promotion occurs. Unchanged Codex/model/content checks are reused.
At integration, the same lightweight verifier passes seven roadmap tests, generated-index consistency and whitespace checks. It matches the summary, thirteen bound records, seven selected hashes and five assets without accessing the live AGY authentication/settings directory awaiting user login. All 249 task IDs/states/dependencies, 46 complete accepted records and 76 nonempty evidence fields remain unchanged from c2cae736; only CLI-409 progress/date and CLI-410 progress change. Final review distinguishes selected child environment from an actually observed child launch, which this authentication failure cannot prove. No unchanged model, native, package or content check is repeated for integration.
October 6 — authenticated AGY and authorized remote qualification
The maintainer confirms normal login in the retained isolated AGY profile and authorizes remote synchronization, the PR required by existing branch rules, Native CI and four-target CLI/Cargo qualification. This grants no tag, release, publication, announcement, main cutover or remote-rule change. No credential file is inspected, copied, linked or hashed; configured models remain unchanged.
Authenticated status call and capture limitation
On unchanged Host candidate 85758cac, AGY 1.3.0 completes one fresh status call in 12.124649 seconds, exit 0, one turn, no denial and one exact MCP call. The returned native status JSON passes its existing schema. Process reaping, group cleanup and workspace/Qiongli configuration/settings preservation pass. Reported usage is 20,955 input, 12,208 cached, 271 output, zero thinking and 21,226 total tokens. The pre-login failure remains separate and unsuccessful.
AGY exposes the native JSON body as a string in tool_info.output, without the MCP response envelope. The unchanged strict score therefore fails, solely on full_native_result. The exact public session transcript also retains only that body; it is not substituted for wire evidence. Official headless, reference and hook documentation supplies no verified safe full-envelope capture path: final-answer JSON schemas constrain model text, and PostToolUse hooks do not provide the tool result. No generic credential-sensitive logging, injected interception or scoring relaxation is used. A separately scoped projected-body recovery observation can establish read compatibility, but cannot close this strict gate or establish automatic Skill discovery.
The retained root /home/hermes/qiongli24-agy-next-nhow8box binds the new status-after-user-login capture and separate score:
| Record | SHA-256 |
|---|---|
status-after-user-login-evidence.json | 6829a2cd631da0c81587a3b3687aee89436c1a4be02a4cd92ce37a957be2fcf6 |
installation-after-user-login.json | 0593d520db403bb5d689ecad08138ca4d2eece444bfacfa152fa936fc3a80e00 |
status-after-user-login/manifest.json | 99bcffd1ac786a8cc2bf90c2d7d5a30bc0b038b3c12577e320a54f41babd8caf |
status-after-user-login/capture.json | 10e692cdaa82200e4a7ac389b84c6920a33e4ab30a2370a3554e39a2398f5883 |
status-after-user-login/events.jsonl | 60afc25d6bbb48ae6bbc0e3845deeff6b6a81586c2c6ac09d1d8316e8fec729c |
status-after-user-login-score/summary.json | 722c720d5b5d3ef5e557240d9221554b1c9eef7a26eb475eb355adb6728677e9 |
Source synchronization and documentation repair
Remote 2.x at c25fb2c1 is an ancestor of local 8a0403c4, 351 commits behind; 325 already belong to released main at 153cb15d. The actual 2.4 increment contains 26 commits across 57 files. Independent scoped review finds no new source-synchronization blocker. The boundary guard passes, and the new 2.4 diff has no whitespace errors. The cumulative remote diff retains an existing trailing space in the published tables-source.md:87 source fixture; immutable bound evidence is preserved.
The authorized branch sync/qiongli-2.4-qualification-20261006 and PR 183 use the existing protected PR route without force, administrator bypass or ruleset changes. Initial Native CI and Evaluation Truth runs bind 8a0403c4, not a later revision. Final-source platform and archive qualification remains separate from PR checks.
The initial local documentation build fails because the maintainer quality contract links outside VitePress's documentation root. Its existing research journey reference now uses the repository's public 2.x URL. The subsequent build passes in 50.873783 seconds, without changing dead-link enforcement, dependencies or package content. Initial Cloudflare Pages reports only a build failure; its unavailable logs do not establish the same cause.
Preserved recovery failure and platform fixture repairs
The frozen external helper at /tmp/qiongli24-agy-recovery-preparation-r2 preserves the original preparation unchanged and adds atomic settings replacement, compare-before-restore cleanup, failed-inspection sealing and exact executable/imported-helper bindings. Eleven parser cases, a fake-process round trip and three cleanup/error cases pass before one actual 180-second-bounded observation. Its freeze SHA-256 is 698dc6418ed5e0e4224d375b1e43f13a2ec615e466dce7c0bcb471ac8ba1f3cc.
The actual observation fails recovery, despite exit 0 and Host SUCCESS in 48.480980 seconds. Ten tool attempts comprise one successful project read, seven invalid document-list calls and two denied file reads. None of the list calls uses the required expected_project_revision; no document body is read and no requested paragraph is produced. Repeated parameter guesses also violate the stop-on-error instruction. Reported usage is 75,292 input, 137,982 cache-read, 1,327 output and 76,619 total tokens; these Host fields are retained as reported, not treated as a controlled efficiency comparison. Process cleanup, public project/configuration preservation and exact settings restoration pass.
The two denied paths are the Host's public project-read schema and the installed Skill entry. Inspection of the three specifically named generated schemas confirms correct native parameter contracts, including expected_project_revision. The observation policy denied every file read and therefore also denied Host tool-metadata access. This is a harness limitation to address in a separately frozen observation, not evidence of a native parser defect or permission to silently retry the failed case. Original raw events and the failed denominator remain in r2/actual-capture; no credential directory is scanned. The CLI permission contract places deny before ask/allow; an exact schema-read allowance cannot override the original blanket denial. Any corrected observation must freeze its explicit metadata-read permissions and retain direct research-file/write restrictions.
Initial PR Native CI 37474974188 exposes a stale three-Host assertion after AGY adds the fourth selection, plus Windows fixture failures in AGY export and saved-document/retrieval-history tests. The bounded repairs assert the four actual Host identities, create AGY test roots/home through the existing Windows owner-only directory API, and canonicalize newly created temporary project bases before deriving registered paths. Production ownership, canonical-path, ACL, revision and refusal guards remain unchanged. The Windows project-registration log reports UnsafeProjectRoot; canonicalization is the targeted fixture repair, not a claim that the log alone proves its precise underlying Windows condition. Fresh platform execution must qualify these changed test sources.
The same macOS run also reports the stale Host assertion and noncanonical project-fixture refusals, then reaches its 30-minute job deadline while still executing the portable archive tests. The preceding artifact and Desktop package tests pass; there is no portable-archive assertion failure in the retained tail. The PR native job budget becomes 60 minutes, with the manual budget unchanged at 120 minutes. Required contexts, test selection and failure propagation stay unchanged. The initial run remains failed/incomplete, not a qualified platform.
Local repair 843766f6 passes formatting, 21 completed affected Rust checks and strict app/project Clippy, plus 20 branch-policy checks. The initial hosted Linux run's four passing bundle cases remain applicable to the unchanged Linux path; the directory-creation change is Windows-only. New hosted execution remains required for that platform. The verifier retains an initial missing-import compile failure (corrected), new isolated fixture directories created as 0775 under umask 0002, and an externally terminated bundle test process (exit 143, cause unestablished). Only newly owned test-directory modes are corrected. Changing the temporary parent alone does not fix the project refusal; a scoped private creation mask does. No production safety check is relaxed. The interrupted case separately completes in 162.64 seconds. Final local receipt /tmp/qiongli24-ci-repair-final-verification.json has SHA-256 cb45628353d925c990e70bb139beb8394681256861d70ff4e53cd1ab579c022d, binding the earlier partial receipt and the completed last case without overwrite.
The final documentation build before this evidence paragraph passes in 78.688734 seconds; receipt /tmp/qiongli24-docs-build-integration/receipt.json has SHA-256 9b6c92b9051118a44f52b0a8aa6fceaa9fe75837cf4901337363f589a54e9cf6. Seven roadmap checks, current generated index, whitespace and all six status capture hashes pass independent verification. All 249 task IDs/states/dependencies, 46 complete accepted records and 76 nonempty evidence fields are unchanged; only CLI-409/410 progress text is extended. Final diff review finds no remaining local blocker. Release is still Not ready pending AGY qualification and fresh final-source platform/package evidence; local integration adds no acceptance.
October 6 — metadata-assisted AGY recovery and candidate CI
Local integration and the existing PR now bind f97b5f7a. Its Evaluation Truth run 37481012601 and Cloudflare Pages check pass. Native CI 37481012794 runs against the repaired source separately from the earlier failed run. These remote actions use the maintainer's existing synchronization/verification grant; publication, main cutover and acceptance remain separate.
One separate recovery observation
The revised external preparation at /tmp/qiongli24-agy-recovery-preparation-r3 adds only the exact three public tool schemas generated by the installed Host to the prompt, explicitly labeling them interface metadata. Research input remains the project ID alone: no body, saved path, revision or file hash is supplied. The driver/parser, three-tool MCP allowlist and blanket direct-file denial remain unchanged from r2. There is no new read grant, schema injection into the Host installation or model override. Eleven parser cases, the fake-process/CAS round trip and three failure/cleanup cases pass before the new single bounded invocation. The old r2 failure remains.
On unchanged Host candidate 85758cac, the run completes in 98.311877 seconds, exit 0 and one Host-success turn. Fourteen completed tool attempts comprise one project read, one document list, eleven document reads and one denied view_file. Twelve native calls retain complete payloads. The initial note-read completion at offset 0 / max 16,384 omits its output from the stream without an error field; the model then attempts to read its own Host step-6 output file and is denied. This is consistent with Host output offload, not proof of a native read error.
Later bounded native windows reconstruct the entire 8,450-byte note and 10,308-byte source packet, with exact whole-file SHA-256 matches. No research body comes from direct filesystem reading. Source-fidelity review passes and the delivered paragraph contains 303 counted characters, within 250–350. Its unsolicited assertion of 294 characters is inaccurate. Complete-session scope and the frozen trace criteria fail on the extra file attempt and omitted result, so structural and whole-answer/V1 results remain 0/1, not a clean recovery pass. No scoring requirement or historical denominator changes.
Reported usage is 75,547 input, 280,581 cache-read, 3,983 output, zero thinking and 79,530 total tokens. These are the Host's fields, not additive or comparable efficiency estimates. Process cleanup, project/configuration preservation and exact settings CAS restoration pass. The driver/verifier neither inspect nor modify credential files; normal authorized authentication remains with the Host. Two offline review-helper enum/format mistakes across r2/r3 remain retained; only the external review inputs are corrected, without repeating either model run or changing source/trace bytes and scoring criteria.
The r3 evidence summary has SHA-256 26e90b182184b3e4220b7c680e72eb4af516eee0f4e70078ac683e89918ff262. The lightweight verifier matches seven capture files, fourteen frozen local inputs and thirteen external bindings, including the three public schemas.
| Record | SHA-256 |
|---|---|
r3/freeze.json | d2a8c68172f38d0649ceeb9fa96b47151c94d0155eed80ea075f17e0e119d469 |
r3/actual-capture/manifest.json | cbbc03d68a40eded7795179a5eeec5af243a4090a8d0e13a55a4b8861d6fd3c1 |
r3/actual-capture/events.jsonl | 884175b9bf2f3c2cfb2e06a4281840a777519ea69b816d8a7fa4695417920e91 |
r3/actual-capture/capture.json | 84ab3bfdd8713723c739ac97cad4a84702e787026cb1145a980647cbe5b71216 |
r3/actual-capture/permission-cleanup.json | d82100ca6b0424e3473b221d93e51f5217e3914f1d88f465efd60ea59de65b3b |
qiongli24-agy-recovery-review-r3-corrected/summary.json | a60b7ceadf50a3c70fb8c6b7a4003bd47aa832f5d30d0ff836c0646e640dac17 |
The original strict status score still fails because the retained status stream and exact-session transcript omit the MCP response envelope. Successful native body reconstruction does not change that gate or establish automatic Skill/schema discovery. The coordinator proposes describing AGY as experimental in 2.4, retaining these requirements for later promotion while keeping Codex and package gates mandatory. That material release-scope change awaits the maintainer's decision; the existing required AGY gates remain in force meanwhile.
macOS parallel-fixture collision
On f97b5f7a, the Windows foundation and Evaluation Truth checks pass. The macOS foundation finishes with one failing retrieval-manifest test: its newly exclusive temporary-base creation returns AlreadyExists. Timestamp-only suffixes can collide between parallel fixtures; the other retrieval case and all three CLI saved-document cases pass. The complete failed run is retained. The three affected project fixture helpers now follow the existing CLI/MCP fixture pattern, adding a process-local atomic counter to the PID and timestamp. Exclusive creation and canonicalization remain in place; production path guards and test selection remain unchanged. Hosted qualification of the repair is still required, independently of the earlier Windows pass.
The repair passes all 11 affected cases (two retrieval-history, three CLI saved-document and six project saved-document tests), formatting and strict app/project Clippy. Independent review finds no remaining local issue. Receipt /home/hermes/qiongli24-ci-fixtures-ykckuntt/collision-results.json has SHA-256 dbb94d74d75deb68480140b5bd0b69d54b0789e52a02a36d5b40525e92bde3de. These local results do not replace the required macOS execution.
Before this CI paragraph, the seven-file documentation review passes seven roadmap checks, generated-index consistency, whitespace and evidence bindings. All 249 task IDs/states/dependencies, 46 complete accepted records and 76 nonempty evidence fields remain unchanged. Documentation builds in 51.994152 seconds; /tmp/qiongli24-docs-build-r3-records/receipt.json has SHA-256 f53c04ecac3404ffc4b5ec93f1510384e2f9044cde5e536451ad4cb33b0f2ccc. The final operator-versus-Host credential wording is a reviewed plain-text clarification; it changes no links, build configuration or dependencies.
October 6 — protected synchronization and four-target qualification
The final PR source 1df769f9bc228caf4dd7622e47faf9d0a9b94709 passes Native CI 37487108616: Linux, macOS and Windows foundations, the native change boundary and Lite compatibility. Evaluation Truth 37487108729 and Cloudflare Pages also pass. The macOS execution qualifies the atomic-counter fixture repair. The preceding f97b5f7a run remains cancelled after supersession: Windows passes, macOS fails its single directory-collision case, and Linux is incomplete. Its retained cancellation log contains no observed assertion failure; that partial execution is not a platform pass.
PR 183 merges normally through the existing protected route. The frozen merged source is 8fd774a05f5fc08fd0b61b0857fe869e87cd3af0, with exactly the same tree as the qualified PR head. Local 2.x fast-forwards to it. Subsequent documentation records do not change the source identity of these checks or artifacts.
- CLI distribution
37494107157succeeds on all four targets: Linux x64/ARM64, macOS ARM64 and Windows x64. Target-native builds and installs, assembly and all four combined-package installation jobs pass. The downloaded packet passes the existingnative_release_assets.py verify --require-ciowner for version2.4.0and the exact merged source. This includes the successful-run API gate, not only receipt inspection. - Cargo distribution
37494107269succeeds in all four qualification jobs. Publication and post-publication registry installation are skipped as required for this branch run. - Manual Native CI
37494133020completes on the same merged source with all three foundation jobs, the change boundary and Lite compatibility passing. All three foundation jobs include Desktop consumer tests and the opt-in capacity step. Seven retained Community Alpha/product jobs fail, so the overall workflow is failure; Community Alpha promotion is skipped. These outcomes remain separate from the successful CLI and Cargo distribution lanes.
Independent downloaded-receipt verification confirms all four npm/PyPI installs, Lite 15 / Full 35, pack 1d84ed12, package hashes and Codex/Claude archive bytes. Each target passes both historical and explicitly selected 2.3.0 upgrade checks with three retained synthetic fixtures. Each of the four Cargo receipts reports ten archive installations and both qiongli/ql checks. Cargo receipts contain archive hashes but no source_commit; their source binding comes from the exact GitHub run head, not an invented receipt field.
The external receipt review at /tmp/qiongli24-merge-8fd774a0-receipts/receipt-verification.json binds 42 files and has SHA-256 c7db1e3cb1b02f3c5f54717f2507d0f6fd012f1e6bdbd9df4dc28db320f6b8a6. The release manifest has SHA-256 1e06335c6e80859a0c5be157117fdd9d69c91a08f37b8c532762cbb74a576ed0. The verifier initially misdescribes --require-ci as receipt-only; inspection corrects that explanation to its actual successful-run API requirement. The recorded command succeeds with that flag, and the exact-source workflow is confirmed successful. No extra verification run or artifact rewrite is needed.
The completed manual-run API snapshot and six capacity receipts are separately bound by /tmp/qiongli24-manual-final-37494133020/verification.json, SHA-256 4c05b49fe1c190bfc70c4c55d56f0d85c444a3b0e49a3240f87b7fc346ad4b73. All six receipts match the merged source and run 37494133020 with status observation-only. They establish no performance acceptance. The original 42-file CLI/Cargo review remains unchanged.
Retained Alpha product boundary
All three candidate-lifecycle jobs reject an ephemeral Alpha authority while building stable 2.4.0, reporting native-release-authority-product-version-mismatch. The retained acceptance owner explicitly constructs Alpha identities, update state and notes. All three desktop package jobs report desktop-package-target-unsupported; their owner maps the Alpha identity failure to that general error, so this does not establish an unsupported Linux platform. The macOS packaged-product wrapper reports packaged-product-acceptance-product-build-failed without the inner build error in its retained output; its precise underlying failure remains unestablished.
The existing CLI distribution decision and contributor release instructions separate standalone CLI qualification from App/Community Alpha signing and promotion. This increment does not expand the retained Alpha helpers to stable Desktop, change the embedded production authority or represent the complete manual workflow as passing. Its failures remain visible; they do not replace or invalidate the separately observed CLI package checks. The original required AGY status/recovery gates remain failed, and the proposed experimental AGY release boundary still awaits a maintainer decision. Overall 2.4 release readiness is Not ready under the current plan.
Independent review of the hosted-evidence documentation finds no issue and verifies all 42 bound files. Seven roadmap checks, the generated index and whitespace pass; all 249 task IDs/states/dependencies, 46 complete accepted records and 76 nonempty evidence fields remain unchanged. Before this final result paragraph, the documentation build passes in 54.390599 seconds, including the new local ADR link. Receipt /tmp/qiongli24-hosted-docs-build/receipt.json has SHA-256 4fd0d15d8bcf869a211fef3c6b2aff7d78b655f2ce6b5f807ef6452925805695.
October 6 — prose, literature synthesis, citations and explanatory notes
The maintainer reports awkward prose, shallow literature reviews, incomplete background citations and weak explanatory-note use. The local baseline is 16a9d7c4. Source inspection finds relevant English/Chinese expression guidance concentrated in J2 revision, a generic B4 completion rule, narrower citation coverage and no shared explanatory-note rule. These are instruction-coverage gaps; no supplied user manuscript reproduces the reported real-use defects.
Canonical content b2d52413 addresses the four outcomes through existing owners:
- Stage F applies scholarly voice while drafting and asks for concrete, connected explanation while preserving meaning, technical precision and source limits.
- B4 and the manuscript-writing route compare inspected evidence, explain consequential differences and connect the synthesis to the paper's question or choices. A section request does not trigger a formal systematic review.
- Citation-risk guidance covers source-dependent background, definitions and note claims, with nearby matching support rather than citation-count targets.
- Stage F and proofreading distinguish explanatory/bibliographic notes, preserve identifiers and venue rules, and keep essential evidence and limits in the body.
The separate synthetic evals/research_journey/writing-quality/ packet provides three bounded requests and review criteria. One requested gpt-6.1-sol / low subagent first uses materialized guidance to produce complete A/B/C answers, freezes them, then reads the criteria for self-review. All three complete without a material defect identified in that review. Coordinator inspection corroborates the source comparisons, background coverage, numerical/edit fidelity and note boundaries. This is a forward trial followed by self-review, not an independent blind judge, controlled improvement measurement, expert or installed-Host pass. The synthetic English edit is especially narrow; it does not qualify an entire manuscript. No answer is rewritten or rerun, and no usage metrics are invented.
The existing six-module content/route/resource suite passes all 81 tests; capability validation passes. The existing content materializer produces exact bytes for all eight changed canonical files, no symlinks and no missing resource links. Full original answers, commands, counts and reviews remain at /tmp/qiongli-writing-verifier-mpnpi2wt/; these temporary local observations are not accepted program evidence. review.md has SHA-256 5c67c9558eac3ed1e5a5cd938e06b07ca68fba98346ee91621bb557abe744d78, and hashes.json, binding source/task/changed-guidance bytes, has SHA-256 2d315db694d666d38df8618f66f1ae0619502ac10d22c696cf57372fea50ddc9.
The existing update_qiongli_core_lock Cargo example regenerates the native 446-resource lock in 7d779929, bound to canonical source b2d52413da3afd01ff44f82ec741bfdf03b656d6, content root b1504ec2a5472cd357f4310837d4086d1f277fb88aeee8ee6af02660854face2 and pack be8128fcbb62e16bc40526e7be1655ba4838b6af0ac28606639af92d19e6ba37. Regeneration succeeds offline without editing generated Plugin or installed files.
Native checks retain an environment failure: seven of nine content unit tests pass in the checkout, while two lock cases reject its group-writable ancestors. An exact 7d779929 archive in a private owner-only directory initially reproduces mode failures (lock selection 2/4; atomic materialization 3/10). Correcting only that verifier-owned tree to 0700 and using umask 077 resolves the setup: both focused lock cases and all 39 previously unreached integration tests pass. The 24 crate/workspace/lock inputs hash-match the committed source. No shared directory permissions, production guards or test sources change. The actual app's embedded_pack check is initially interrupted during compilation with exit 143 and unknown cause; one incremental retry passes 1/1. Neither the interruption nor the original permission failures are relabelled as passes. Commands, retained failures and successful results are in native-review.md in the same external evidence directory, SHA-256 9754c2843d0727020d4e7446c6b8196071275a55b723b87f81766bdb2e09a613.
Final canonical/documentation review finds no actionable issue; seven roadmap checks and generated-index consistency pass. All 249 task IDs/states/dependencies, 46 complete accepted records and 76 nonempty evidence fields remain unchanged; only CLI-405/410 progress text changes. The plain-text documentation changes do not rerun or inherit the prior documentation build.
Next qualify the regenerated candidate's installed guidance and, when supplied, review a representative real passage against its research question and source excerpts. The earlier 8fd774a0 four-target artifacts do not qualify this changed content. No new search, credential use, Host installation, research-data write, remote action or publication occurs. CLI-405/410 retain ownership and their acceptance state; the strict AGY gates remain failed and the proposed experimental boundary remains unapproved.
October 6 — first source-traceability implementation
The current A–E priority makes traceable literature summaries and writing the main 2.4.0 outcome. Slice A is implemented in 6970da52, with the CLI test launcher and equivalent validation-style correction in 91a5d02d. This adds the optional selector to the existing CLI/Full MCP reader, teaches exact saved passage readback and retains locations in existing note/ledger records. It does not add a new tool, evidence store, paper-page inference or project write. Raw wire behavior and Full 35 / Lite 15 remain unchanged. Bounded passage discovery (B) is the next implementation, followed by C/D/E under their named exit criteria; a local slice A result does not complete the main release outcome.
Pack commit 5c81e14e binds 446 resources to source 6970da527038a37d95136884a950a775cc8d4465, root a7dbb14b4f0d18e7a516d2af1f22fe6d1191f8b5add2b69337725ded0a8a2854, and pack ed5af23968a00122148a681a5f7975e9af3f2a109bed2e388446f9d50e5450ce. The later fixes change no canonical content, so the pack is not regenerated.
One gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier passes 14 focused tests on the corrected source: ten saved-document tests, three actual CLI/MCP tests and one embedded-pack test. They cover decoded/escaped text, arrays, repeated passages, UTF-8 continuation, legacy wire shape, invalid/ambiguous selectors and retained file/revision/security refusals. Capability validation, materialized resource reachability, formatting, seven roadmap checks and index consistency pass. The project-only strict Clippy check passes. Under Rust/Clippy 1.99.0, the combined project/app strict check fails four unchanged platform locations: one deprecated fetch_update and three chunks_exact_to_as_chunks diagnostics. The same focused check passes allowing only those two diagnostic categories; this filtered result is not a strict pass.
Initial failures remain recorded: fixture registration under umask 002, a resource audit against the unmaterialized workflow layout, incorrect placement of the test launcher's terminal --json, the unavailable pytest runner, and the new nested-if lint repaired in 91a5d02d. Tests use umask 077 without shared permission changes; resource checks use the existing materializer, and roadmap checks use the existing stdlib unittest runner. No production guard is weakened.
Final review finds no remaining actionable diff issue. All 249 tasks, 46 complete accepted records and 76 nonempty evidence fields are preserved; only CLI-405/410 progress text changes. These results establish local native passage readback, not installed-Host, academic-support or final-source release qualification.
Commands, source bindings and retained failures are recorded externally in /tmp/qiongli-traceability-verifier-2026-10-06-r2.md, SHA-256 311daf0af9fd1f59af653bc6116bdefb4a7054ec7da7f367576555990cf5cbc4. The initial frozen report accidentally omitted the first two pack-digest digits; the correction is verified against committed lock 5c81e14e and preserves the original report and its hash. No source/input change or test replay follows that transcription correction. Temporary local verification is not accepted evidence.
October 6 — bounded saved-passage discovery
Starting from local fc0abaef, slice B is implemented in 8da74df2 through the existing checked saved-document owner. CLI adds project document search; Full selects search mode with search_text on qiongli_project_document_read. Raw and selected reads remain compatible, and Full 35 / Lite 15 are unchanged. Strict requests reject mixed read/search controls. There is no new evidence store, project write, directory scan, remote fetch or installed-Host mutation.
The search scans decoded string values in one explicitly bound source packet, one selected string, or raw saved note/retrieval-history text. It retains distinct locations, returns bounded context with exact replay arguments and binds continuation to source/revision/query/pointer/context/page size. Matching is literal, case-sensitive and non-overlapping within each string. Packet metadata is included, so hits require content inspection; no hit cannot establish absence from unread material. Existing reading and evidence-review guidance retains reviewed locators in current note/ledger records and discloses those limits.
Pack commit b4e70b64 binds 446 resources to canonical source 8da74df254a8e7e717ea6fd5197ddfb43eab42ca, content root 008314f7a8e95e2891447948c0c35e7abfd7da90b0bcb8a2c6a0503fffe989b7, and pack 7174bfd715438f49042b7a335604267f9b8564810553c473799f354558bc13fe. Regeneration uses the existing offline update_qiongli_core_lock owner.
One requested gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier passes 21 focused tests: 16 project saved-document tests, four actual CLI/MCP tests and one embedded-pack test. The 14 prior cases are retained. Added coverage includes decoded/escaped Chinese, deterministic repeated matches and pagination, exact context replay, minimum UTF-8 context clipping, metadata and no-hit scope, literal/case/non-overlap limits, changed source/query/page bindings, invalid mode combinations, invalid JSON and locators, source permissions/links/size, and unchanged Lite refusal. Fixtures use umask 077; checks run offline and locked without weakening production guards.
Capability validation, content-only materialization/resource reachability, formatting, seven roadmap checks and generated-index consistency pass. Strict project Clippy passes. Combined project/app Clippy passes with only the two known Rust 1.99 baseline allowances, deprecated and chunks_exact_to_as_chunks; the preceding strict failure remains recorded above and is not relabelled a pass or rerun merely to reproduce it. No new diagnostic category is allowed. Final diff review finds no remaining actionable issue. All 249 task IDs/states/dependencies, 46 complete accepted records and 76 nonempty evidence fields remain unchanged; only CLI-405/410 progress text changes.
Commands, exact source/pack bindings, results and limits are recorded in /tmp/qiongli-saved-passage-search-verifier-2026-10-06.md, SHA-256 bc504b26872dc046d32d371a8dac8f57e450d7b973b34ef1f2e434aa75e659f0. The content-only materialization used an automatically removed temporary directory; the committed resource lock retains its pack identity. This local report is not accepted program evidence.
Next implement C: select an existing claim, traverse its actual ledger/note/source bindings and present supporting/conflicting passages separately for source-support review. Ambiguous identities, missing passages and access limits remain unresolved. Then D connects synthesis and changed-source review, followed by E's installed journey and final-source qualification. The B result establishes local native retrieval behavior, not academic support, installed-Host quality or release readiness. Prior package results, strict AGY gaps and pending scope/publication decisions retain their existing boundaries.
October 6 — manuscript-first claims, explanation and writing quality
The maintainer clarifies that exact sourcing and quality must apply during body writing, not only to reading notes or pre-existing claims. The implementation starts from da3ca8b0. Inspection finds that Stage F already discusses prose, depth and notes, but F4 coverage emphasizes major abstract/introduction/discussion claims and its type examples differ from the ledger vocabulary. There is no explicit shared manuscript-first traversal of unlisted assertions during drafting. The maintainer confirms no original failing passage is available yet; a later supplied manuscript/source pair remains the real-use regression input.
Canonical increment 8e25df35 connects the existing owners:
- The existing evidence-verification reference starts from exact manuscript spans across body sections, captions and notes. Compound assertions, causal bridges, numerical qualifications and unlisted claims receive their own source checks.
- Stage F and both writing workflows apply that route while drafting/revising. Claim maps retain final text locations and compatible ledger type examples; column headers, stable IDs, statuses and project-write owners stay unchanged.
- The Host follows all relevant records, including gaps and conflicting sources, and uses existing Graph reads and saved-passage read/search tools. It preserves note-local versus project-wide identity, version uncertainty and access limits. Native tools do not extract semantic claims from arbitrary manuscript text.
- Writing review separately checks explanations, premises, paragraph continuity, clear language and useful sourced notes. Core reasoning/limits stay in the body; a readable transition or populated citation list cannot replace support/depth.
The frozen synthetic evals/research_journey/manuscript-trace/ packet supplies actual body-writing and complete-claim audit tasks. One requested gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier uses materialized guidance, preserves both original answers and only then reads the separate criteria for self-review. A returns 657 body characters of results/discussion with source-bound comparisons and a resolved glossary note. No material support or flow defect is identified in that bounded review. It omits an explicit statement that the trial did not measure benefit receipt, although the criteria name it and the answer makes no claim about receipt; the omission remains recorded, not relabelled as an all-criteria pass. B identifies the manuscript's unsupported and unmapped assertions, preserves supported proportions, distinguishes incorrect causal/relative-percent wording, and leaves an unbound two-version claim unresolved. These are same-agent forward trials and self-review, not independent blind judgment or full-manuscript validity.
Actual CLI observations use an isolated registered fixture at revision 2. They open both CLM-001 ledger support records and recover both bound Trial2026 strings at /segments/1/text and /segments/2/text through search/read arguments. These are explicit fixture bindings; the empty receipt-backed list is not called failed discovery or a project-ID-only save/restart pass. Changing the isolated packet then reusing the old request refuses with project-revision-conflict; original bytes/reviews are preserved. This is read refusal, not automatic manuscript invalidation or completion of D's change-tracking outcome.
The 29 scoped content tests, capability validator, exact content materialization and resource-link audit pass. The regenerated candidate's embedded-pack test passes 1/1; seven roadmap checks and generated-index consistency pass. No Rust production code changed, so unchanged native suites/Clippy are not replayed. Retained failures/corrections are explicit: the first combined content invocation reaches a Plugin materialization test and is interrupted; the final scoped run excludes that method and uses the existing content-only audit. Copying source directory modes initially makes the synthetic root unsafe; only verifier-owned permissions are repaired. CSV CRLF triggers whitespace failures; 4ffa62fe normalizes only that fixture to LF and updates its manifest digest. Parsed rows, source/draft/task/criteria bytes remain equivalent or unchanged. A separately bound LF native recovery passes; original observations and model answers remain unchanged instead of being silently rebound or rewritten.
Pack 2e154819 contains 446 resources, canonical source 8e25df358e83bf441356b9c422bf8ef4a72da50e, content root 19b6718d63b0b07cf4c492a188ed765e02b3fa7f179af481e1e97953817bbcdc, and pack 195c20a323417ff88882ae241a377a486fc0e25bf6e7f6b5da7baaa2f781f4ec. Original native binary identities and the rebuilt pack check remain separately bound. Consolidated observations are in /tmp/qiongli-manuscript-verifier/self-review.md, SHA-256 59b527d36ea1ceb5752b7679e013267439b7d8219026e6133bce3fc266c3a655; final-artifact-hashes.json in that directory binds the answers, inputs and calls, SHA-256 1519ec9b708cd12aaecfad5c39b21ae8f73ec6b02e19a763c2d0e7563eb968e5. Temporary observations are not accepted program evidence. All 249 task IDs, states/dependencies, 46 accepted records and 76 nonempty evidence fields remain unchanged; only CLI-405/410 progress text changes.
C now has a bounded Host-guided implementation and synthetic/native observations. Next is D: retain these identities through summaries, synthesis and substantive source changes, identifying the affected manuscript claims and preserving old reviews. E still qualifies actual installed behavior and final-source packages. Real manuscript quality, automatic Skill discovery, strict AGY gaps and release readiness are not established by this increment. Publication authority and the pending AGY scope decision remain unchanged.
October 6 — synthesis continuity and source-change impact
D starts from local 3e154f9d. Canonical f469c8e6 connects the existing Stage E, evidence-verification, reading-summary/matrix and writing/handoff owners. A cross-paper conclusion retains its own claim identity and contributing evidence; comparisons explain design, outcome, context and uncertainty in relation to the current paper. The synthesis template removes paper-count consensus cues and distinguishes unknown access, inconclusive findings and comparable contradiction.
Changed-source review compares old/new content before following dependent notes, summaries, synthesis and actual manuscript uses, including paraphrases, background, abstract and notes. It distinguishes corrections, additional access, reserialized bytes, duplicate reports and missing material. Revised prose, unchanged conclusions with reasons and unresolved checks travel together; originals and prior reviews survive. Native Graph/artifact-change reads do not become a semantic dependency engine. Existing IDs, statuses, fields and preview/approval/CAS owners remain.
The frozen evals/research_journey/synthesis-change/ continuation references C's immutable invented sources. One requested gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier writes an initial complete candidate, freezes it, then receives updated sources and writes the continuation before reading separate criteria. The initial/revised LR has 645/654 characters under the recorded counting scope. Actual prose carries the trial's 9-point estimate to the explicit 4-point correction (CI −2 to 10), revises abstract/LR/interpretation/notes, retains the cohort's noncausal 40%/60% result and the outcome distinction, and preserves the missing supplement. Parsed equal JSON with different bytes and a companion report do not add independent evidence.
These are forward trials with same-agent self-review, not blind acceptance. The original outputs retain concrete imperfections: compound claim IDs, an omitted OUT-1 digest inside the initial candidate, and a free-form excerpt label outside the templates' controlled fields. 56ee4916 repairs the demonstrated guidance ambiguity: claim-level full_text body evidence requires an explicit partial-body scope when appropriate, with inspected/missing locations; it never upgrades whole-paper retrieval or coverage. A separate prompted candidate repair splits claims and supplies the bindings. Final inspection also identifies custom map headers, decorated ID cells and range-like pointer shorthand in that first repair. A second prompted repair retains that attempt and produces the existing eight columns, bare IDs, permitted vocabularies and individual locators (29 checked rows). Neither repair is relabelled as an original or independent pass.
Mechanical evidence: 36 focused content tests pass, followed by 12 affected tests after the excerpt repair. Content-only materialization and resource-link audits pass before/after, with five repaired canonical/materialized files byte-identical. The final complete capability validator passes. All manifest input hashes and the 16 frozen C files remain unchanged. The first pytest invocation reports its module unavailable; the verifier uses existing unittest instead, without installing anything. Both intermediate and final embedded-pack checks pass 1/1, with the unchanged activation deprecation warning retained. No broad native/Clippy suite, network, Host installation, login reuse or project save/restart is exercised.
Final pack 5f47649e contains 446 resources, canonical source 56ee4916878336669956f1033f7b293c4efbe872, content root 3f451128cfe5437c4932eae412941dc31a5dc142f517f5aece38d1f08646d7b8, and pack d421f2ee33c31ac062d8b3bcce2aeb01dbf4e108b6820641bd8c1ef8ae62d090. The intermediate f469c8e6 pack/check remains separately identified in the report. Evidence is retained in /tmp/qiongli-synthesis-change-verifier/:
initial-original.md: SHA-256198f0008883c77d0f1fa51115dd4f6caacef750b5d31f2f076ef297cc53946c2;continuation-original.md: SHA-25645a52e301ffea0ba04a0ab4770a7a36804387f0ea1f3438838cb51166df51147;continuation-repaired-v2.md: SHA-2562a47b61681ac560829de61f0dfc12073283c76316bb6495a3fd339d09f342cc7;final-report-v2.md: SHA-256122d8cb93c8735a49e7741f8f6479732ffe97f7e5f644444030c709764155a84;artifact-hashes-v2.json: SHA-256762b65cdf10f870de9115f0b77ed1bf094a672908f0783b4a8d56e4368688fb7.
Seven roadmap checks and generated-index consistency pass. All 249 task IDs/states/dependencies, 46 complete accepted records and 76 nonempty evidence fields remain unchanged (198 populated evidence/commit/run fields preserved). Only CLI-405/410 progress text changes; temporary observations are not accepted program evidence. The main Agent reviews the final diff before local integration.
D now has a bounded Host-guided implementation, actual changed-source continuation and separately reviewed prompted repairs. Next is E: use the final installed candidate for the source-to-manuscript-to-recovery journey and requalify its packages/upgrade paths. Real failing manuscript reproduction, automatic discovery, strict AGY gaps and final-source release qualification remain open. Earlier package results do not qualify the new content; the AGY scope decision and publication authority remain unchanged.
October 7 — installed traceability and bounded candidate qualification
E starts from clean local ff6ce4db63f6c46957df771aeb8db826e139ef7c. Product and canonical content remain unchanged: content source 56ee4916, 446 resources, content root 3f451128cfe5437c4932eae412941dc31a5dc142f517f5aece38d1f08646d7b8, pack d421f2ee33c31ac062d8b3bcce2aeb01dbf4e108b6820641bd8c1ef8ae62d090. This increment adds the frozen evals/research_journey/installed-trace/ exercise and corrects evaluation prerequisites, without a native API, content-pack or configured-user-model change. One requested gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier owns actual observations, complete output review and focused checks.
The credential-free preflight initially sees the shared socket directory as mode 0000 inside the outer tool sandbox. A separate TMPDIR hypothesis fails. An authorized read-only host-context check instead sees the existing owner and mode 0700; the same unmodified preflight succeeds there, retaining the inner read-only/no-network profile. No shared-directory chmod or tested-sandbox bypass is performed. Both views and the failed hypothesis remain in the evidence. Native exports also correctly refuse unsafe /tmp and group-writable repository ancestors. The successful installation uses a new private directory under the user home. Helper parsing/readback errors and an initial group-writable cache refusal remain retained; a fresh preparation uses umask 077. No failed frozen cohort is overwritten or quietly relabelled.
The installed Host candidate is a separately extracted test-profile archive, SHA-256 2058890304c5f965774ba861dd14cb854b28da17ce89eb03b29dce8906ff4a52, with CLI ccc69afe884cd8a0ea9a603b49c555866e78addd49ddf08eef8f755a1e01eab7. Official native export and Codex registration retain 468 matching receipt entries; Lite/Full discovery remains 15/35. Codex 0.160.1 uses the requested model/effort, supported effective-policy readback, and exact granted read tools. Guidance locations are explicitly supplied; automatic Skill discovery is not established. Temporary login symlinks are removed after every actual run, without reading, copying or hashing credential contents. Processes complete normally and the original configuration/project snapshots are preserved.
The fixed three-case regression passes structure 3/3 and complete-answer review 3/3. The source paragraph has 256 characters under its established counting rule; fresh saved-note continuation recovers the actual 7,117-byte note and 10,308-byte packet, retaining the changed duplicate and historical count. This cohort has its own frozen manifest and denominator; earlier failures remain under their original candidates. No broad academic acceptance follows.
The additional invented packets, tasks and separate criteria freeze at manifest SHA-256 2feb19481fc1d87fb0717d24ba85a03e48da3b204627e97cc971b4e2ec2ebab8. Their provenance explicitly states supplied synthetic excerpts, without a live search, publisher retrieval, real DOI or complete-paper claim. Native approved source saves precede the actual installed writing task; the task receives only project ID and installed guidance locations, not source bodies or review criteria.
- Original writing check: 0/1 complete pass. The 623-character body, sourced note and source-support review pass; its 35-row map retains exact headers, IDs, versions, packet hashes and six observed JSON pointers. However CLM-035 combines the directly reported multiple-operations fact with the inference about apprentice-level proportions. The frozen independently-checkable-claim criterion fails. One guessed optional guidance filename also fails before the model finds the actual template. The original answer is preserved, not repaired or rerun:
e55ec7e343fbb60266f210a36ab3964e706517c0b25b3e54906f1266ddbaae59; full reviewe7ef27a1334d35575da159b45ba149475c1129c9c1bd2788c9077093330b521a. - Persistence passes its bounded checks. The reviewed source-supported original writing unit is saved verbatim through the native stage-summary/handoff owner at revision 4, with a separate partial/unaccepted map review. Summary SHA-256 is
ba4afd2ba7ec15ee6bb820cc2177e689296a98df3a044b2bed928447fe82aba1. Missing academic approval, stale revision, and changed/missing-source reads and previews refuse without altering retained records. Original source bytes are restored before the final reviewed save. This is a saved writing unit, not native consolidation of F2/F4 manuscript files or stage acceptance. - Original fresh-session recovery: 0/1 complete pass. Both source packets, literal
3 fewer errorssearch, exact returned read arguments and broader context inspection succeed. The saved body and original claim IDs are not recovered. Of 12 native calls, 11 succeed; an unapproved artifact-changes call is correctly denied and not retried. The model reports this limitation instead of inventing recovered prose. Complete review SHA-256 is6959a69c5128ace6dd89f175d7e6074c3499705cec006feb8739ee335a4655c1.
Offline diagnosis corrects the initial assumption that a usable summary route had been provided. The pre-denial project read returns a redacted root label and revision, not an absolute root, state body or summary history; the document list contains the two source packets only. The shared preamble expressly permits command reads for guidance, while the task conditionally mentions Host document reads. Filesystem permission alone does not provide the missing observed binding. This is an incomplete/ambiguous driver-capability prerequisite, not evidence of a native defect or wrongdoing in respecting denial. The top-level journey README now requires a supported, authorized discovery route before freezing such a run. The frozen original fixture, prompt, denial and failure remain unchanged. There is no extra model retry, policy widening or replacement observation this turn.
Separate release-profile qualification uses the same clean product source in an isolated glibc 2.35/Rust 1.97 Linux ARM64 environment. The existing release owner passes strict Clippy, 46 CLI integration tests, nine MCP stdio tests, format/version checks, empty-PATH archive smoke, Codex/Claude Plugin archives, DeepSeek projection and isolated npm/wheel installation. All five asset hashes and sizes match its manifest. Release binary SHA-256 a741603ddcdb0a5c1e15150f5054ea172d291faa2e12c09f8966b14acc5d17da is kept separate from the test-profile installed Host binary. Release manifest SHA-256 is f68e1ee3f3ed98a631541c1b4df99e040a557b8f0c2eddf3d837bb91838acf5f. Actual public pip/npm predecessor 2.3.0 upgrades pass through the existing explicit-predecessor owner; its exit result is checked separately from Cargo. Ten actual Cargo source archives also pass isolated archive-only installation, including qiongli/ql, version, invalid-command refusal, Lite 15/Full 35 and exact content-pack checks. Upgrade report SHA-256 is d4b2a93e89e752b1e70556414bdc3b74f5ec318b7620309396ecf9d46b2997a2; Cargo install report is a2d71890aa2c81f2575d9997adbe093ce9a365a04a118dde223dde9e4171f611. The upgrade proves package replacement and synthetic fixture byte retention, not a project-format migration or live Host update.
The observation roots are /home/hermes/qiongli-e-20261007-zftrb1ao/installed/cohort-r2/, /tmp/qiongli-installed-journey-2026-10-07/, and /tmp/qiongli-e-release-20261007-76dtw1lb/. The consolidated report /tmp/qiongli-installed-journey-2026-10-07/evidence-summary.json, SHA-256 282737eeb1db3ece4f82703ac950aa2d0bb39e943d5fa858b70a08cc6853d696, binds all five actual episodes, complete calls/answers/reviews, save/negative receipts, frozen checkpoints, policy, cleanup and separate artifact/install results. These local temporary observations are not accepted program evidence.
The frozen fixture's seven file bindings, seven roadmap tests, generated-index consistency and whitespace checks pass. All 249 task identities/states/dependencies, 46 complete accepted records, 76 nonempty evidence fields and 198 populated evidence/commit/run fields remain unchanged. Only CLI-405/410 blocker progress and update dates change. No runtime/content suite is replayed for these evaluation and documentation edits; the main Agent reviews the final diff before integration. The scoped verification record, before this result annotation, is /tmp/qiongli-installed-journey-2026-10-07/final-checks.json, SHA-256 aa8a5188dfc812712b825cc647ae476ac7321a05aa026395534bc19d75bc2198.
Readiness remains Not ready. Next resolve independently checkable map rows and establish a supported project-ID-to-saved-writing discovery route through existing read/Host owners, then freeze a separate observation with clear authority. Do not repair the old capture in place or widen permissions after denial. The first E writing/recovery pair is not a complete journey pass. Fresh representative writing, final-source four-target packages/Cargo and strict AGY gates remain unqualified; prior candidates do not supply these results. The real failing user manuscript is still unavailable. Pending AGY scope and publication decisions are unchanged; no push, tag, publication or accepted-evidence promotion occurs.
October 7 — real manuscript diagnosis and literature-review positioning
The maintainer now supplies an actual earlier-version literature-review section. This closes the missing-example gap for text diagnosis, not the missing-original- sources gap: its bibliography, cited full texts and surrounding paper are not supplied. The original attachment and selected-span review stay outside the repository; no manuscript text, subject-specific citation keys or claimed source verdicts are added to the public fixture. Only generalizable failure patterns inform this bounded increment on local baseline 45296eb4.
The requested gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier identifies premature movement from brief findings into contribution ranking, dense feasibility/reporting language, underexplained cross-study comparisons and unverified field-wide practice/data capability assertions. It also retains positive organization and inferential limits. Absence of an explanation in this section does not establish absence from the whole paper; no footnote quota or blanket claim of ungrammatical prose is imposed. Citekeys alone do not verify the reported papers or their findings.
Canonical source 717653135e55c6f083c1e3c11ba2f69279ef651b repairs the existing Stage F and citation-risk owners: readers must be able to understand the actual evidence and unresolved substantive question, rather than infer a contribution from a methods list or statements about what the paper cannot claim. Boundary reviews remain useful drafting inputs, with consequential limits preserved and operational detail placed where it serves the requested section. Comparisons state their compatible or different quantities; literature-wide and dataset capability judgments require matching inspected evidence. The existing claim-map template clarifies that independently checkable findings and inferences need separate claims even when they share a source passage. Qualifiers, stable IDs, headers and project preview/approval/CAS ownership remain unchanged.
The frozen evals/research_journey/lr-positioning/ exercise reuses the prior invented writing packet, without the private manuscript. Manifest SHA-256 is 9975f06acc64ba7f5943c211e3eef1e2623cc2c9b7b4368e203f09efac3cfa35. One original 376-word answer is preserved before the verifier reads the separate criteria. Its complete source-support, comparative explanation, flow and useful sourced-note review passes. This is a targeted regression with diagnostic context and previously observed sources, not blind/held-out, controlled improvement or installed-Host evidence. It does not verify the real manuscript's citations or repair its complete argument. The changed claim-map guidance still needs its separately frozen installed continuation; the earlier compound row remains failed.
Thirteen closest content-contract checks, capability validation, content-only materialization/resource reachability and Skill quick validation pass. The three changed canonical guidance files match their materialized bytes. No new test asserts research quality from a heading or keyword. The original diagnostic report's section-count slip and the initially assumed materialized directory path are retained with explicit correction; neither causes a model retry. Observations are under /tmp/qiongli-real-lr-review-20261007/; the private original diagnostic has SHA-256 31936dd1f25b2543806fb7644b1a3e6f4a3992c1c808b24c61c46e2f0c103b59, and its count correction is erratum.zh.md, SHA-256 5c54d1dc93465454f62a0d4e42302a8ac4fa296afbcf3b0b11aa5cb33f57f597. The synthetic answer SHA-256 is 3f479153303b42531fb40162f96957dcaec34414f7275a173fd94a900bd50c6a; regression/review.json has SHA-256 cef63ffcc6d042d86fe062ec98a520d43b3c159367e4b8718d6afc90ca12dcbd.
The existing Cargo example regenerates the 446-resource lock from source 71765313: content root e7331e78e141b87cc15ea617f4ed1bf4f5b5dc3aa93cf8d7b9587d0bc4171841, pack 8314fbc1600b5390f0174c5c22699ebbafdbbca5e67fabbb20a8c375f1477dd1. The actual app embedded-pack check passes 1/1, retaining the existing unrelated fetch_update deprecation warning. No unchanged broad native suite is rerun. regression/pack-check.json in the private observation root has SHA-256 fd92fb4925c8e0cd7966c0a2bffbfc52664d8ff631f4bd415214cea4f7e5e1dd. The private selected-claim audit uses the existing eight columns, attachment-local IDs and explicit unverified source locations; it is not exhaustive manuscript coverage or a supported-claims ledger. A prompted v2 correction retains v1, clarifies contextual citation attribution and splits one compound interpretation using new local IDs. Its SHA-256 is a08189bf1d5fd6bfdfd6b91fed41ebb0fd60bfffc404441bdc4544ccfc9d77a3. No original paper or data documentation is silently substituted for the missing source, and the supplied manuscript is not rewritten.
Seven roadmap tests, generated-index consistency, frozen-input bindings and whitespace checks pass; final review identifies no actionable finding. All 249 task IDs/states/dependencies, 46 accepted records, 76 nonempty evidence fields and 198 populated evidence/commit/run fields remain unchanged. Only CLI-405/410 progress text changes. The scoped check record before this result annotation is /tmp/qiongli-real-lr-review-20261007/final-integration-checks.json, SHA-256 629d62a681bdfe91ad62ffeb21b6a01ca7190ca9e3c1bc001c8d8f4cc7a814ef.
No native runtime or write API changes; no new login reuse, live source search, installed-user-profile update or publication is performed. Prior ff6ce4db Linux ARM64 release/upgrade/Cargo results retain their original source identity and do not qualify this changed content. Next establish the supported saved- writing discovery path and qualify a separately frozen installed continuation; source verification of the real manuscript requires its actual cited materials. Final-source multi-platform and strict AGY gates remain open. Local observations do not change task acceptance or the pending AGY scope/publication decisions.
October 7 — readable prose and continuity across manuscript sections
The maintainer emphasizes that depth and logical continuity must not be sacrificed for elevated vocabulary, throughout writing rather than only the literature review. On local baseline bc79521f, canonical source c631317750718e3345b8349067bb32e850505fd2 strengthens the existing scholarly-voice, Stage F and academic-write owners. Use the clearest precise wording; retain and explain necessary technical terms. Concision removes empty framing, while keeping the evidence-to-conclusion step, comparison, qualifications and useful explanation. The final continuous read checks actual sentence and paragraph connections and consistent questions, constructs, populations, outcomes and time frames. An unsupported premise remains a gap; polished transitions cannot supply it. No sentence-length score, vocabulary blacklist or extra review process is introduced.
The new evals/research_journey/readable-manuscript/ fixture uses invented evidence about initial guided practice and a separate observational follow-up. It contains no private manuscript or real-paper citations. Manifest SHA-256 is 2b30ad15d530336cca384c4277c60b66c7f474b90cb98d78b658ed818a572e9b. The requested gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier uses materialized guidance and produces each of three answers once, freezing originals before reading separate criteria:
- A: Chinese Results and Discussion, 442 body characters under the fixture rule.
- B: formal English Results and Discussion revision, 179 body words, preserving headings, supported quantities and citations while simplifying the phrasing.
- C: a concise explanation of the missing premises between initial assistance, understanding and later independent completion, without inventing a mechanism.
Complete source-support, expression and continuity reviews pass for all three originals. This is targeted model generation and self-review with supplied synthetic evidence, not a blind/held-out comparison, measured improvement, whole-manuscript judgment or installed-Host observation. No original is repaired or retried after review. Results and per-file bindings are retained in /tmp/qiongli-readable-manuscript-20261007/review.json, SHA-256 19b7fbfddfe608db39bab3213a91f5ace031d6adff6ba59b96bf1b091b13c57a.
Fourteen closest content-contract checks, capability validation, fixture bindings, resource reachability, exact bytes for the three materialized guidance resources and Skill quick validation pass. The first check selection accidentally invokes the broad command/workflow class and its costly distribution owner; it is stopped with exit 130 and retained as incomplete, separately from the successful scoped checks. No broad runtime suite, installed Host run, authentication reuse, real-source search or private-document edit is performed. Configured models and existing write/preview/approval/CAS owners are unchanged.
The existing Cargo lock generator succeeds at source c6313177, retaining 446 resources. Content root is 4d3ffbc6385e606bbc45a13dc08638283cfb0489aa481ee63a6ced3b68fab17c; pack is 4e27832913048111fa7398105d6985945319769b9712e2ee101acb8c20337fa9. The actual app embedded-pack test passes 1/1, with the existing unrelated fetch_update deprecation warning retained. The scoped report is /tmp/qiongli-readable-manuscript-20261007/pack-check.json, SHA-256 ffec4c5bf7e9f7ea1af2ebfb065a509faed541699934a3c2876900b3efad730c.
Seven roadmap tests, generated-index consistency, the four frozen fixture bindings and whitespace checks pass; final review has no actionable findings. Relative to bc79521f, all 249 task IDs/states/dependencies, 46 accepted records, 76 nonempty evidence fields and 198 populated evidence/commit/run fields remain unchanged. Only CLI-405/410 blocker progress changes. The report, before final result annotations, is /tmp/qiongli-readable-manuscript-20261007/final-integration-checks.json, SHA-256 5c6fd8e03cfa7f900bc576f9b11cbe4ee24b6ab9c37b89b2be18e575b1c242c2.
Next establish the supported saved-writing discovery route and separately frozen installed continuation, with full delivered-unit support and readability review. Real-manuscript source verification still requires its cited materials. Earlier release artifacts retain their old source bindings; final-source packaging and strict AGY qualification remain open. This increment does not change acceptance, the pending AGY scope decision or publication authority.
October 7 — complete writing recovery and prepare publication
The maintainer explicitly requests completion of the two remaining writing observations and release-task dispatch. The prepared experimental Antigravity boundary is separately approved: retain its original failed complete-result and recovery checks for later promotion, advertise the limitations in release and installation documentation, and keep Codex and package/upgrade gates mandatory. This supersedes the earlier pending-scope/publication restrictions for 2.4.0; it does not relabel old failures, promote program acceptance, change remote rules or authorize an external Marketplace release or announcement.
The bounded diagnosis confirms that redacted project metadata plus the original three read-tool grants cannot discover saved summaries. The summary already has an immutable document and consolidation receipt, but list/read exclude its class. Source c9748636f1ab8022c0e7d8a7f46a2a06a6f02c55 extends those existing owners: list includes validated stage-summary receipt bindings, and read/search accept only the existing strict context/stage_summaries/STG-*.md path contract. The same revision/digest, storage safety, pagination and no-write checks apply. No absolute root, arbitrary context access, new MCP tool or broader Host permission is introduced. Guidance uses actual returned bindings and retains partial reviews and source fingerprints. Atomic claim guidance from 71765313 remains in force.
The requested gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier passes eight list tests and eighteen saved-document tests; after strengthening the search assertion, only its two summary cases rerun. Seven focused content checks and capability validation pass. The initial fixture run fails at directory safety under inherited umask 002; the corrected process uses umask 077 without changing production guards. An overbroad Python test-class selection is stopped at exit 130 and retained as incomplete. The prerequisite report is /tmp/qiongli-summary-recovery-20261007/focused-prerequisites.json, SHA-256 cebfef44ef21a5ada7bdb7680b50df43bab371aa40e86ba27c39456f40640c87.
Pack commit 54a2a3ee retains 446 resources, content root bf12a5d0eb557304d52327fa2e5bfed6c47f653e48c09ee5779b99fd841d475e and pack bc44f8b59ab0d687edbd75316c29937b98531dd15466140f25580da086a068f2. Five actual CLI saved-document tests, including existing Full MCP parity, and the app embedded-pack test pass. The new summary CLI case compares exact output with the shared owner and refuses a packet-only selector on Markdown.
Before dispatch, freeze a separate installed candidate and new writing/recovery cohort, retain complete original outputs and source-support/atomicity/readability reviews, and verify native approved persistence plus fresh-session recovery. The fixed regression and three newly frozen synthetic boundary cases remain separate denominators. Current-source local packaging and upgrade checks, followed by the immutable-tag four-target publication pipeline, retain their existing owners. Do not monitor after the requested publication-task dispatch or claim completed registry publication from a successful dispatch alone.
Installed completion and release preparation results
Clean candidate 3fa02b17ddf30e37c7168375c15651b6bba18b2c is independently snapshotted for installed and glibc 2.35 release checks. The corrected test-profile binary SHA-256 is 689a3a6da1c71e2db202b9c28b694e8e512c849435f43244e4d05f4563944edc; official export/registration verifies 468 cache entries, Lite 15/Full 35, exact content identity, effective three-read-tool policy and credential-free preflight. The first test binary lacks the explicit source stamp and is refused before any model run; its installation and the preparation-order correction remain retained. No real profile, configured model or tested permission is changed.
The gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier captures ten actual bounded installed episodes, each capped at 180 seconds. Original tasks, criteria and synthetic inputs freeze before execution; the two later review-driven corrections have separate frozen prompts and original records. Complete outputs are reviewed against actual saved sources, with source support, prose and claim structure judged separately:
- Fixed baseline: structure and complete-answer review 3/3; source paragraph 262 characters. A review-annotation correction preserves original answers.
- Original new writing: 0/1 complete pass. Its 650-character body, note and source support pass, but five map rows combine separately checkable claims. The original answer and failed review remain unchanged.
- Explicit reviewed writing correction: 1/1. Five retired IDs map to ten new IDs; twelve unchanged rows, body and note are byte-identical. All 22 final map rows receive independent support/atomicity review. The correction Host asks for an ungranted project-list tool, is denied and does not retry; its disclosure that it did not reread sources is preserved. A separate authorized native audit fully rereads both exact packets before acceptance. No denied call is a pass.
- Native saving retains the reviewed correction verbatim at revision 4; missing approval, stale revision and missing/changed-source cases refuse without losing original bytes. Summary SHA-256 is
e08236ed148b8ab7803b1ada88e60b7afdef7704a17998f1383bf9f05928b630. - Fresh installed recovery: 1/1, 126.48 seconds, 28 tool calls including 13 native MCP calls, without a failed call. Starting with project ID and guidance only, it recovers the complete 13,534-byte saved unit, revised IDs, partial status and source/history bindings. Two literal searches and exact returned read arguments recover source context; complete semantic review passes. This closes the previously missing summary discovery path without exposing a project root or expanding tool permission.
- New synthetic boundary cohort: original 2/3, not a first-pass clean sweep. Abstract-only access and changed-source continuation pass. The original unit- conflict answer accurately reports the conflict but omits the required explicit conversion. A separately frozen, single reviewed correction passes all its criteria in 213 words, including derived unit/interval conversion and the tenfold discrepancy, without selecting either reported estimate as correct.
All required judgments close on the final reviewed units; this establishes the bounded review-and-correction workflow, not universally atomic first drafts, blind generalization or whole-manuscript/expert acceptance. Earlier failures keep their original denominators, including the previous E cohort. Review metadata errata remain separate from source judgments; no original is overwritten. Observations are under /home/hermes/qiongli-final-installed-20261007-qebeee93/installed-r2/ and /tmp/qiongli-summary-recovery-20261007/. The reviewed-correction binding audit has SHA-256 ff4bd0c0bd6996fd14bcfb594defff4482929a5dad27abb84cd347f2c699e649; fresh recovery review is d10e3a66784242e5d54486448a031b6cf4f63a0ded403a29f54034671ca653a8; unit-correction review is 6de40a1638986cff1eacffa696125757af08a6cb64fcc926f7a0794185444040. The consolidated evidence-summary-current.json in the temporary observation root has SHA-256 c50fbdf9c6a68fab6229fc9c114caee91e2d728f5abb960003aab914f862fdae. It binds all ten captures/reviews, the original failures and separate corrections, retained setup/review errata, native save/refusal records and artifact checks. All ten process groups terminate; temporary authentication links are removed, and original configuration/project snapshots are preserved outside approved synthetic native writes. Credentials are never read, copied or hashed.
The independent same-source Linux ARM64 release owner passes strict pinned Clippy, 46 CLI and nine MCP tests, packaging and extracted npm/wheel/Plugin checks. Five asset sizes and SHA-256 values match the manifest. Explicit public 2.3.0 pip/npm upgrades and archive-only installation from ten actual Cargo source archives pass, including qiongli/ql, inventory and pack checks. The independent artifact review at release/independent-artifact-review.json in the temporary observation root has SHA-256 980d297d729436c38d6438ec5970dddcc64784e7a4dd3eea73dde213c54406be. Test-profile Host and release-profile artifacts retain separate identities.
Subsequent integration edits only clarify documentation and record these results. Their final tag must pass the existing four-target exact-source publication pipeline before assets are published; local ARM64 results do not substitute for the other targets. The authorized stopping point is a verified release-task dispatch, not a claim that registry uploads have already completed.
The final seven roadmap tests, generated-index consistency, both retained fixture manifests, whitespace checks and documentation build pass; findings-only review has no remaining actionable issue. Documentation preserves the existing build warnings. Against baseline bd1992ba, all 249 task identities/states/dependencies, 46 accepted records, 76 nonempty evidence fields and 198 populated evidence/ commit/run fields remain unchanged; only CLI-405/409/410 blocker text changes. The check report, before this checks-only annotation, is /tmp/qiongli-summary-recovery-20261007/final-integration-checks.json, SHA-256 3203c0d706e26c90ada1d1e15e3306a92c0ab50a599b3388299a2eb1bbe78939.
October 7 — compact AGY entries after the 2.4.0 release task
The maintainer's screenshot shows the main Skill and every research shortcut in Antigravity's global Skill list. Starting from fa5d1537, the bounded fix changes only the native AGY projection: omit the twenty generated workflow wrappers, retain the qiongli research router and independent no-qiongli reply-only entry, and keep the internal workflows, cards, references, language and variant bytes. The main entry explains internal routing and legacy workflow-name intent. Both terminal export and completion messages describe the compact layout. The shared content pack, MCP inventory, other Host entry policies and receipt schema stay unchanged. ADR 0234 supersedes only ADR 0233's public wrapper layout; historical 22-entry evidence and experimental Host gaps remain historical facts.
The requested gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier runs focused checks against an isolated source copy with the changed native files bound to the working-tree bytes. The four existing AGY integration cases pass; two new cases independently pass after fixture corrections. They cover exactly two public entries against Codex's 22, English/Chinese metadata, a custom variant, every retained internal resource, one MCP server, and verified legacy-wrapper migration with stale-receipt and modified-wrapper refusals. The two new projection/receipt cases use explicit synthetic binary bytes; they do not claim native execution. Five terminal-adapter checks and two shared bundle-owner checks also pass. Strict pinned Rust 1.97 Clippy passes for the affected production and integration-test targets.
Initial runs retain their failures: group-writable workspace ancestors, then synthetic directories created under inherited umask 002, fail before projection. The secure copy and command-local umask 022 resolve that setup without changing real ancestor permissions or weakening validation. The new tests initially use invalid destination leaf names; corrected fixtures use the existing approved names. A mismatched new ADR title is corrected and ADR validation passes. No failed result is counted as a successful behavior check.
The official AGY manager subsequently installs a verified legacy source with 22 Skills and one MCP server into a new disposable profile. It validates the compact export as two Skills and one MCP server, then installs/enables/lists it. The cache now contains only qiongli-workflow and no-qiongli; old wrapper directories are gone and source/cache receipt bytes match exactly. This is an actual manager replacement observation, not a simulated cache copy. No model or authentication operation is performed. GUI display, model routing and complete research sessions remain unverified, and AGY retains its experimental scope.
The initial full terminal flow times out at 240 seconds after legacy source export; an unnecessary interactive update retry is interrupted. Direct official manager commands reuse the verified source and establish the replacement result. Temporary export attempts also retain invalid-leaf and Cargo-binary hardlink refusals; a byte-identical single-link binary copy supplies the valid fixture. No refusal check or production ownership rule is relaxed. The full Codex integration command has no passing outcome and is not counted; the focused shared-owner checks and Codex entry/resource comparison supply compatibility coverage for this adapter-only change. Final formatting and whitespace checks pass; findings-only review has no actionable issue.
Evidence is retained under /tmp/qiongli-agy-entries-20261007/, including final source bindings, real-binary bindings, manager summary and individual test logs. The secure source and disposable manager profile are under /home/hermes/qiongli-agy-entries-20261007/. The ledger records only CLI-409 progress; no task state, dependency or accepted evidence is promoted. This is local development after the 2.4.0 release-task dispatch, not another publication or a change to the user's installed Plugin. The next delivery increment is a separately scoped CLI update carrying this fix, followed by actual GUI and fresh session routing checks. No prior release monitoring is resumed.
Final integration checks pass: seven program-roadmap tests, generated-index consistency, formatting and whitespace. Against fa5d1537, all 249 task identities, states and dependencies, 46 accepted records, 76 nonempty evidence fields and 198 populated evidence/commit/run fields remain unchanged. Only CLI-409's blocker and update date differ. A preliminary pytest invocation lacks that optional module; the existing unittest owner supplies the seven passing roadmap cases without installing dependencies. These checks are reused for local integration.
October 7 — one install entry for all detected clients
The maintainer requests an all-install entry and explicitly confirms its scope: every already-installed supported client gets its Plugin, including Skills and MCP. Starting from 8566055f, the existing Plugin guide gains install all (and update/upgrade equivalents), main menu choice 5 and Host choice 6/all. --target all uses the same read-only CLI detection for Codex, Claude Code, DeepSeek Harness and Antigravity. It reports selected clients and skipped missing CLIs; an empty set returns an actionable error before any install. Explicit client lists remain strict. The full all-Host preset validates options before filtering, preventing a single detected client from accepting a shared destination or unsupported Hook option. No scripted all-install plan or auto-approval is added.
The detected set enters the existing sequential Plugin owners with their current previews, confirmations, source selection, receipts and failure/cancellation behavior. Plugin delivery already includes Skills and MCP, so it creates no extra standalone copies or MCP registrations. The installer does not install client applications, change models or update the Qiongli executable. The menu also drops its stale hard-coded Full MCP count. ADR 0235 supersedes only the unconditional all-selection portion of ADR 0225; bilingual quickstart and installation instructions label the entry as the next update after 2.4.0.
The requested gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier passes seven focused native tests: two detection/selection cases, the new argument matrix, two retained Plugin parser cases, the retained selection case and actual CLI non-terminal refusal. They cover deterministic detection/order, partial/all/no available clients, missing-client messages, strict explicit lists, incompatible/duplicate options, --dry-run refusal and no writes through redirected input. Strict Rust 1.97 Clippy, formatting, ADR validation and findings-only review pass. Only the required help match-arm formatting was corrected; no semantic production fix was needed.
Four isolated terminal observations additionally pass: direct install all, main menu 5 and Host menu 6 each select inert Codex/AGY fixtures, skip missing Claude/DSH and cancel at language selection. No fake client executes and no Home or configuration file is written. An empty-client invocation returns installation-no-hosts-detected before language selection or installation. Initial menu-driver attempts reused fixture directory names and failed before invocation; distinct fixtures correct that setup and the failures remain in the logs. No actual user profile, Host installation, model or authentication is used. This establishes entry wiring and refusal/cancellation, not a new complete four-Host installation or live-session qualification.
Evidence is retained under /tmp/qiongli-install-all-20261007/. Only CLI-402 progress and its link to this plan change in the ledger; accepted records and task states/dependencies remain unchanged. Integrate locally through the existing feature-branch flow. The next delivery increment combines this entry with the preceding AGY compact-entry fix in a separately scoped CLI update. No push, publication or previous-release monitoring belongs to this increment.
Final integration checks pass: seven roadmap tests, generated-index consistency, ADR validation and whitespace. Against 8566055f, all 249 task identities/states/ dependencies, 46 accepted records, 76 nonempty evidence fields and 198 populated evidence/commit/run fields remain unchanged. Only CLI-402's blocker, date and one additional current-plan reference differ; all other task fields are identical. The focused native and terminal results are reused for local integration.
October 7 — Pi coding-agent package and MCP adapter
The maintainer requests Pi support on baseline 26cc94c4. ADR 0236 adds terminal install/update/upgrade plugin --target pi, Host choice 7 and Pi detection in all-install. Existing 3/both and 6/all retain their meanings. Require stable Pi 0.99.0+, the first published native MCP/registerMcpServer API. A distinct local schema-4 receipt reuses the bundle transaction for two public Skills, complete internal resources, locale/variant projection, the native binary and one JavaScript MCP extension. Pi owns transport and models. The stable source path remains bound while staging/backup/quarantine trees are verified. No canonical content-pack bytes, signed target, App plan or child-agent protocol changes.
The adapter honors PI_CODING_AGENT_DIR, resolves relative package declarations, reuses verified local sources and separately confirms source writes and any needed official pi install registration. Unknown/changed files, duplicate Qiongli packages/MCP entries, filtered resources and disabled built-in MCP refuse. Post-registration comparison preserves unrelated packages/model settings. New Unix profile files use a fixed-shell, separate-argv exec with umask 077; existing user permissions remain unchanged. This addresses observed official Pi creation of 0664 settings under umask 002, preserving unsafe-profile refusal. Removal uses pi remove <source> before separately handling retained source files. Bilingual installation help discloses experimental scope and the distinction between session /mcp and shell pi mcp list, which omits package extensions.
The requested gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier passes six adapter cases, three bundle cases, seven CLI selection/parser/non-terminal cases and five retained AGY adapter cases. These exercise exact entry/resource projection, locale and variant preservation, comparison with Codex's 22-entry layout, relative source reuse, configuration/model preservation, explicit approvals, private file creation and literal argv handling. Negative cases retain receipt CAS/drift, foreign/unmanaged sources, symlinks/hardlinks, unsafe permissions, oversized/malformed profiles, unsupported versions, resource filters, duplicate declarations and standalone MCP overrides. Small synthetic binaries cover projection/receipt behavior; actual native execution is recorded separately below.
Published 0.87.1/0.99.0 archives establish the API boundary. Official Pi 0.99.0 and 1.1.0 loaders each observe the two package Skills and one deferred MCP registration without model execution. A real 1.1.0 terminal install using the new native binary exits successfully after two separate approvals under parent umask 002. The custom agent directory is honored, default Home/.pi is absent, and official settings are 0600. Declining the source confirmation creates no source, receipt or settings. A 1.1.0 SDK session connects the actual native Full MCP and returns a successful config-status result without an LLM or credentials; registration and tool invocation remain separate observations.
Evidence is retained in /tmp/qiongli-pi-20261007/, with a new secure source and Host fixture under /home/hermes/qiongli-pi-verification-20261007/. Initial compile failures, disk exhaustion, a disallowed override fixture, omitted managed Pi paths and a missing fixture Node executable are retained alongside corrections. An initial SDK cwd discovers an unrelated ancestor Skill without executing it; a separate isolated-cwd observation resolves that fixture boundary. Two short AGY test filters selected zero cases and are not counted as passes. Local integration does not qualify a model-driven research journey, all operating systems, installed user profiles or publication. Only CLI-409 progress changes; task states/dependencies and accepted evidence retain their existing owners. The next increment is a separately scoped CLI delivery carrying Pi, install-all and compact AGY changes, followed by actual research-session qualification. No push, publication or previous-release monitoring belongs to this increment.
Final Pi observations also pass: declining registration retains the verified source and creates no Pi settings; a separate SDK cwd loads exactly the two package Skills with zero diagnostics/errors, discovers 35 native MCP tools and keeps only the built-in tools plus tool_search active initially. Deferred config-status execution returns status: ok. Two exact retained AGY compact/ legacy regressions and two shared Codex bundle owner cases pass. Strict Rust 1.97 Clippy passes for the changed platform/App and Pi integration surface. source-binding-final.json records byte equality for all twelve changed native inputs between the workspace and the secure test copy. These results are reused for local integration; later documentation/index checks are recorded separately. The final native count is 25 passing tests; zero-match filters are excluded. Cancellation and successful terminal runs all complete within their bounds. Pi mise shims are not resolved by this adapter; use the official executable on PATH. Windows and macOS behavior and model-driven research remain unqualified.
Final integration checks pass: seven roadmap tests, generated-index consistency, ADR validation, formatting, whitespace and scoped findings-only review. Against 26cc94c4, all 249 task identities/states/dependencies, 46 accepted records, 76 nonempty evidence fields and 198 populated evidence/commit/run fields remain unchanged; only CLI-409's blocker differs. The verifier records these invariants in invariant-final.json and retains exact commands in verification-summary.md. The frozen native and isolated Host results are reused for local integration.
October 8 — writing contract alignment and 2.5.0 release
The maintainer requests the reviewed writing corrections, comparison and tests, scoped commits and a new release-task dispatch, then no follow-up monitoring. This authorizes source synchronization, reviewed main cutover, immutable tag and the existing release workflow. It does not authorize announcements, external Marketplace promotion, altered remote rules or a claim of completed publication. Reuse this bounded plan; historical 2.4.0 evidence and acceptance remain intact.
Baseline is c1a05c4d559a07a1362ad235a1563f689e7b1da8. Candidate 2.5.0 includes its accumulated Pi/all-install/compact-AGY changes and the writing corrections. Canonical Stage F remains the shared owner; Discussion and F6 inherit its full scope rules, formal output paths remain compatible, literature maps use corpus-appropriate structure and the generic rubric judges consequential reasoning rather than mandatory mechanisms. Citation support follows the result producer and original inference binds premises; RFS advice carries its official source and does not impose empirical evidence on every theoretical paper.
Independent gpt-6.1-sol / low work owns verification and review. A separately frozen invented two-task cohort exercises a complete English LR and connected Chinese manuscript sections, with reviewer criteria withheld from authors. Source support, argument depth/continuity and expression are separate verdicts; original failures and later corrections keep their own records. No real private manuscript, automatic scientific verification or journal acceptance is claimed.
Before dispatch, retain focused contract/projection checks, reviewed model outputs, current-source Linux ARM64 release/install/upgrade/Cargo evidence and final diff review. The existing immutable-tag workflow gates publication on all four target artifacts. Pi and AGY retain their disclosed experimental boundaries. Results and exact bindings are appended here once available; pending checks are not passes. Program task states, dependencies and accepted records are unchanged.
Writing checks and comparison
Writing commit e6737d74 and version/docs commit 8ffd3f83 integrate at ebf6d4af6359514e8dd459a8742469e11189f88a with the regenerated pack. The pack retains 446 entries, source 8ffd3f8377edae5889e7525c44dff0802f8f27d3, content root d81db0b1eb86dedaaaf35ac2892b4790750b39a900e709153039d064f839ce2a and pack f2f8b22426fc3a8eea0600de7268de76988b6abefbdbe0abc2d81c5712e8eec7. Sixteen Rust 1.97 embedded/writer/loader tests and an independent actual-content binding check pass. Content and model guidance stay unchanged in subsequent release bookkeeping.
Independent final review identifies and closes two remaining conditional-scope conflicts (direct-edit citation reports and mandatory F3 lenses). Fresh affected Python checks pass 19 tests, cross-platform routing/materialization passes all 11, and unchanged downstream results are retained without adding overlapping counts. Strict B-literature and finance overlay audits pass. The original 43-test attempt retains its one version-drift projection failure; the exact-input rerun resolves that failure. Seven roadmap tests, generated-index freshness, 102 relative documentation targets, the documentation build and frozen-source boundary guard pass. Existing highlighting/chunk-size build warnings remain.
The four initial model attempts fail at transport discovery before generation; they remain setup failures. A same-cohort transport retry uses the identical frozen synthetic prompts, nine guidance files per arm and gpt-6.1-sol / low, with 180-second limits, read-only sandbox and no enabled tools. All four retry answers complete; all processes are reaped and temporary login links/profiles are removed. Credentials are never read, copied or hashed. Actual user settings and research data are untouched.
The reviewer receives anonymous answer files and the frozen criteria without arm mapping. Candidate arm 1 passes A/B 2/2; baseline arm 2 passes A/B 2/2 across request scope, continuity, depth, readable language, factual/citation fidelity and inference fidelity. Candidate outputs are 844 English words and 1,222 Chinese characters; baseline outputs are 854 and 1,237 under the documented count procedure. Twenty-four exact answer spans bind the six-dimension reviews. The candidate develops some comparison and magnitude details more explicitly; the baseline develops other distinctions more fully. No pass-count gain or universal writing improvement is inferred. This is supplied-guidance synthetic validation, not installed-Host discovery, private-manuscript repair, whole-field or expert/journal acceptance. The used cohort now becomes regression evidence.
Evidence root: /tmp/qiongli-writing-20261008/. Retry frozen-input SHA-256 is e6f24ee609a19cc418fcb3d0922b6b8b71c6dc050883d90ba65aac86200e66ae; argument-ab-transport-retry/execution-summary.json is e40bfa42f56b6e8eb21f0da1e073c907bfda9600b2e068cf56efa1cfaa4932a2; blind-review/review.json is 557b1263d991de5a36355ddf8d7e6159cb2ed3408cffc2f0c3a030518f632762. The isolated glibc2.35 package run initially refuses a missing v in the release note heading before building; that documentation correction passes the canonical version preflight. Current-source packaging is resumed on a new frozen snapshot, with the original failure retained. Ledger states, dependencies, all 46 accepted records and all prior evidence/commit/run fields remain unchanged.
Package qualification and publication handoff
Clean isolated candidate cfbb897c40b90e300e15be99aafc630081cfb5ec passes the existing CLI release owner under Linux ARM64/glibc2.35 and Rust1.97: strict Clippy/format, 47 CLI and 9 MCP tests, archive extraction, npm/wheel installs and generated Plugin checks. Separate current-pack regressions pass 6 AGY and 3 Pi integration tests; Pi's synthetic fixture is not a live SDK/model session. Actual published 2.4.0 → 2.5.0 npm and pip upgrades preserve the synthetic research/source/model settings. Installation from the checked Cargo archives and both qiongli/ql entrypoints passes. The snapshot's HEAD and clean status remain unchanged throughout the successful qualification.
The independent artifact review passes 46 checks across all five assets: sizes, SHA-256 values, identical executable bytes, 446 canonical content resources, embedded pack and installed/extracted payloads match. The manifest's registry_install field refers to these local installs, not public publication. All scopes remain distinct from the supplied-guidance writing comparison.
Retained failures include the release-note heading mismatch and an initial read-only fixture-directory mount that caused 42/47 CLI tests to fail before the corrected mount yielded 47/47. Production source and checks were unchanged by that mount repair. Inactive local debug incremental compiler cache was removed to recover 4,866,908,160 bytes; source, research and evidence files were preserved. Owned verification containers exited and the manual rootfs mount was released.
Evidence under /tmp/qiongli-writing-20261008/release-verification/:
final-cfbb897c-r2/verification-summary.json, SHA-256c7c7ce39bc0c33c822a0b9c76cd89523dc8f9777fec0531843234ee3a4296c55;final-cfbb897c-r2/upgrade-2.4.0/registry-upgrade-check.json, SHA-2564790a32a86f8eea4c719c868df967842649d1b4c216ea5c8847fcea8050926f3;final-cfbb897c-r2/cargo-install/install-check.json, SHA-2560718903c5bb264a9efe7d666c5e6acb5ce5409d5f4594d8c67e0b241203d90e2;independent-assets-review-cfbb897c.json, SHA-2563a17fb33042ae4acbc20c1b6bb7503fd2b0bf4e7e290510f67ab2bb279b708ba.
Final integration changes only this evidence bookkeeping. Reuse unchanged local checks; the final immutable tag must pass its own four-target distribution before publication through release-automation.yml post mode. The maintainer requests ending after an accepted release-task dispatch, without monitoring jobs or asserting that GitHub/registry publication has completed. No announcements, external Marketplace promotion or program acceptance are included. The next writing-quality increment needs a separately scoped real manuscript with its sources and target-venue review; the present synthetic cases are now regressions.
October 8 — automatic Host and source selection
The maintainer requests automatic recognition of installed common clients and matching installation paths after the 2.5.0 release-task handoff. Baseline is 60399ef53772549af3c3ded66cfe174cbac9e48e. This increment is local development; it does not restart release monitoring or authorize another publication.
Reuse the existing executable discovery and sequential Plugin installers for Codex, Claude, DeepSeek, AGY and Pi. Default the main guide to all on Enter and unqualified Plugin commands to all unless a Host-specific option needs selection. Codex/Claude reuse registered or verified legacy sources; fresh exports use separate Host-scoped defaults. AGY recovers a custom path from its verified cache and receipt-bound MCP command. Pi's source resolution and DeepSeek's profile selection remain unchanged. All-detected mode preserves Hook settings (off on first install). Existing previews, separate file/registration confirmations, conflict checks, write guards and cancellation/failure boundaries retain authority. ADR 0237 records the limited default/path compatibility change. No canonical research content, generated pack, model configuration or installed user profile changes are included. Only development-branch documentation claims this behavior.
The requested gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier owns focused native checks and independent review, using isolated files and fake Host commands for terminal observations. Results, retained failures and the next increment are recorded below at integration.
Verification passes 33 focused Rust tests: seven content-guide cases, eighteen Host installer cases, four argument/parser cases and four presentation cases. Coverage includes distinct fresh paths, verified legacy reuse, foreign/unknown files and canary retention, receipt/cache drift, AGY custom-source recovery, Pi settings/model retention, explicit target compatibility, cancellation and stale approval checks. The unchanged expensive automatic-source case is reused; the six other guide cases are rerun after the cancellation fixture correction.
Four isolated terminal cases pass with fake Codex/Claude managers: unqualified Plugin, explicit all and main-menu Enter reach the automatic source preview and decline without any Home writes; no clients returns the expected failure before installation. Only read-only fake manager commands execute. No Host/path/Hook selection menu appears on the automatic routes. These cancellation observations do not claim completed registration or a live five-Host research journey.
Rust 1.97 formatting and CLI/library Clippy with denied warnings, ADR validation, seven roadmap tests, generated-index consistency and whitespace checks pass. Independent gpt-6.1-sol / low review reports no remaining actionable findings. The ledger changes only CLI-402 progress/date; all 249 task states/dependencies and all accepted evidence, commit and run fields retain their original values.
Retained failures: initial workspace fixtures encounter group-writable ancestors; isolated private fixture mounts restore the existing safety preconditions without changing user/repository permissions. An initial container libc mismatch is resolved with a read-only compatible library mount. Two stale test expectations are repaired: the all-Host list omitted Pi, and the old empty-menu cancellation input now enters automatic detection. Initial terminal driver issues (Codex inventory fixture shape, PTY process-exit race and an overbroad Hook-menu assertion) are corrected independently of production behavior. The original logs remain. Private executable copies are stripped to reduce fixture hashing; original binaries remain unchanged. Only inactive debug incremental cache is removed after Cargo stops (3.3 GB), preserving source, binaries and evidence. Owned test containers are removed; unrelated existing containers are preserved.
Evidence: /tmp/qiongli-auto-install-20261008/verification-summary.json, SHA-256 3ba046e0e577c48375aad6a074e61bdae4c1a2f696a00ffcb9e990faee784998. It records final native source hashes, exact check counts, terminal outcomes, limitations and the ledger comparison. This is local Linux ARM64 source verification, not release/package or cross-platform qualification. Integrate through the normal local feature-branch fast-forward; next qualify these native changes for a separately selected delivery. The prior 2.5.0 packages do not establish acceptance for the changed installer. No push, new release, real client-profile update or previous-release monitoring occurs.
October 8 — installation progress, diagnostics and batch recovery
The maintainer reports DSH's generic host-command-nonzero-exit and requests visible progress, continued multi-client installation and a final recovery summary. Baseline is local d715fd35bf353b7f52a9c164cf17355453a612c8. Use the same bounded plan and CLI-402 owner; no release or real user-profile installation is authorized by this source-development increment.
The gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier reproduces the missing-diagnostics defect with an isolated synthetic manager: stdout/stderr and exit 17 disappear behind a unit failure enum. The caller also discards successful command output, while ? propagation stops the entire batch. This identifies Qiongli's reporting and batch-control defects; it does not establish why DSH failed on the user's machine. An optional OS/version/profile clarification remains separate.
ADR 0238 records per-Host continuation, explicit declines as skips, input/output interruption as a stop and final nonzero partial-failure results. Existing source, receipt/CAS, official manager commands, file/registration approvals and model settings remain authoritative. The final summary carries targeted retries; manager diagnostics retain exit codes and known static categories plus the exact command/profile/version. Raw manager output is neither echoed nor saved, and unknown errors stay unknown. Per-Host/command counters and five-second elapsed messages expose progress without inventing download percentages.
The shared process owner preserves its isolated environment, byte limits, legacy reason codes/UTF-8 interface and Pi's private umask. Pipe EOF now shares the command deadline. Normal terminal process-group membership is retained for Ctrl-C; timeouts still terminate the direct child only and may leave descendants. No automatic retry, process-tree termination or rollback is claimed. The native content pack, registry pin and platform support remain unchanged. Verification and integration evidence follows.
Verification passes 39 focused Rust cases: nine content-guide, twenty Host installer/diagnostic, four installation-parser, four presentation and two bounded runner cases. The two runner cases are rechecked after preserving foreground process-group membership. Five isolated terminal cases pass: synthetic DSH ETARGET/exit 17 with five-second progress and no credential echo; a failed Codex step followed by a receipt-verified synthetic DSH installation; explicit decline followed by the next Host; EOF stopping later Hosts; and Ctrl-C terminating both the foreground CLI and its synthetic manager. These use private test profiles and fake managers; they do not establish a live DSH installation or session.
Retained verification issue: the initial Ctrl-C fixture checked its child before Python processed the group signal. A bounded wait and fresh PID marker confirm both processes terminate; the initial observation remains in the evidence. Private stripped binaries reduce hashing cost without altering original build outputs. Final wording changes require only focused help/prompt/diagnostic checks; unchanged behavior tests retain their earlier source-bound results. No model, authentication or real profile data is used. Task-owned containers are removed, with unrelated containers preserved.
Final rebuilt-CLI checks confirm the batch help and DSH skip prompt with no fixture-home writes; Hook skip and dependency-neutral diagnostic wording are present. Rust 1.97 formatting, CLI/library Clippy with denied warnings, ADR validation (seven frozen, 38 current), seven roadmap tests, generated-index consistency (249 tasks) and whitespace checks pass. Independent gpt-6.1-sol / low review reports no actionable findings. Compared with d715fd35, the ledger changes only CLI-402 progress text; states, dependencies, accepted evidence, commit/run fields and dates remain unchanged.
Evidence: /tmp/qiongli-install-resilience-20261008/verification-summary.json, SHA-256 1b7a1da2805e6f3c3291c73a7f3617edb5ae44a2facb7c263e7d862dd789d76c. The summary binds current native source hashes and distinguishes fresh final wording checks from reused behavioral observations. This is local Linux ARM64 verification, not package, cross-platform or live-Host acceptance. Integrate the reviewed feature branch locally after the frozen-source guard; next qualify the changed installer for a separately selected delivery. The user's DSH root cause still needs its actual diagnostics. No push, release, user-profile change or previous-release monitoring is included.
DSH 0.2.0-rc.2 Desktop launcher clarification
The user supplies Qiongli 2.5.0, DSH 0.2.0-rc.2 and desktop file, treated as selection of the desktop profile pending launcher/OS confirmation. After local 14b0ec33, the gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier downloads only public npm metadata, integrity-verified DSH rc.2 and Commander 15 packages into a private test area. It executes the exact published argument parser without invoking the manager or installing dependencies/profiles. Default npm mode rejects the requested argv with profile "desktop" is managed exclusively by the Electron application; Desktop opt-in accepts and forwards the same package/version/registry/flags. Public npm metadata confirms qiongli 2.5.0 exists. This establishes a reproducible launcher restriction, not the cause on a machine whose executable path is still unknown. type -a dsh and OS information are requested separately.
Extend the existing static diagnostic allowlist with that exact restriction and clarify the launcher distinction in both installation guides and the canonical npm README generator. Use Desktop's manager or its installed launcher for the reserved profile; changing to web would target another profile. No automatic launcher/profile switch, authorization bypass, registry change or real user installation is introduced. ADR 0238 retains ownership without a new decision. Focused follow-up verification and integration evidence follows below.
Follow-up checks pass: two Rust diagnostic/command-quoting tests, two existing README/channel and npm archive tests, generated npm 2.5.0 text inspection, formatting, CLI/library Clippy with denied warnings, seven roadmap tests, 249-task index consistency and whitespace. Independent gpt-6.1-sol / low review finds no actionable issue. Relative to 14b0ec33, the ledger changes only CLI-402 progress; all states, dependencies, acceptance, commit/run fields and dates stay unchanged. The prior 39-case and five-terminal behavioral results remain valid for unchanged installer control flow; no live Desktop-manager acceptance is added.
Evidence: /tmp/qiongli-dsh-rc2-diagnostic-20261008/followup-verification-summary.json, SHA-256 1d0083fdd30a84f43b9c805771d9fa34d6d88d3624641d7509a4c99c8b452679. It preserves separate original parser evidence, package integrity checks and source hashes. Integrate by local fast-forward after the frozen-source guard. Next resolve the user's actual launcher path or original manager error; release qualification remains separately scoped. No publication or installed profile change is included.
October 8 — DeepSeek installation step reporting
The maintainer requests complete flow printing because the failed installation stage remains invisible. Baseline is local fa7a87fb. Later user evidence resolves the earlier unknown launcher: macOS DeepSeek Desktop's bundled command was selected, Desktop was fully quit before both attempts, and the identical direct command installed qiongli 2.5.0 successfully. The earlier npm-entry/open-app hypotheses do not explain this case. The source audit confirms Qiongli's existing isolated environment, sorted reconstructed PATH, HOME working directory, null stdin, captured streams and 120-second limit; these are differences, not a confirmed root cause. No speculative environment change or reinstallation is part of this increment.
Under ADR 0238, expose twelve numbered stages with started/completed/skipped/ failed outcomes and elapsed time. Split actual postconditions into registration, package metadata/version, content receipt and language-write stages without weakening them or changing their error codes. Reuse the bounded command owner for version and manager calls; version probes retain both-stream UTF-8 checks. Show actual launcher context, environment key names (not credential values), captured byte counts and static recognized pnpm observations after capture. Retain command heartbeat, exact argv/retry guidance, declined/EOF handling and batch continuation. No raw output persistence, inferred internal failure stage, process/environment changes, new approval flow or live-session claim is added. The existing gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier owns focused checks and isolated terminal failure-stage cases; verification and local integration evidence follows below.
Verification passes 31 focused Rust cases: 21 Host/diagnostic cases, nine guide cases and one bounded-capture/descendant-pipe case. Six isolated terminal scenarios pass: command failure at step 8 followed by the next Host, bad receipt at 11, language CAS conflict at 12, all twelve stages for a fresh successful profile, decline at 5 without manager execution and invalid version at 2 without installation commands. Existing profiles skip initialization at 7. Failure stages retain their reason, subsequent stages do not claim success, and fixture secrets are not echoed. Stage 9/10/11 postcondition negatives are retained in the native test. These are fake-manager Linux ARM64 observations, not live macOS, DSH package/session or user-machine root-cause acceptance.
Formatting, CLI/library Clippy with denied warnings, seven roadmap tests, 249-task generated-index consistency, ledger invariants and whitespace checks pass. Independent gpt-6.1-sol / low change review finds no actionable issue. The final help sentence is checked in a separately rebuilt CLI after the frozen runtime-owner checks; unchanged runtime tests are reused. Only CLI-402 progress text changes in the ledger; task states, dependencies, accepted evidence, commit/run fields and dates are unchanged.
Retained setup/driver failures include rootless-container sandbox setup, a private fixture's initial writable mode, a reused test PID, human-text versus JSON expectations, help extraction/build timing and a fixed-index ledger lookup. Corrections affect only task fixtures/drivers; repository ancestor permissions, user data and original build artifacts remain unchanged. Private executable copies are stripped; task containers exit and the pre-existing container remains.
Evidence: /tmp/qiongli-dsh-step-trace-20261008/verification-summary.json, SHA-256 74cabecdb805768f56fe7323165beb944363fb3027e9ba39efa0e79365b5336a. It binds current runtime/help sources and distinguishes fresh/reused checks. Integrate through the authorized local feature-branch fast-forward after the frozen-source guard. Next qualify a separately selected CLI delivery and collect its stage output if the user's failure recurs. This CLI change requires a new build; reinstalling the existing 2.5.0 Plugin alone does not update its installer. No push, publication, real profile change or release monitoring occurs.
October 8 — local diagnostic CLI packaging
The user requests a locally packaged CLI and installation verification. Freeze runtime/content input at ce2c8d1ed48d5b57cf243f79a974cca9c4fb1aef; retain version 2.5.0 while labeling the output local.ce2c8d1e, explicitly distinct from the published 2.5.0 bytes. Build the native release CLI offline with Rust 1.97.0, locked dependencies, no default features and the embedded native source commit. Export embedded Plugin content through the existing example and package through the canonical portable/npm/Cargo staging owners. No native behavior changes.
An actual ELF inspection finds GLIBC_2.39 requirements, so the first portable/npm READMEs' generic glibc 2.35 claim is invalid for this host-built diagnostic binary. Retain that failed packaging observation; regenerate both packages with accurate Linux ARM64/glibc 2.39 notes. The npm composer gains an optional README argument; its default published-package description and all validation owners are unchanged. The corrected local recipe supplies this argument instead of editing generated payloads. BUILD.json binds the runtime commit, native binary, content pack, packaging script/recipe and three artifact digests. A staged source archive with a pinned CLI-only build helper is available for a separate Apple Silicon Mac build; it is not a prebuilt or verified Mac executable.
Fresh gpt-6.1-sol / low verification passes eleven registry packaging tests and clean offline installation from the corrected archives. Portable and npm CLI checks cover version, help, content, invalid commands, Lite 15/Full 35 local and stdio MCP tools. The npm ql alias and non-TTY postinstall pass without HOME changes. The installed DSH bundle loader exposes 22 Skills for auto/zh/en, rejects traversal and runs its selected Full MCP binary. Source helper shell syntax and staged offline/locked/no-deps Cargo metadata pass; no separate source compilation or macOS run is inferred from those checks.
Six synthetic DSH terminal cases also pass through the actual installed npm launcher: manager failure at stage 8 followed by the next Host, receipt failure at 11, language CAS conflict at 12, all twelve stages succeeding, decline at 5 and invalid version at 2. The existing 31 focused native tests are reused because runtime inputs are unchanged. The actual argv still selects public npm [email protected] with the same registry/ignore-scripts options; this local CLI package changes the installer diagnostics, not the Plugin selected by that command.
Corrected assets reside in /tmp/qiongli-local-cli-ce2c8d1e-20261008/corrected/assets/: portable SHA-256 faa4e142d63043e915046c1d448a99f7852c93fd7bde72033c31cb78ce19a7e7, npm 9f8f938a585e969706796a38f0c417aec7c8e1a37d2641ecffc4471a4465df16, source 57ad1f2010a698bd54111bf4e3df017ddfeda945847599daddb20a280016510a. The runtime binary SHA-256 is 3494a27c7ddae3d4ffa58797d6b68cd98b88518ab67f5ed8b47907f8e2a101a2. Evidence: /tmp/qiongli-local-cli-install-check-20261008/verification-summary.json, SHA-256 0e4a006f292c41b33b72aa2667933c9c33186fec11a75c8a6f32bee42f7edb66. It retains the initial README ABI mismatch and driver-only help-route failures, then binds corrected artifacts, drivers, recipe and reused native evidence.
These are host-local installation/protocol and fake-manager checks. No real DSH install/session, macOS compilation/runtime, release qualification, registry publication or user-machine diagnosis is claimed. Existing installations, profiles, credentials, models and task acceptance remain unchanged. The next increment is a Mac-native build and the user's real DSH retry with stage output; no push, publication or release monitoring is part of this task.
Final independent review finds no actionable issue. Seven roadmap tests, 249-task generated-index consistency, whitespace and ledger invariants pass; only CLI-402 progress text changes, with all task states, dependencies, accepted evidence, commit/run fields and dates preserved. Frozen report, artifact, recipe, packager and runtime hashes match. Integrate the packaging-description option and evidence bookkeeping through the authorized local fast-forward after the boundary guard; unchanged runtime/package results are reused.
October 8 — Apple Silicon diagnostic binary
The user asks for a directly usable macOS binary and confirms Apple Silicon. Freeze source at 66252b29f1d36f7ce8f374bb38a53571dcaa5a16. Cross-compile the CLI on Linux ARM64 using Rust 1.97.0, hash-pinned cargo-zigbuild 0.23.4/Zig 0.16.0 and the SDK 11.3 archive referenced by the upstream adapter's Dockerfile. Retain headers/framework link stubs, excluding unnecessary Swift modules. The locked, offline, release/no-default-features build succeeds in 6m59s; a disk-space guard never fires. Product sources are unchanged. The existing Linux content exporter is reused only after checking that native/content input is identical across ce2c8d1e and 66252b29; verify the actual Mac binary's embedded pack separately.
The first static check rejects the assumed macOS 11.0 package requirement: LC_BUILD_VERSION actually declares minimum 13.0.0 and SDK 26.4.0, despite the configured deployment target 11.0 and extracted framework SDK 11.3. Retain this mismatch and the initial artifacts. Regenerate portable/npm descriptions and BUILD.json for a macOS 13+ local diagnostic without relinking or changing the published release baseline. Record configured values separately from observed load commands. The user's system version is not yet established; ARM64 confirmation alone does not prove that this minimum is met.
Independent gpt-6.1-sol / low static verification passes ARM64_ALL/MH_EXECUTE, bounded load commands, dyld/entrypoint, system-only dylibs and no rpaths. The embedded ad-hoc SHA-256 CodeDirectory verifies all 5,675 code-page hashes and present special slots; this proves byte integrity, not Developer ID trust or Apple notarization. Parser fixtures reject page tampering, foreign architecture and truncated signatures. The exact 2,169,621-byte resource pack occurs once, with SHA-256 f2f8b22426fc3a8eea0600de7268de76988b6abefbdbe0abc2d81c5712e8eec7; the expected native source marker is present. Actual streamed archive contents match the native bytes, with correct executable mode, darwin/arm64 npm metadata, qiongli/ql aliases, 22 Skill files and receipt source/content hashes. No SDK is bundled. These are static checks, not a Mac npm install or loader execution.
Corrected assets: /tmp/qiongli-macos-cli-66252b29-20261008/corrected-assets/. Portable SHA-256: f7656d0c3e0b200b5a99ba42372d7b8061a1e85846e224d844bf24719a5bd8e3. Npm SHA-256: 76b00a172a3101eba4f4f61b3d6eac29935f4ceddd0023a0d8ca07ceed33b9b9. Native SHA-256: c329fa09b6cf6267a28a1b1e6cba8ab94e426f35a79f75ad1968bd7898d5ba01. Frozen report: /tmp/qiongli-macos-cli-66252b29-20261008/verification/verification-summary.json, SHA-256 40f25513baeb326c4fa84125388a1fe1a286530f9c5aba6696cb6038f20bbe0f. The packet retains build/export commands, results, tool/SDK provenance, initial minimum-version mismatch, corrected recipes, artifacts and verification drivers. Task-owned tool/SDK extraction, Zig caches and unpacked npm staging are removed after checks to restore disk space; archives, source SDK archive, metadata, native binary and all evidence remain. No unrelated build cache is deleted.
Ready for a user-run macOS 13+ diagnostic trial only. Mac execution, installation, Gatekeeper, Keychain and real DSH session outcomes remain unrun; the preceding Linux tests are baseline evidence, not Mac acceptance. The installer still requests public [email protected]. Next run the binary on the Mac and capture the real DSH stage outcome with Desktop fully quit. No native behavior change, real profile/credential/model change, publication or release monitoring is included.
Final independent documentation review finds no actionable issue. Seven roadmap tests, generated-index consistency, whitespace and all 249 ledger invariants pass; only CLI-402 progress changes. Retained artifacts, native binary, recipe and report hashes match. Integrate this evidence-only increment by authorized local fast-forward after the boundary guard, reusing unchanged verification.
October 8 — 2.5.1 installation release handoff
The maintainer supplies a successful real Mac installation trace and requests a new release, ending once the release task is dispatched without follow-up monitoring. This authorizes reviewed source synchronization, main cutover, an immutable v2.5.1 tag and the existing release-automation post task. Announcements, external Marketplace promotion and remote-rule changes remain outside scope. Reuse this bounded plan and the existing four-target publication gates.
Baseline is 1c8c1fbaae9183b9d06a412145fba62e584f1d26. Version 2.5.1 delivers the automatic Host/source selection, resilient batch flow, bounded manager progress and twelve-stage DSH diagnostics developed after 2.5.0. Use canonical version synchronization and content-pack generation; writing guidance and research contracts otherwise retain their 2.5.0 behavior. Update current installation and upgrade instructions without rewriting previous release notes or ADR history.
The attached trace reports CLI 2.5.0, DSH 0.2.0-rc.2 and the Desktop-owned launcher on the maintainer's Apple Silicon Mac. Stages 1–6 and 8–12 succeed; stage 7 is skipped for an existing desktop profile. The official manager exits zero in 2.90s, followed by registration, package/entry, receipt and language checks; the final summary is one installed and zero failures. Record only a sanitized observation and raw-log hash, not the user's home paths or full trace in public documentation. This is user-reported real installation/registration success for a diagnostic CLI installing public 2.5.0. The log supplies no executable digest, and explicitly leaves new-session Skills/MCP unchecked. It does not qualify new 2.5.1 bytes or establish the earlier intermittent failure's root cause.
/tmp/qiongli-251-release-20261008/user-install-observation.json retains the bounded observation. Fresh gpt-6.1-sol / low work verifies version-sensitive contracts, generated content and the candidate's Linux ARM64/glibc2.35 packages through the existing release owner. Reuse unchanged focused installer results as behavioral evidence only. Exact-tag four-target qualification remains inside the publication task. Checks, source bindings and remaining gaps are recorded below before dispatch; pending work is not a pass. Program acceptance remains intact.
Candidate checks and handoff
Clean isolated candidate 575b74e2e8004a66990b768f0e41a8e501899732 passes the canonical CLI release owner under Linux ARM64/glibc2.35 and Rust1.97. Fresh checks include version preflight, 22 Python release contracts, strict workspace CLI Clippy/format, 47 CLI and 9 MCP integration tests, archive extraction, offline npm/wheel installations and Codex/Claude Plugin packages. Installed Lite/Full retain 15/35 tools; the npm DSH bundle loader retains 22 Skills. These package checks do not establish a live DSH model/session result. The unchanged 31 focused installer tests remain prior behavioral evidence, separate from this fresh candidate qualification.
The regenerated pack contains 446 canonical entries, source 6b4ded163d5d00b743b65ab53fb258bcfbff6966, content root 2b6c96406ac9101fc7314853c0aa01a16c561a3170b71d3a12c7fcaa696c97e4 and pack digest bc0d7245411a7aa346bdfacfa7e9bda05c42f0a4a56dc362836206499ac74187. Independent archive inspection verifies all five artifact hashes/sizes and identical native payloads, embedded pack/source marker and Plugin receipt bindings. ELF requires at most glibc2.34; the qualified distribution retains its declared glibc2.35 baseline.
Offline npm and pip upgrades from retained, previously qualified 2.5.0 packages at cfbb897c40b90e300e15be99aafc630081cfb5ec to this 2.5.1 candidate pass, preserving the synthetic research/source/model-setting canaries byte-for-byte. The temporary driver substitutes verified local predecessor copies for download only and keeps the canonical install/upgrade/canary checks. It does not establish current public-registry predecessor identity or research-format migration.
Evidence root: /tmp/qiongli-251-release-20261008/:
verification-summary.json, SHA-25615341c3e2820359c30e7c1007b27d1b89f3c04b1e3518ef0d98c1456b0e0e07d;linux-arm64-glibc235/assets/release-manifest.json, SHA-2568f9780f58eb17c59a4075559425ad7789a4d213d54e292a83b2d7df00ccccb81;artifact-audit.json, SHA-256ddbfd8d794617f0141c80004e2a5db6f69ab915c9b5f24817313421b31c831c1;retained250-upgrade-result.json, SHA-2564d058251a98d68471cbdb2d479b3e0adae5c8443fc1a602717dc67c91a3584e4;user-install-observation.json, SHA-25641fb89523afa9040608151a312e8d28efa076c10871a8c7e0ba793d20ac733a7.
Initial driver setup mistakes are retained separately from product outcomes. The release owner completes without a product failure. Two unused compiler incremental-cache directories are removed with incremental compilation disabled, recovering about 1.8 GB while preserving source, binaries, artifacts and reports. The isolated source remains unchanged. Final bookkeeping changes only this plan, CLI-402 progress and its generated index; acceptance states and evidence remain unchanged, and unaffected native checks are reused.
The requested next operation is reviewed local main fast-forward, source push, immutable v2.5.1 tag and release-automation.yml post dispatch. Final-tag four-target qualification and registry publication remain workflow-owned gates; the local Linux candidate and user-reported diagnostic Mac run do not replace them. Stop once dispatch is accepted, without release/registry monitoring. An accepted task request is not evidence of completed publication. AGY/Pi remain experimental, live DSH session use remains unchecked, and no program acceptance, announcement or external Marketplace promotion is implied.
October 8 — compact installation display
The maintainer reports that released 2.5.1 installs smoothly but its output is crowded and continuously scrolls. Baseline is local 1f2035494c7febe87e7c5f76c480b144b41d1c43. Use the existing CLI-402 owner and ADR 0239 for this display-only increment; do not monitor the preceding release, publish another version or modify real Host profiles. Official managers, approval/CAS, receipts, error codes, model settings and batch continuation retain their existing behavior.
Independent gpt-6.1-sol / low reproduces the old display with a safe fake DSH and the qualified 2.5.1 binary: success produces 93 lines/6,545 bytes, 12 START lines and three launch-context blocks. The longest line is 458 characters; the rough 80-column row budget is 124. A failed manager plus later-Host attempt produces 82 lines/5,890 bytes and two context blocks. No ANSI redraw is present: repeated append-only diagnostics, rather than cursor manipulation, explain this fixture's scrolling. These are synthetic measurements, not captures from the user's Mac. Evidence is retained under /tmp/qiongli-install-ui-20261008/.
Implement a shared presentation writer over the existing command progress owner. Group Hosts and preview/progress/summary sections; keep full mutation previews, each DSH result and exact failures. Hide duplicate START, successful launch contexts and completed export receipts unless --verbose is selected. Failures automatically expand safe diagnostics and commands. Use one short ASCII waiting line only on supported, sufficiently wide Unix terminals. --plain, verbose, NO_COLOR, CI and unsupported/narrow consoles use append-only output. Installation remains terminal-only; flags never approve a write or alter structured dry-runs. Also correct the stale 33-tool presentation labels to the existing Full35 count.
Design follows the primary-source examples linked in ADR 0239: pnpm terminal vs append-only reporters, Clack task/result separation and GitHub CLI verbosity/ accessible progress controls. Keep native Rust ownership and use only a feature of the already-present rustix dependency for actual terminal width.
Validate compact and verbose PTY journeys against the preserved baseline, actual width/resize and prompt behavior, long waits, failure attribution/privacy, later Hosts, decline/EOF/output errors and redirected refusal. Run affected parser, renderer and installation regressions; preserve fixture/setup failures instead of hiding them. Record results and remaining target-native/manual gaps below once at integration. Local output improvements do not establish live-Host or release acceptance; all task states and accepted evidence remain unchanged.
Implemented result and verification
The shared display writer now keeps one short current-step/elapsed-time line on supported Unix terminals, clears it before prompts/results, and falls back to plain output when width, environment or user options require it. It never enters raw mode, hides the cursor or clears previous output. --verbose retains detailed diagnostics; --plain retains concise append-only output. Official-manager arguments, approval previews/digests and per-Host retry behavior remain unchanged.
Independent gpt-6.1-sol / low reports 43 distinct affected Rust tests passing, including shared Host compatibility and bounded command execution. Eight tests affected by the final current-step label change are rerun; unchanged checks are reused. 21 final terminal/refusal cases pass, covering 80/40-column terminals, resize, plain/verbose modes, unsupported environments, long waits, staged failures, continuation, declined approval, EOF, narrow terminals and redirected input. A process-group SIGINT case exits without reporting success; this does not qualify actual keyboard/foreground-terminal signal routing. An additional fixed profile/executable comparison proves identical approval text and digest across all three display modes, with every preview declined and no manager invoked.
The successful synthetic transcript falls from 93 to 54 persistent lines; the longest line falls from 458 to 129 characters and the estimated 80-column row budget from 124 to 63. These counts interpret CR/erase-line sequences, not a full emulator or a screenshot. Formatter, strict all-target CLI Clippy, four frozen architecture tests and ADR validation pass. Source inspection and unit coverage support fallback behavior; no macOS/Windows runtime, real Host profile, authentication, model/session call or release artifact is qualified here.
Frozen evidence: /tmp/qiongli-install-ui-20261008/verification-summary.json, SHA-256 3b18827e62634d01fcf2fec7c6f12e16022ea5bcb47dd78275926e267a81fe0f. It binds each changed native source to the tested debug binary and complete private stripped copy; this is a working-tree source binding, not a claim that a later bookkeeping commit was compiled. Retained setup failures include fixture reuse/timing/assertions and disk exhaustion. Earlier partial-copy terminal runs are excluded; all 21 final cases use the complete hash-bound binary. Scoped cleanup removes only inactive retained debug caches and the task's partial copy, preserving source, release artifacts, reports and the active build target.
Integrate locally after final ledger/index and diff review. The next delivery increment should qualify these bytes on release targets and collect a real Mac terminal observation. No new release, remote push or preceding-release monitoring is part of this request; program states and accepted evidence stay unchanged.
October 8 — 2.5.2 display release handoff
The maintainer authorizes committing and triggering the next release CI task, then ending the conversation without follow-up monitoring. Prepare stable 2.5.2 from integrated edf1864a, using the existing CLI release and publishing owners. Synchronize canonical versions, generated Skills references and embedded resource pack, freeze release notes, then qualify a clean candidate through ./scripts/release_ready.sh --cli-github --version 2.5.2 --staging-dir <new-external-dir>. Retain full release gates and separate new package qualification from the preceding 43 focused Rust tests and 21 synthetic terminal cases. Use gpt-6.1-sol / low for verification, preserving initial setup failures and remaining runtime gaps.
This release covers installation presentation, verbosity/plain options and the stale Full MCP count correction. Existing approval/CAS, official manager commands, source ownership, models, batch recovery and research schemas remain unchanged. AGY/Pi stay experimental, Mac terminal interaction and live DSH/session behavior remain separate observations, and Full/Lite retain 35/15 tools. Rollback retains the prior executable and Plugin sources/settings; it does not reverse research writes. The existing four-target release workflow owns final-tag qualification, public downloads and registry publication. Do not skip checks, retag a published version, promote program acceptance or modify external Marketplace catalogs.
Record candidate results below once available; pending checks are not a pass. After reviewed local integration, fast-forward main, push the source and immutable v2.5.2 tag, dispatch release-automation.yml at that tag in post mode and stop as soon as the dispatch is accepted. No subsequent release/registry monitoring is requested, and accepted dispatch must not be reported as completed publication.
Candidate checks and handoff
Clean candidate f6c823bfa77eb38e32bec2861f43a33335501b0f passes the canonical release owner under actual Linux ARM64/glibc 2.35 and Rust 1.97. Independent gpt-6.1-sol / low verifies version preflight, 22 Python release contracts, formatter/strict workspace CLI Clippy, 47 CLI and 9 MCP integration tests, archive extraction, isolated npm/wheel installations and Codex/Claude Plugin packages. Installed Lite/Full retain 15/35 tools; the npm DSH bundle loader retains 22 Skills. The unchanged 43 focused native tests and 21 synthetic terminal cases remain prior behavior evidence, separate from this fresh package qualification.
All five actual artifacts have verified sizes/hashes and identical native payloads (41ce49e4b9c0cbb68d760f3c6c2c1f7c230fd50f6492c7ec535c52c1b9caf898). Independent inspection verifies Plugin receipts and embedded source/resource bindings. The pack contains 446 entries, source 5b7c297103c71d9da37728cf9993b9cf4166dc1d, content root e6af690492e1dfb1e5680376d4373f5bd841243b4507805a8a895fa6690e3397 and pack digest 1cc804ed9f4f3ee151c9d51a4cb8066bc91fe4ecb4d170d6af2dfc69f407e270. ELF requires at most glibc 2.34; qualification and wheel metadata retain the published glibc 2.35 baseline.
Offline npm/pip upgrades from retained, locally qualified 2.5.1 packages at 575b74e2e8004a66990b768f0e41a8e501899732 pass and preserve all three synthetic research/source/model-setting canaries. Only the download step uses verified retained bytes; the canonical upgrade/install/canary checks remain intact. This is not verification of the current public predecessor or research-format migration.
Frozen evidence root: /tmp/qiongli-252-release-20261008/:
verification-summary.json, SHA-256eccb570c406cf3241e02a3f11e6536ab5c922d1f408ed5f34e93b142f90de15b;linux-arm64-glibc235/assets/release-manifest.json, SHA-25660ff185333eca0c2a6c68c4fffe1f2e2b5473cec3105939cf910d7162c0613e7;artifact-audit.json, SHA-25606fe607cc541605e4a748039f2f1e35fe62f4231bc02fad0f64be3603c12c4c7;retained251-upgrade-result.json, SHA-256a6a873864620d5fde40a8b4893331ac5f024756c61bb16e9a767e8d3e69cafee.
Initial checks racing content-lock generation, an incorrect preflight entry and a detached snapshot refused by the release owner are retained as setup failures; the final clean branch runs pass without bypassing checks. Scoped cleanup removes 216 inactive product compiler cache files (4,071,638,994 bytes), preserving all executables, source, release caches/artifacts, reports, registry and user data. Final bookkeeping changes only this plan, CLI-402 progress and its generated index; program states, dependencies, accepted evidence and commit/run fields stay intact.
The next authorized action is local main fast-forward, source/tag push and the existing v2.5.2 release task. Its final-tag four-target, public-download and registry gates remain mandatory; local Linux qualification does not establish native Mac terminal behavior, Windows/Linux x64 acceptance or live Host/session use. Stop on accepted dispatch and report that handoff only, without follow-up monitoring.
October 9 — DeepSeek latest terminal installation
The maintainer requests the normal dsh plugin --profile desktop add qiongli@<latest exact version> installation and fewer scrolling messages/inputs. Use the current installation owners under ADR 0240: bounded public npm latest lookup before approval, frozen stable version, existing executable/profile CAS, no appended registry/scripts flags, and native DSH terminal/environment handoff. Default to the initialized Desktop profile, allowing explicit web/custom choices; reuse valid stored language or locale for a DSH-only install, with explicit language overrides. Ordinary failures continue the batch; interruptions stop it.
Keep Qiongli output to the approval summary, failures and final result, with full stage details in verbose mode. Clear its progress before DSH owns the terminal; DSH/pnpm controls its own rendering, prompts and download cache. No latest-version cache may silently cause a stale installation. Verify the approved package version and source pack independently of the old CLI's embedded pack. This is source consistency, not registry origin/generated-executable attestation; official DSH owns package download integrity and the release owner retains full projection qualification. Preserve real profiles and model settings during isolated checks.
Public latest metadata read for this request reports 2.5.1. That observation is not monitoring or a diagnosis of the preceding release task. The latest user Mac failure has no new error trace and remains unreproduced. Use gpt-6.1-sol / low for focused tests and review, recording actual results and remaining gaps below once available. Integrate scoped local commits into 2.x; no push, version bump or new publication is requested, and all existing program acceptance states remain intact.
Focused checks and integration
Independent gpt-6.1-sol / low verification passes 23 focused checks: six DSH lookup/approval/content tests, one explicitly run retained real npm bundle test, one explicitly run prompt-driven PTY test, nine installation-guide tests, three manager-diagnostic tests and three renderer tests. The package check uses the retained locally qualified 2.5.2 artifact, not an asserted public download. The PTY confirms inherited terminal input/output, progress cleared before the native prompt, a reply sent only after that prompt, and no competing Qiongli timer. Eight unaffected guide results are reused; the updated duplicate-output assertion passes separately against a refreshed test binary. Strict CLI-library Clippy, final formatter/diff checks and architecture validation (7 frozen/40 current ADRs) pass. Review finds no remaining actionable issue in the scoped behavior.
Initial fixture/implementation checks expose a canonical mapping error for non-workflow resource paths; both now follow the packaging owner's optional prefix removal, and the retained real package passes. The old per-Host duplicate success assertion and missing ADR registry entry are also repaired. These initial failures remain in the report rather than being counted as successful runs.
Evidence: /tmp/qiongli-dsh-latest-20261009/verification-summary.json, SHA-256 1843982a83899b27565ac3b3bd27b261a3723e5ca5ecd22c74e8f524943fcea1; source-bindings.json in the same directory, SHA-256 42cd7aeb0a187131086e03d5db6e124be75b6de433c5e8e0cb3d52479ad47062. The report binds individual logs and source files. No live DSH/Mac installation, new-session tools, registry-origin attestation or release qualification is claimed. The next independent observation is the updated installer on the maintainer's Mac; package/release qualification belongs to a separately authorized release. This increment ends after reviewed local integration into 2.x. Program states, accepted evidence, dependency and commit/run fields remain unchanged.
October 9 — 2.5.3 release handoff
The maintainer authorizes the next patch release from integrated 02b37c2c, source/tag push and execution of release automation, then ending without following its progress. Prepare stable 2.5.3 through canonical version synchronization, resource-pack binding and frozen release notes. A gpt-6.1-sol / low verifier runs fresh candidate checks with the existing release_ready.sh --cli-github owner under Linux ARM64/glibc 2.35, reusing its verified environment/cache. Retain mandatory package, install, receipt, version and upgrade gates. Prior 23 focused behavior checks remain separately identified; no unrun native Mac/DSH session check or registry-origin attestation becomes a pass.
The release changes DSH package installation to approved exact latest-version argv and native terminal interaction, reduces routine output, reuses saved language and removes the running-CLI version/pack binding. Version/profile probes retain their existing safety checks; initialization output stays captured. Research schemas, model choices and other Host execution contracts remain unchanged. Full/Lite retain 35/15 tools, AGY/Pi stay experimental, and the target set remains macOS ARM64, Windows x64 and Linux x64/ARM64 (glibc 2.35+). Preserve previous executables, Plugin sources and research/settings backups for rollback; changing executables does not undo research writes.
After reviewed local integration and candidate qualification, fast-forward local main, atomically push main and immutable v2.5.3, then dispatch release-automation.yml at that tag in post mode with create_release=true. Its four-target qualification, public-download and registry gates remain mandatory. Stop on accepted dispatch without polling runs, releases or package publication. Program task states, accepted evidence and commit/run fields remain unchanged.
Candidate qualification and final handoff
Independent gpt-6.1-sol / low qualification passes against clean candidate cd76e8c1739871bc9ad7b874673feb5cc07352cc with the canonical release_ready.sh --cli-github --version 2.5.3 owner on Linux ARM64/glibc 2.35. The run passes 22 Python release contracts, formatting, strict workspace CLI Clippy, 47 release-profile CLI tests and nine MCP tests. Actual archive, npm, wheel and Codex/Claude Plugin installation checks pass, including empty-PATH archive execution, DSH bundle-loader isolation (22 Skills/35 Full MCP) and receipt/projection checks. The five native payloads share SHA-256 100fd77ec27c806b5859a5b584afaa74f2c5d12454b1314a3846afc201ee0c07. Independent artifact/source/pack/ELF checks pass; the observed highest required GLIBC symbol version is 2.34 and the declared release baseline remains 2.35.
The 446-entry 2.5.3 pack binds content source 8184d476de021aa577e3d19a0b44d3e1b0246da4, content root b1187a17633a1e5d5258d85965b83abade6029e8431b2f61c1baeb4d43684ae0 and pack SHA-256 817a4767f8e9ebbe11c935cbf0a1aab885db429fbd9343bbbb0afb654cce3d86. Retained locally qualified 2.5.2-to-2.5.3 npm/pip upgrades pass using the existing upgrade owner and hash-verified local download bytes. Three synthetic research/source/model-settings canaries remain intact. This does not assert the identity of a current public predecessor download.
Initial setup failures remain recorded: an incorrect unittest module/preflight argument was corrected before the canonical run. The first clone inherited 775 directory permissions and correctly hit three security refusals (44/47 CLI tests passed). Correcting 519 task-clone directories, without changing repository/user ancestors, product source or gates, allowed the complete owner to pass again in a new staging directory. No failed run is counted as a pass or hidden by a skip.
Frozen evidence: /tmp/qiongli-253-release-20261009/verification-summary.json, SHA-256 9ccc822aec2590d6996cb888aa3aeeef85b29f4e93b243780d0d90372d10b496. Its source bindings and individual logs retain the setup observations. Under the same evidence root, artifact-audit.json has SHA-256 9fd127ab4d762be159c2858b28aa2884d36ac42670b40e3574c1c5f5c5e0ebf1 and retained252-upgrade-result.json has SHA-256 6ca6d300061aa099dd636a54d02c2eeeaabbad3114bbbe53ae551230a4c88956. The qualified linux-arm64-glibc235-secure/assets/release-manifest.json has SHA-256 bde19af0bd14348157d1a2a0ff0ad6568a4179827768691d4ba6a8d5d3ea825d.
This establishes local Linux ARM64 qualification only. Real macOS/DSH sessions, authentication/model calls, public downloads and registry publication remain unverified. The preceding 23 focused behavior checks are reused separately. Final bookkeeping changes only this plan, CLI-402 progress and its generated index; program states, dependencies, accepted evidence and commit/run fields stay intact. The authorized next action is reviewed local fast-forward integration, atomic main/v2.5.3 push and the existing post-mode release automation dispatch. Exact-tag four-target/public-download/registry gates remain mandatory. Stop on accepted dispatch without following the run or claiming publication completion.
October 9 — Unified provider configuration entry
The maintainer authorizes filling the native CLI/Plugin provider setup gap. The current native ConfigureProvider/SaveProvider paths refuse despite documentation promising a local setup page. Add qiongli provider setup with optional provider selection, offline status/doctor, and explicitly approved bounded test. CLI and its Lite/Full MCP profiles share one tokenized loopback setup owner, global settings/CAS and the existing OS secret-store facade. Native MCP accepts secrets only through the local page; the legacy raw-value save tool redirects callers to that page. Preserve the public tool inventory and compatibility alias.
A page previews one selected provider, accepts explicit user confirmation, and updates that provider only. Empty key fields retain existing credentials; removing a key is explicit. Rotation, failed writes and concurrent settings changes retain rollback/no-lost-update checks. Keys stay outside ordinary config, research artifacts, output and errors. macOS uses the existing Keychain implementation; other platforms retain explicit secure-store-unavailable behavior until their separate backend exists. Refresh running native MCP configuration after a save and after external settings changes; never cache stale credential access.
Use gpt-6.1-sol / low for isolated meaningful checks/review, including actual HTTP/MCP/CLI flows, token/origin/Host/size/timeout refusals, stale revisions, missing storage, rollback, canary redaction and unchanged unrelated settings. No user credentials, real profiles, online authentication or preceding release monitoring is needed. Integrate reviewed scoped local commits into 2.x; a new version, push and publication remain separately scoped. Record final results and remaining target-native gaps once at integration, without acceptance promotion.
Focused verification and local integration
Independent gpt-6.1-sol / low verification passes 43 Rust cases against the final development pack: 11 new provider setup cases, three existing provider transaction owner cases, nine native MCP stdio cases, two provider-runtime cases, six affected CLI cases and 12 shared Lite MCP cases. The new cases exercise actual loopback HTTP, approval/token/Host/Origin/size/deadline refusals, stale revisions, unavailable storage, rotation/write/read-back/CAS compensation, explicit removal and committed cleanup failures. Same-session metadata refresh, external revision changes and redaction pass. A selected-provider loopback test proves one bounded Crossref request with empty successful results and zero requests to other providers. Loaded-secret cache replacement is reviewed; real credentials are not read.
Six actual private CLI flows pass, including offline status/doctor, help, missing network confirmation and a confirmed Crossref page save followed by clean process exit. Two existing Skill resource-link checks, strict library Clippy, formatting, ADR validation and whitespace checks pass. Independent final behavior/ownership/ documentation review has no actionable findings. These are focused development checks, not release qualification.
The shared routing reference had a stale native-unavailable/legacy-only rule. Reviewed content commit fd79b388b9f7054f2122eb3f87fb32031ed69c05 replaces it with runtime-gated local-page guidance, user-only key entry and old/standalone Lite fallbacks. The existing resource-lock owner regenerates the local 446-entry pack: content root cdd2b6317c6e0a32b3f960fbad60fffdd647c4b39f2d282e9fdad73d7a761290, pack 3e811a75863abc088565724e7c67fd0aef2ea5cd88eb90581edf2df4ebf61e8c. Actual compiled CLI bytes contain that complete pack and its routing reference matches canonical bytes. The development version remains 2.5.3/Unreleased; this new local pack does not replace the immutable v2.5.3 tag/resource identity.
Frozen evidence: /tmp/qiongli-provider-setup-20261009/verification-summary.json, SHA-256 e5d13710bab5e96f3714740dfbbd553d4b3fadd18656364ac00ca04db5f3c060. Its source-bindings.json has SHA-256 bc31283e8950edc97db7e8048dd73307ace61ef54f5c0038ff2aae2dfbad64d1; the actual pack audit has SHA-256 33d956e61be27e1a64cf83a2e3d679a4c68579600bb604a94b79a5f37737bf14. Frozen source bindings precede this integration bookkeeping and the provider guides' tag-status wording correction. Runtime, tests, canonical content and resource-lock inputs remain unchanged; those focused results are reused. Initial compile errors, fixture reset/unsupported arXiv argument/CAS-code assertions, the concurrent short fixture timeout, sandbox loopback refusal and ADR/audit/format invocation failures remain recorded. Corrected fixtures use bounded waits and serialized execution without changing production deadlines; the actual CLI passes with authorized isolated loopback access. No failed attempt is counted as passing or hidden by a skip.
Real macOS Keychain, OS browser launch/navigation, Host sessions, online provider authentication and release packaging remain unrun. Windows/Linux secret backends remain unavailable. CLI-hosted Lite/Full and the bundled Full Plugin use the new owner; the separate standalone Lite runtime retains unavailable setup. The next increment is target-native Mac/Plugin configuration and credential-rotation verification, followed by separately authorized release qualification. Integrate the reviewed scoped commits locally into 2.x; no version bump, push, publication, preceding-release monitoring or program task/dependency/accepted-evidence/commit/ run-field promotion is included.
October 19 — G4/J2 language editing and meaning review
The maintainer requests the proposed G4/J2 rule changes, Chinese/English examples, validation and local integration into 2.x, with no publication. Canonical source commit 553a1125179c5b86388cf19f79e83862e42ae6d8 removes G4's per-claim hedge rule, fixed shortening target and word blacklist. G4 makes evidence-backed calibration proposals; J2 edits language, then compares meaning against the original. A comparison-only request returns concrete drift and minimal repairs, preserving valid direct wording. Shared scholarly-voice guidance owns both responsibilities, paragraph-level edits, consequential uncertainty and an optional authorized Codex/Antigravity handoff. No Host launcher or automatic transfer is added.
The rubric, stage references, workflow, registry, capability summaries and generated bilingual Skill guide inherit the same policy. Task IDs, artifact types/paths, configured models and preview/approval/CAS owners remain compatible. The content distribution contract records this ownership. The resource lock is regenerated through update_qiongli_core_lock, retaining local version 2.5.3 and 446 entries, with source 553a1125, content root 54a9436497108940a21bb344af5d983acc82e0241d4f7bacc82af46f1e9f2e53 and pack 7f26315350a76980413c53d6384302476018635dd9d1cd921746c1983f8ec27d. This local development pack does not replace the immutable released pack.
Behavioral verification
Cases D–J extend the existing evals/research_journey/writing-quality/ tasks and review criteria. One independent agent context receives frozen guidance and synthetic tasks, without the criteria, patch discussion or intended answers. Original answers and input SHA-256 bindings are retained in evals/research_journey/writing-quality/observations/g4-j2-2026-10-19.json, SHA-256 7aec51c5bc7eac9f4f439128f8e1426820abdc699c41815b8a712550ebaaefcb. The coordinator reviews every original against its task and criteria; all seven pass within this scope, with no post-review answer correction:
| Case | Scope / requested flow / meaning | Concrete answer evidence |
|---|---|---|
| D | Pass / pass / pass | “86家本地企业中,X与Y呈正相关” retains r = 0.27, p = .02, [D1] and the cross-sectional causal limit without stacked hesitation. |
| E | Pass / pass / pass | “We interviewed each of 60 nurses at one hospital” connects to 41 reports; “may contribute” and “has not been tested [E2]” retain the untested explanation. |
| F | Pass / not requested / pass | “No meaning drift was found” preserves the per-plant denominator, timing and citation without a replacement paragraph. |
| G | Pass / not requested / pass | Findings identify “相关关系改为因果效应”, coefficient-to-27% substitution, missing p value/causal limit, universal scope and reversal of an unexcluded explanation; repairs restore only affected spans. |
| H | Pass / not requested / pass | “Replace ‘weeks’ with ‘days’” plus separate findings restore attribution, the lack of established equivalence and interview preference instead of a demonstrated symptom effect. |
| I | Pass / not requested / pass | “Adding ‘may’ would not supply the missing evidence” accompanies an explicit substantive correction; the 72/120 observation and untested procurement explanation remain intact. |
| J | Pass / not requested / pass | “缺少原稿。请提供与这句话对应的原文” requests the missing input without claiming a completed comparison. |
This is an independent-context instruction trial with coordinator review, not an installed Codex/Antigravity journey, different-model comparison, human expert acceptance or measured improvement over a baseline. No private manuscript or external research source is used in the behavioral trial; user Host configuration remains unchanged.
Contract checks and integration
The affected Skill contract, workflow document, resource-link and generated-guide suites pass 19 tests. Capability Contract v2 validation passes. The broad research validator reports 6,123 passes, six failures and fourteen warnings. All six failures reproduce from byte-identical 2.x inputs: meta-optimizer.md lacks Purpose/Process headings and the 2.5.3 release note lacks four legacy format tokens. The unchanged validator and failing files were compared directly with the base; no unrelated cleanup or passing full-validator claim is included.
The ten bounded cross-platform routing checks pass. The existing portable materialization owner reproduces all nine changed canonical resources byte for byte. Native qiongli-content deterministic writer, embedded service and loader suites pass 16 tests, including source/digest drift, corrupted manifests, unsafe paths and resource limits. Seven program-ledger tests and index freshness pass. Together the affected automated suites pass 52 tests; capability validation and actual portable-resource equality are separate checks.
The full routing suite was interrupted during Plugin materialization; a clean tracked-source retry also exceeded its 120-second bound and its process group was stopped. That projection invokes the Lite binary builder. This full test is not counted as passing; the ten selected routing checks and portable-content projection above do not claim a full Plugin binary build. Native CLI --test embedded_pack compilation failed with No space left on device before execution. Only this run's incremental files and the interrupted test checkout's Lite build target were removed; the smaller content suites then passed with CARGO_INCREMENTAL=0. No full rebuilt CLI or release-package claim is made. The local commit initially lacked Git author configuration; the retry uses the repository's existing Codex identity for that command only.
Final source review finds no actionable request-fidelity, compatibility or meaning-review regressions within the checked scope. The integration uses scoped local commits and the frozen-source guard before fast-forwarding 2.x; unchanged checks are reused. The existing six full-validator failures and the uncompleted binary-build checks remain recorded rather than reclassified as passes.
Next is an explicitly authorized real-manuscript comparison using the user's chosen Antigravity model, judging readable flow and semantic fidelity separately. No task state, accepted evidence, remote branch, tag or release is promoted.
October 20 — writing validation completion
The maintainer authorizes cleanup of regenerable build caches, completion of the two interrupted checks, repair of all six baseline failures and local integration into 2.x. Source commit da522d997d9b6c322bee72b2fa15a530c7a18ca2 adds the missing Purpose/Process headings to meta-optimizer without changing its prose or output contract. The research validator now applies native release-note structure under ADR 0219 to native checkouts and retains the four legacy token checks for the retained line. Native notes need a matching version, linked verification evidence, publication guidance and rollback guidance. Local evidence files must resolve inside the checkout; web evidence is not fetched. The existing 2.5.3 release note and publication authority remain unchanged.
Only ignored native target/debug/deps and target/debug/incremental caches were removed, recovering approximately 25 GB. Release artifacts, other target trees and research files were preserved. Available space rose from about 1 GB to 26 GB; 24 GB remains after rebuilding. Native checks use CARGO_INCREMENTAL=0 and two build jobs; Plugin materialization uses four jobs and offline Cargo. No product timeouts were changed. The previously interrupted full Plugin test now completes in 351 seconds, beyond the earlier 120-second execution bound.
The supported update_qiongli_core_lock generator binds the unchanged local version 2.5.3 and 446 resources to source da522d99, content root 50e5cb0afc5113e2490ba05dc9761f603f6a52d57c6c885ff3275167ff0c8423 and pack c888ac2ec572f71366483a0c9bc23f1d02ecf8d9b26b770a5fbaae5bc4c2bd11. This development binding does not replace an immutable released pack.
Completed checks:
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
python3 -m unittest tests.test_research_standard_validator tests.test_release_note_versions | 26 pass, including missing native evidence/guidance, invalid version, missing/outside evidence files, malformed links and retained legacy failures |
python3 -m unittest tests.test_skill_structure_lint | 8 pass |
python3 scripts/validate_research_standard.py | 6,130 pass, zero failures, 14 existing warnings |
python3 -m unittest tests.test_cross_platform_routing_grill_contract | All 11 pass, including actual Plugin materialization and Lite binary compilation |
Native cargo test --offline -p qiongli --test embedded_pack | 1 pass after a successful 6m 14s compilation |
Native cargo test --offline -p qiongli-content --test resource_pack_loader --test deterministic_writer --test embedded_content | 16 pass, retaining digest/source drift, corrupt manifests, path and resource-limit negative cases |
python3 -m unittest tests.test_program_roadmap and python3 tooling/scripts/update_program_roadmap.py --check | 7 pass; generated index current for all 249 tasks |
The focused suites total 69 passing tests; the broad validator is counted separately. Python tests use the repository Python source path where required; native Cargo commands use --manifest-path packages/qiongli-native/Cargo.toml. Logs remain in /tmp/qiongli-*-20261020.log and /tmp/qiongli-validation-repair-unit.log as local observations. The earlier timeout and disk failures remain recorded above; these completed checks supersede their open validation gaps without deleting them. The 14 research-validator warnings concern recommended Skill sections and the /stage-close guide entry; strict warning-free validation is not claimed. Native compilation also retains the existing Atomic::fetch_update deprecation warning in qiongli-platform. G4/J2 guidance and its seven frozen synthetic outputs are unchanged, so their prior observations are reused.
Final integration review covers request fidelity, native/legacy compatibility, evidence-link failures and generated-pack ownership, with no actionable findings. The program-ledger/index checks and frozen-source guard complete the local integration record. No task state, dependencies, accepted evidence, commit/run fields, Host/model settings, remote refs or publication status are promoted.
Next prioritize held-out Chinese/English whole-section comparisons: fix the original and context, distinguish rule changes from model differences, and record author preference for flow separately from meaning errors. Exercise the actual configured Codex → Antigravity → Codex round trip, checking that a no-drift review keeps fluent language and changed originals cannot reuse a stale comparison. Then address remaining contract warnings by actual requirements, and separate fast content checks from cold binary builds with a bounded cache budget. These are follow-up recommendations, not completed research-quality qualification.
October 20 — connected writing and validation efficiency
The maintainer authorizes the suggested writing-quality and verification improvements, followed by local integration into 2.x without publication. Sources 9a08b2de and d56a7b14 extend the existing scholarly-voice owner: review a connected unit, align abstract/outcome/population/timing, distinguish inherited manuscript conflicts from edit-induced drift, and recheck affected claims when the original or returned candidate changes. Good edits survive; a no-drift result ends the comparison. Existing G4/J2 roles, configured models, task outputs and preview/approval/CAS owners remain intact.
Five Skill cards gain missing entry/quality headings using existing prose. The shared section audit recognizes heading case and valid canonical failure_modes without duplicating pitfalls; required Purpose/Process, malformed metadata, alias and size checks remain. The guide now includes the existing /stage-close command. The fast routing suite exercises the actual portable materializer; full stable/next Plugin assembly and binary digest/size checks remain in the integration suite. A read-only build-cache budget defaults to 16 GiB of listed regenerable caches and 8 GiB free, with explicit overrides and no deletion. The native atomic update uses the supported API under the existing Rust 1.97 minimum; ordering and overflow refusal are unchanged.
The frozen observation retains exact inputs, all eight original process captures, anonymous reviewer output, identity key, K/L answers and a separately labelled repair. Both baseline and candidate pass 2/2 existing synthetic long-form tasks across all six review dimensions. The anonymous reviewer slightly prefers candidate flow in both languages and English argument development, with semantic fidelity tied. This is neither a new held-out cohort nor a controlled general improvement estimate. Codex uses configured gpt-6-astra / xhigh; Antigravity configuration is preserved but its event stream does not report model identity. No tools are observed in the raw model streams, and no private manuscript is accessed.
The actual Codex → Antigravity → Codex handoff finds five English changed spans, including “was not observed” strengthened into “does not occur.” The original edit and review remain; coordinator minimal restorations are a separate follow-up, not a new independent pass. Chinese review finds no material drift and accepts the prose without rewriting. New K/L independent-context answers pass coordinator review for inherited abstract conflicts and stale version review. These are bounded synthetic observations, not real-manuscript, expert or installed-Plugin acceptance.
Completed affected checks:
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| Python audit, Skill structure, routing, cache-budget, research-validator and release-note suites | 53 pass in 1.389 s; malformed metadata, missing required sections, alias/size, legacy/native note and budget/symlink negative cases retained |
python3 scripts/validate_research_standard.py --strict | 6,210 pass, zero failures, zero warnings |
Full DistributionMaterializerTests.test_plugin_target_materializes_to_staging_without_touching_source | 1 pass in 237.715 s; actual Lite build, both Plugin channels, runtime identity and canonical writing bytes |
Native qiongli-platform --lib product_control::tests | 8 pass in a private source copy with secure ancestors and umask 077; changed-state, tampering, preview, repair, lifecycle and prior-managed removal cases retained |
Native CLI --test embedded_pack | 1 pass after successful 88 s compilation |
Native content --test resource_pack_loader --test deterministic_writer --test embedded_content | 16 pass, including corruption, source drift, path and resource-limit refusals |
| Program-ledger/index suite and generated-index check | 7 pass; 249-task index current |
| Frozen input and capture verification | All input/capture hashes and eight terminal answers match; paired prompts differ only in the frozen guide addition |
| Read-only cache budget | Pass, approximately 2.1 GB listed caches and 25 GB free after native compilation |
The unit/integration suites total 86 passes; structural validation and qualitative answer review are separate. Logs remain in /tmp/qiongli-strengthen-*.log. The first platform attempt failed all eight fixtures before the changed atomic operation: checkout ancestors were group-writable. An isolated copy initially reused a cached binary with the old compile-time path; after rebuilding, its inherited umask still produced group-writable directories. Giving only the new copy private directories and umask 077 made all eight pass. A byte comparison verified 789 copied inputs; only the subsequently regenerated pack lock differed. No existing ancestor permissions or production safety checks were changed. These setup failures remain recorded rather than being relabelled as passes. After validation, the private copy and its one cached test binary/fingerprint were removed to avoid retaining a stale compile-time fixture path.
The supported generator binds local version 2.5.3 and 446 resources to source d56a7b147dae9abef128a58c0da00553826bc45e, content root f5d29bdc1cf6947c2af2cb64d06df33b5b1409ab72eb80e006c05c84d3f1af16 and pack 66757acbefaf36734f0fdb02b32eb0df6adae8d798b196868ee5e028ca3b685b. This is a development binding, with no version bump or released-asset replacement. Final review covers source ownership, request fidelity, compatibility, preserved negative cases, original observation provenance and unchanged research-write boundaries. The frozen-source guard completes local integration; unchanged test results are reused after commits and merge.
Next is an authorized real-manuscript author blind comparison, with explicit Antigravity model identity and discipline-aware review. No task state, dependencies, accepted evidence, commit/run fields, remote refs, installed Plugin or publication status is promoted by this work.
October 22 — Public visual evidence journey
The maintainer authorizes the first public-paper round: source extraction with figures/tables, literature-review writing, fresh-session recovery, fixes and recorded results, followed by local integration into 2.x without publication. The public-visual observation owns source versions, frozen tasks/criteria, five original attempts, separate follow-ups and reviewed outcomes. It uses Kestin and Bastani public education papers, six rendered pages and the affiliation-only Bastani correction. No private manuscript, study-data reanalysis or external author review is claimed.
Codex 0.162.1 retains configured gpt-6-astra / xhigh. The completed bounded journey preserves means/medians, SEM, relative changes, assignment/analysis units, source versions and the distinction between assisted and independent performance. Two source packets, two reviewed notes and a partial bilingual writing summary are saved through the existing preview/approval/CAS owner. A fresh project-ID-only session discovers all five bindings at revision 6, preserves claim IDs and limits, actually opens Table 1 and returns a 145-word English continuation. Source and image hashes, exact saved bytes and unchanged model-turn project/config bytes are verified. This is direct Full MCP plus frozen canonical guidance; the runtime binary is hash-bound but lacks a compile-time source stamp. It is not installed Plugin, formal manuscript/claim-ledger, expert or program acceptance.
The first extraction driver is interrupted with exit 143 and leaves an owned child group; its original partial capture remains. The first synthesis ends with a tool-approval denial and no draft. Its corrected follow-up retains a rejected limit: 100 call before successful pagination. Source 1f1e6791 fixes main-thread SIGTERM/SIGINT capture cleanup and stale saved-summary help. Explicit policy for only the three already-authorized read tools is checked through strict app-server config/read; the user's profile and sandbox are unchanged. Unsupported schema- generation flags and temporary preparation errors remain separate from model outcomes and are documented in the observation.
The original synthesis claims image inspection, but its exec stream does not prove that action. A separate reviewed candidate changes only this provenance annotation. The recovery's authorized public local rollout records a nested view_image call and an image whose decoded bytes exactly equal the saved table. That image call is absent from simplified exec JSON, demonstrating a capture limitation. Earlier missing evidence remains unverified rather than retroactively passed; replay guidance now distinguishes hashes from actual image delivery.
Affected validation:
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| Python capture/preflight, journey, portable routing and saved-document gates | 57 pass in 12.120 s, including actual SIGTERM/SIGINT child cleanup and handler restoration |
| Canonical MCP fixtures | 9 pass in 0.457 s |
| Native content loader, deterministic writer and embedded content | 16 pass; corruption, path/limit and source-drift refusals retained |
| Native CLI embedded pack | 1 pass after cold compilation |
| Program ledger/index suite and generated index check | 7 pass; 249-task index current |
| Live isolated negative scenarios | Missing academic approval, missing filesystem approval, stale revision, changed source and missing source refuse without reader/apply writes; original fixture bytes restored |
| Candidate MCP inventory | 35 tools, with only the corrected summary-path parameter description differing from the frozen runtime |
| Source/capture/image integrity | All retained digests and terminal answers match; exact recovery image delivery verified; temporary authentication link removed |
| Build-cache budget | Pass before/after; about 1.75 GB listed caches and 73.5 GB free after compilation; no deletion required |
These are 90 distinct unit/integration tests, with live negative cases and qualitative source review recorded separately. The 23-test capture-only run is a subset of the 57-test batch, not another 23 passes. Native logs remain under /tmp/qiongli-visual-native-checks; raw public source and Host evidence remains at the observation manifest's external capture_root. No full release or remote CI suite is implied. Reuse these results unless their inputs change.
The supported generator binds 446 resources, still version 2.5.3, to source 1f1e6791b975daed3a4c537ddd815ea4529d13a5, content root 2e944e0d86d610c82496a5609910b1771e906f8d7decb84035fe85c48be5c83d and pack 96f018af28b11d175298500fd8b295b3a911030b0a1fd97872b9860ab52f6b6a; pack commit cc14eceb changes no published asset. Final review covers owner placement, source support, retained failures, signal cleanup, compatibility, exact approval/read boundaries and generated-content integrity. The frozen-source guard completes local integration; no push or publication is authorized.
Only CLI-405 progress text/date and the generated index change. Task states, dependencies, accepted evidence and commit/run fields remain unchanged. Next are another discipline/visual type, author or subject-expert assessment, and fewer repeated guidance/packet reads while retaining source context. Antigravity model comparison and private-manuscript review remain separately scoped.
October 22 — Attention diagrams and bounded reads
The public attention follow-up adds one computer-science study in proceedings/arXiv v7 versions, four original page renders, an attention-link diagram, comparison/ablation tables and three fresh project-ID-only recoveries. It preserves inter-version and within-v7 score conflicts, development/test distinctions and qualitative versus causal interpretation. Two source packets, a reviewed note and a coordinator-authored partial bilingual seed use the existing preview/approval/CAS owner; four current bindings at revision 5 are recovered without promoting the writing unit or accepted evidence.
All observations retain configured Codex 0.162.1 / gpt-6-astra / xhigh. Baseline, first candidate and balanced follow-up take 201.1 / 281.3 / 270.4 seconds, with 8 / 21 / 9 document reads and 87,632 / 44,917 / 87,632 returned content bytes. All preserve source meaning and actual original-image delivery, but neither candidate demonstrates lower latency or input tokens than baseline. The first candidate's additional searches motivate an explicit compact-packet/dispersed- claim tradeoff. Final guidance reuses available version-bound context and chooses source windows from the question while retaining evidence and freshness checks. This is a single-case iterative comparison, not a general efficiency claim.
Original captures retain extraction's two shell failures, candidate's two invalid limit=100 calls and the follow-up's one invalid limit call. Canonical schema bounds already exist; final tool help now exposes default 32 / maximum 64 in its description. The final runtime's 35-tool inventory differs only in that description. Model runs use the frozen preceding binary; prevention of this error with the new help is not independently observed. Coordinator capture preparation changes the extraction fixture; only the three later, frozen recovery turns demonstrate unchanged project/ config bytes. A stale unused packet preview and a corrected metadata-search driver request remain recorded separately from completed model outcomes.
Source commits d5407661 and addd7956 own reading guidance; c7895dea owns the final MCP help. The supported generator binds 446 resources, still version 2.5.3, to source c7895deaae4c794497a3cf1c3f4703c057f7c246, content root 8973850300a6859aab4564ba32b5f6fd98ac42b1b5e2a44278a17a37e989d1a6 and pack d6dcef652df7bb85ae6be5889a50f680b3d5edb8b45c0b3649c40e1cb560de44.
Affected checks total 90 distinct tests: 57 Python capture/preflight/journey and content gates, 9 MCP fixtures, 16 native content, 1 CLI embedded-pack and 7 ledger/ index tests. Repeated checks after changed inputs are counted once. Three live negative cases refuse stale revision, non-string selection and changed source; other bindings stay current and original fixture bytes are restored. Metadata-only hits remain locators. Source/capture/image digests, final runtime inventory and removed temporary authentication link are checked. Final native receipts remain under /tmp/qiongli-attention-final-native-checks. The build-cache budget passes at about 1.75 GB listed caches / 73.3 GB free; no cleanup is needed.
Final diff review covers canonical ownership, preserved source conflicts, exact saved bytes, missing acceptance claims, original failures, unchanged read/write boundaries and generated-pack identity. The frozen-source guard precedes local fast-forward integration into 2.x; no push, publication or remote CI is requested. Only CLI-405 progress and the generated index change; states, dependencies, accepted evidence and commit/run fields remain unchanged.
Next: measure source-window selection and Host guidance truncation across additional papers, exercise unavailable-image recovery, and obtain author/subject-expert assessment. This pilot supplies neither independent expert review nor evidence that the latest instruction increases overall speed.
October 22 — Guidance delivery and unavailable-image recovery
The delivery follow-up records four fresh configured-model observations and offline inspection of the three preceding attention rollouts. The latter expose 3/1/3 outer truncations and 0/1/1 script failures omitted by simplified exec JSON. Existing evaluation code now records this layer separately, rejects malformed/duplicate records and keeps unknown/unmatched/pending output explicit without exporting source or reasoning.
The education baseline, first candidate and explicit-budget candidate take 239.7/206.9/228.8 seconds with 23/20/35 recorded calls, 15/12/16 document reads, 129,186/120,488/94,034 content bytes and 2/2/1 outer truncations. All preserve source distinctions, partial status, actual image delivery and project/config bytes. The first candidate still bundles three guides; source ee97f6e5 explicitly separates nested reader limits from outer budgets. Its later guides arrive in bounded sections without another bundle truncation or whole Stage F reread. Initial root/tool discovery still truncates; increased calls and input tokens prevent an overall efficiency claim. The adaptive follow-up and readable sibling input trees are documented, with actual commands confined to selected guidance.
A separate revision-5 public fixture imports prior attention text/notes through existing preview/approval/CAS and omits only the current Figure 4 render. The original prior image remains intact. The fresh run takes 232.7 seconds, recovers four current bindings, actually receives three other images and handles the missing-image rejection. It uses the checked caption for AIAYN-C07, explicitly defers historical AIAYN-C06 detail and preserves version/causal limits. No image rule change is needed. Two invalid coordinator capture requests and one invalid consolidation preview remain recorded; correction selects valid evidence objects and source bindings without overwriting failures or mutating original projects.
Two education runs each exceed the existing search-context limit. Source 9fe1656c exposes default 128 / range 4..512 bytes per side in tool help and points longer passages to read mode. Final native inventory differs only in this description; model observations use the preceding binary, so prevention remains unobserved. The supported generator binds 446 resources, version 2.5.3, to source 9fe1656c7d9381037cc4dcc7b634f3a56b86da01, content root a981d8d144ff10da89b9c5b26a0488d12bb39888efe19ec1460cf33da4a7479f and pack d140407859cdce23118726b2c912f3ba52822cd476980ab06d2688dcc4185801.
Affected checks total 71 distinct tests: 38 Python evaluation/content gates, 9 MCP fixtures, 16 native content, 1 CLI embedded pack and 7 ledger/index checks. Changed-input reruns count once. Final bounded native receipts are under /tmp/qiongli-delivery-final-native-checks; all exit successfully, are reaped and leave no process group. Cache budget is within limits at about 1.75 GB listed caches / 73.0 GB free; no cleanup is needed. Public traces, exact image bytes, source bindings, removed temporary auth links and unchanged case fingerprints are checked. These are coordinator reviews, not blind author/expert judgments.
Final diff review covers owners, output-delivery accounting, source fidelity, retained failures, unchanged schemas/write authority and final pack identity. The frozen-source guard precedes local fast-forward integration into 2.x. Only CLI-405 progress and the generated index change; task states, dependencies, accepted evidence and commit/run fields stay unchanged. No push or publication. Next: scoped tool discovery during initial loading, section-size/round-trip measurements, a behavior check of search help and author/subject-expert review.
October 23 — Evidence-led writing quality
The maintainer prioritizes content quality over overall startup speed. The quality observation compares two fresh writer processes on the same saved public education papers and the existing fictional cluster-randomized error-identification record. Each produces a bilingual literature-review unit and a separate Chinese Discussion: four task outputs, not four model runs. Source aea773ad strengthens Stage F's supported cross-source answer and scholarly voice's distinction between measured findings, unknown mechanisms and longer-term outcomes. Its bilingual coating example preserves G4 substantive review versus expression-only J2 scope.
Both guidance trees, task/source/config bytes and criteria are frozen before the pair. Only Stage F and scholarly voice differ. Writers retain gpt-6-astra/xhigh, use separate read-only profiles limited to their selected guidance and supplied sources, and preserve the current project/config. A third fresh process receives anonymous P/Q outputs, raw sources and actual image metadata, without identities, writer traces, other guidance or MCP access. The mapping is revealed after its review completes: P is candidate, Q baseline. This is same-model anonymous review, not independent author/expert or installed-Plugin acceptance.
All four task outputs pass six reviewed dimensions. Public-review flow and fidelity tie; explanatory depth slightly favors candidate's link between actual Bastani Figure 3 interaction measures and the absent confirmed Tutor exam gain. Candidate also states Kestin's measured post-test advantage directly while retaining unconfirmed unaided-test conditions. Synthetic Discussion flow slightly favors candidate's closing supported answer; substantive explanation/fidelity are tied. The reviewer accepts a scope-correct positive conclusion and detects both long-term/instrument-outcome overstatement and excessive-caution denial of the measured result. No original output is replaced by a repaired success.
Baseline/candidate Chinese review counts are 721/794, English 366/373, and Chinese Discussion 330/369, all within the frozen targets. They take 382.2/484.2 seconds, with 39/33 recorded calls and 22/18 document reads; each retains two outer truncation warnings, no script/inner-tool failures. Their different source reading and concurrent execution do not establish speed improvement. The 337.7-second review has no outer delivery failure and independently receives three original images. A premature readiness assertion starts no review process; only the completed later review counts. Prior delivery-report length ambiguity is corrected: the already loaded default rule gives 506/502/507/531 Chinese characters, all in range. Original answers/reviews and their hashes remain unchanged.
The canonical Skill validator and 38 distinct affected tests pass: 14 Python routing/saved-document, 16 native content, 1 CLI embedded-pack and 7 ledger/index. Bounded native receipts are under /tmp/qiongli-quality-native-checks; processes exit successfully, are reaped and leave no group. Frozen input/project maps, actual image returns, final lock and removed temporary auth links are verified. Cache budget passes at about 1.75 GB listed caches / 72.5 GB free; no cleanup. Pack cd9950cf retains 446 resources/version 2.5.3, bound to source aea773ad9fb62c3035501c16c2dcfdec3eff792c, content root 33570901b2670a3269b87c1bf34ed09dd70aaaf6ff6c6e2f887d52df903eb329 and pack a617beb6ee81da078e1a33d8d3c54ba8ced7e09d0ef502ac75c7e76940be5373.
Final review covers owners, substantive-versus-language-edit authority, source and bilingual fidelity, preserved negative cases and restrained quality claims. The frozen-source guard precedes local fast-forward integration into 2.x. Only CLI-405 progress/date and the generated index change; task states, dependencies, accepted evidence and commit/run fields stay unchanged. No push or publication. Next test additional questions and author/expert judgments while keeping the supported answer clear without accumulating detail; startup discovery remains separate bounded work. The pilot does not establish broad language-quality gains.
October 23 — Cross-discipline long-form writing
The maintainer asks for longer public-paper passages in additional disciplines, prioritizing content quality and local integration without publication. The long-form observation uses Hallmann2017 ecology and Dwyer2023 social policy. Two fresh configured-model writers produce four bilingual task outputs (eight language sections), all within 1100–1500 Chinese characters / 700–900 English words. Source e406ce8c narrowly clarifies carrying limits across paragraphs, idiomatic measurement wording and aggregate versus sustained outcomes; pack eaa4e47d retains version 2.5.3.
The fresh anonymous same-model review finds 27 dimension passes, one local unknown and no definite failure. Social-policy flow/explanation slightly favor candidate; ecology is tied or mixed, and language/fidelity often tie. Most qualifications have distinct purposes, so the initial concern about defensive endings does not justify indiscriminate removal. Baseline's similar habitat rates follows the paper's body but encounters different rates in its printed S5 description. That source tension stays unresolved; candidate already uses both groups declined. All six meaning-review probes receive correct acceptance or local substantive repair. Original outputs are retained, not rewritten into successful runs. Same-file review preparation and metadata-assembly errors are repaired without changing inputs or rerunning writers; unsuccessful commands remain in the observation.
The canonical validator and 38 distinct affected checks pass (14 Python, 17 native, 7 program/index). All three model runs finish, preserve their inputs and receive the four original images; auth links are removed and bounded subprocess groups are reaped. The content source, generated lock and frozen-source boundary are reviewed before local fast-forward integration into 2.x. Only CLI-405 progress/date and the generated index change; task states, dependencies, accepted evidence and commit/run fields remain unchanged. No push or publication. Next validate unchanged rules on unseen questions/sources and seek author/disciplinary-expert judgments; this diagnostic pair does not establish general language-quality gains. Startup discovery and optional PDF rendering remain separate bounded work.
October 23 — First-use qualitative writing
The qualitative observation freezes existing 997ea931 guidance on Mitter2019, an 18-page public qualitative paper not used in preceding local adjustments. The 1672-character Chinese and 925-word English discussions pass all seven independent review dimensions. Six separate G4/J2 cases preserve faithful wording and repair evidenced drift or claim errors. The first reviewer accepts their content but requests an extra substantive-review status for three G4 proposals. It lacked the role contracts. A fresh adjudication with those unchanged contracts retains all six responses.
The narrow fix belongs to the existing writing review criteria: supply the frozen task/role contract when assessing authority, preserve identity blinding, and judge the described action instead of requiring an escalation label. G4 substantive proposals remain distinct from J2 expression editing and from project writes. Original responses and both reviews are retained; this adaptive review does not become a new held-out writing result. Canonical content, pack and user model selection remain unchanged. No writer rerun or new prose rule is needed.
Four configured-model runs complete, preserve inputs and deliver the two original source images. Three outer truncation warnings in the first two runs remain in the record; all four have zero failed inner calls and no outer script failure. Program/index checks and contract-link checks accompany integration; unchanged content/native checks are reused. Only CLI-405 progress/date and the generated index change, preserving task states, accepted evidence, dependencies and commit/ run fields. Integrate by the authorized local fast-forward workflow into 2.x; no push, publication or acceptance promotion. Next use a fully accessible purely theoretical paper and author/disciplinary-expert adjudication. The excluded Ostrom source, single qualitative sample and same-model reviews limit coverage.
October 23 — First-use theoretical writing
The theoretical observation uses the complete 17-page publisher PDF of Anderies2004, absent from preceding local writing adjustments. Guidance, source, question, seven review dimensions and six editing cases are frozen at e21d4581 before execution. The anonymous review receives the actual G4/J2 contracts from the start. All seven long-form dimensions and six case responses pass; correct definitions, natural translation and necessary scope remain intact. No canonical prose-rule change is warranted.
The coordinator counter initially removes all citation anchors, despite a frozen task excluding standalone anchor lines only. The reviewer independently reports both counts. The corrected task counts are 1752 Chinese code points / 1020 English words; removing all anchors gives 1516 / 996. Both pass, so the verdict is unchanged. The counter and existing review criteria now preserve this distinction; original counter/result, writer output and first review remain. This is a measurement correction, not a new writing trial or evidence of improved language.
Three configured-model runs complete with preserved inputs and cleanup. One writer outer truncation and one reviewer missing-pdfinfo call remain recorded; the supplied full text and original pages support the completed review. Seven program tests, index freshness, mixed/no-anchor controls and source/output/model/ contract audits accompany integration. Canonical content, pack, native code and model selection remain unchanged; their prior checks are reused. Only CLI-405 progress/date and the generated index change, preserving accepted task fields. Integrate locally into 2.x with the frozen-source guard and fast-forward workflow; no push, publication or acceptance promotion. Next: author/disciplinary-expert judgment and proof-based theory, beyond this single conceptual-framework paper.
October 23 — Cross-section writing and external polish
The cross-section observation uses the complete nine-page Doshi/Hauser2024 public paper and Figures 1–4, absent from prior local adjustments. It freezes guidance, question, eight-section bilingual layout, counting contract and seven review dimensions at 01b20b08. The configured Codex writes the original; a real Antigravity turn returns a language-edited candidate; a fresh identity-blinded Codex review reads both, the source and the matching G4/J2 contracts. All seven dimensions pass for each version, with tied flow/argument and a slight language preference for the original. No consequential drift or research error is found. The coordinator retains the original plus two reviewed expression improvements (2102 Chinese code points / 1091 English words). Full original/return/review remain; this selection is not another blind trial. No canonical writing-rule change is warranted.
Reusable helpers provide explicit measurements, selected-file bindings and bounded reads. The shared Antigravity parser now handles schema-mode finish completion and a clipped ACTIVE preview, binding the complete terminal payload without changing ordinary native/MCP argument checks. Both rejected parses of the same successful Host stream remain, with no additional editing run. Actual Host version is 1.4.6, corroborated by frozen identity and the run log; its selected model is unknown. A mistaken prerequisite version note and ineffective plan-mode flag are retained with corrections. Configured models and settings are preserved.
The 62 affected tests pass. Source/manuscript/contract chunks and four original images are delivered in both Codex contexts where applicable; one writer alias failure, two reviewer shell failures and one reviewer startup-catalog truncation remain explicit. Source and manuscript delivery are complete. Version/count/ cleanup audits, index checks and final diff review accompany local fast-forward integration into 2.x. Only CLI-405 progress/date and the generated index change; accepted task fields remain untouched. Canonical content, native code and pack remain unchanged; no push, publication or acceptance promotion. Next seek author/ disciplinary-expert judgment and an unseen multi-paper unit. One paper and a same-model reviewer cannot establish general gains or named-model superiority.
October 23 — Multi-paper writing and recovered language review
The three-study observation uses complete first-use Kazemitabaar2023, Prather2024 and Shen2026 public versions. One configured Codex writer, one real Antigravity edit and one fresh Codex review complete. The reviewer recovers current source/manuscript/task/guidance bindings from an explicit local packet and refuses a separate stale-original control. Reusable freeze/recover helpers preserve existing native project-save/CAS owners.
The original's 2946 Chinese code points / 1292 English words fit the body limits, but task prose conflicts with required language labels. That raw layout failure remains. The returned Chinese expands to 3652 code points; English has 1466 words. Both versions pass argument, explanatory depth and natural language. The original also passes bilingual equivalence. Source fidelity and outcome qualifications need localized correction; the return adds bilingual drift. Flow/argument tie, Chinese favors the original and English ties. The selected original-based repair has 2986 Chinese code points / 1320 English words, preserving correct argument while correcting score constructs, outcome scope, offered tool access and the completion/confidence-versus-understanding relation. Selection is coordinator adjudication, not another blinded model or human trial.
Preserve the initial handoff path failure, conflicting heading instructions, raw judgments, candidate length failure and a frozen check that wrongly totals Shen's printed subgroup counts as 25 rather than 24. Separate errata and resumed preparation resolve evaluation defects without rewriting history. All runs retain inputs/settings and cleanup; each Codex context receives ten original images and has no outer truncation. The only failed reviewer command is the intended stale packet refusal. Antigravity's selected model remains unknown; configured models, canonical content, native code and pack are unchanged.
The 65 affected tests and direct freeze/recover/duplicate-role/stale-input CLI checks pass. Final source/meaning/count review, program/index freshness, ledger invariants and the frozen-source guard accompany local fast-forward integration into 2.x. Only CLI-405 progress/date and the generated index change; task states, dependencies and accepted evidence/commit/run fields remain untouched. No push, publication or acceptance promotion. Three randomly labelled manuscripts, public PDFs and a blank human form are prepared but unsent. Next obtain authorized human/ disciplinary judgment and actual editing time before claiming user-perceived quality gains or choosing the next content regression.
November 6 — Scoped human feedback and Chinese expression
The user prefers B for the single Chinese Discussion paragraph shown in the first-pass follow-up, while finding further room for improvement. Preserve the exact question, three labelled excerpts and manuscript/request hashes. A/C are identical at this scope; the submitted body equals B, with one added line whose intended placement is unspecified. No specific preference reason or editing time was supplied. Record the response separately from the prior whole-document model judgment and frozen manuscript selection; do not promote it to English, source or disciplinary review.
The shared G4/J2 scholarly-voice reference gains a bilingual synthetic example that makes participants, practice topics and task comparisons explicit. The review criteria judge reader effort rather than brevity and bind human preference to the actual unit shown. The coordinator's further wording proposal retains both possible mechanisms, the cross-study inference, lack of a direct comparison, authors' separate interpretations, causal-attribution limit and exact citations. It is not human approved or applied to the frozen manuscript. This feedback-driven example is an adaptive regression, not a fresh held-out model experiment.
The supported update_qiongli_core_lock owner binds 446 resources at local version 2.5.3 to content source 81e2e5ad3f45c9fc8c291b41fc1e83e9c0b250a5, content root 3ab80b24604ad5f8a9a41ea5756a3aa57c7ff63f55f68f5906ab9aea9ec84eac and pack 6b4a969ea234a50449d544c3a63eb557a540eaa636289e6d0327d6dfb542da98. This development binding does not replace a published pack or installed Skill.
Validation: 43 affected tests pass — 19 routing/structure, 16 native content loader/writer/embedded-content, one actual native CLI embedded-pack check and seven program-ledger checks. Skill quick validation, generated-index freshness, feedback/input hashes, unchanged original observation, proposal consistency and exact content-source binding also pass. Cache budget is within bounds; no cleanup is needed. Existing negative fixtures retain digest, path and malformed-input checks. Test logs are /tmp/qiongli-chinese-feedback-{content-tests,native-content, native-app,program-tests}.log; no new Antigravity or model batch is claimed.
Review the final diff and use the frozen-source guard before local fast-forward integration into 2.x. Only CLI-405 progress/date change in the ledger; all task states, dependencies and 198 populated evidence/commit/run fields are preserved. Configured models and native write/CAS owners remain unchanged. No push, publication or acceptance promotion. Next validate on an unseen passage and obtain human feedback on the further wording; whole-manuscript/English judgment and actual editing time remain open.
November 6 — Unseen Chinese paragraphs and human selection
The new Chinese observation uses two previously unused passages from Traag's 2016 PLOS ONE paper. Complete publisher HTML/XML/PDF and exact JATS paragraph locators are preserved. The two writers receive identical sources/tasks and the user's configured model; their prompts differ only by the preceding 16-line scholarly-voice addition. Both writers and one fresh anonymous reviewer finish, with complete inline delivery, unchanged inputs/settings and authentication-link cleanup. Optional PATH alias warnings in the temporary profile remain; no requested operation fails.
All four paragraphs fit the frozen 250–450-character range and pass the model's Chinese-naturalness and qualification checks. The reviewer gives one paragraph a partial argument score for omitting an experiment observation. Preserve that raw score: a separate coordinator adjudication identifies checklist overreach, because the task permits optional examples and the passage retains every premise needed for its conditional explanation. The review-criteria owner now requires an actual missing premise and consequence before calling an argument incomplete. No further canonical writing-rule or content-pack change is warranted.
The user prefers B's overall fluency while valuing A's wording/completeness and selects B as the base. The exact response and comparison binding remain separate from model judgments. The coordinator's combined paragraphs retain B's flow, A's conceptual/methodological detail, source attribution and necessary uncertainty; they have 348 and 391 characters. The user did not supply per-case scores, exact phrase choices or editing time, and has not reviewed the combined wording. The version key and automatic review appeared in tool output before feedback, so strict human blinding is not claimed. Preserve this exposure; future criteria withhold keys/judgments from visible output until the response.
Seven program tests and generated-index freshness pass. Actual helper-based checks verify frozen inputs, all three complete prompts, the 16-line-only prompt difference, source locators, output/feedback hashes, selected-text counts and citation anchors, current packet recovery and cleanup. Final artifact/ledger audits retain all 249 tasks and 198 populated acceptance fields; only CLI-405 progress changes. Native/content/pack source is unchanged, so prior affected checks are reused. The final diff review and frozen-source guard accompany local fast-forward integration into 2.x, without push, publication or acceptance promotion. Raw local evidence remains under /tmp/qiongli-zh-holdout-20261106-3vfczvmn; program test output is /tmp/qiongli-zh-holdout-program-tests.log.
One sample per guidance arm and this scoped human preference do not establish general or causal gains. These passages now become regression material. Next use a new connected passage with the key and model judgments withheld through human review; combined-text, English and whole-manuscript judgments remain open.
November 6 — Connected Chinese prose and blinded feedback
The connected Chinese observation uses the first ten consecutive Discussion paragraphs from Fanelli's 2009 PLOS ONE paper, locally unused at 53de04a6. Complete publisher HTML/XML/PDF and exact JATS locators are retained. Both writers receive the same 1,281-word source and four-paragraph Chinese task; the prompts differ only by the preceding 16-line guidance addition. Two writing turns and one fresh identity-blinded review finish using the configured model, with complete inline delivery and no tool calls.
The raw sections contain 1,512 and 1,400 characters. Both pass all six content dimensions and three paragraph transitions; model preferences tie and no required repair is identified. The coordinator confirms the source distinctions and permitted omissions. Necessary limits concerning respondents, incidents, papers, truthful reporting and calibration are substantive reasoning in this passage. Preserve correct writing and the existing G4/J2/scholarly-voice contracts.
The exact human feedback prefers B's overall language and A's detail handling. Whole-section labels were randomized once, and neither the key nor model judgments appeared in visible output before the response. No exact phrase preferences, per-dimension scores or editing time were supplied. A 1,506-character B-based selection adds A's historical argument/direct-measurement distinction and willingness/past-behavior example. Both additions are source-checked; paragraphs 2 and 4 and citation anchors remain unchanged apart from trailing whitespace. The combined text is not newly human reviewed, and this success does not erase the preceding trial's blinding limit.
Seven program tests and generated-index freshness pass. Actual artifact checks verify frozen sources/prompts, continuous source selection, complete deliveries, runtime permissions, exact feedback and output hashes, the two selected edits, counts/anchors, current packet recovery and cleanup. All 249 tasks and 198 populated acceptance fields remain; only CLI-405 progress changes. Canonical content, pack, native code and helper code are unchanged, so their prior checks are reused. Initial sandbox DNS failure is resolved by authorized public-source retrieval. Temporary-profile PATH aliases and the isolated policy probe's untrusted-project notice remain documented; no global trust/config change occurs. The initial staged whitespace check rejects four Markdown hard-break space pairs. Normalize only the archived display's trailing spaces, retaining the exact issued packet and digest separately in the observation; source, model inputs, wording, human feedback and their original bindings remain intact.
Review the final diff and run the frozen-source guard before local fast-forward integration into 2.x; no push, publication or acceptance promotion. Raw evidence is under /tmp/qiongli-zh-connected-20261106-2m1clugm; program-test output is /tmp/qiongli-zh-connected-program-tests.log. One generation per guidance arm and this scoped human preference do not establish general or causal quality gains. These passages now become regression material. Further held-out work needs a new source; English, longer manuscripts and disciplinary judgments remain open.
November 6 — Chinese writing across acoustics sections
The cross-section Chinese observation uses Tarlao, Steele and Guastavino's 2022 environmental-acoustics paper, locally unused at 7616f636. Complete publisher HTML/XML/PDF are retained. The continuous Methods–Results–Discussion–Conclusions packet includes 69 paragraphs, lists, nine XML tables and five figure captions (119 blocks), with exact JATS locators. Figure pixels, supplements and separately cited papers are not inspected; the missing local PDF renderer is explicit rather than a claimed visual check.
Two writers complete the same two-section/eight-paragraph Chinese task within 3,000–4,200 non-whitespace characters. The prompts differ only by the preceding 16-line scholarly-voice addition; the configured model and source are unchanged. A fresh identity-blinded model review also completes. All three inline prompts, read-only turns, no-tool execution, preserved inputs/config and temporary-auth cleanup are verified. Runtime observations do not establish a speed or causal quality improvement. Isolated PATH/untrusted-project notices are retained; no global trust or user-model configuration is changed.
The coordinator source comparison finds no mandatory repair: participant/rating units, similar latent structure versus equal ratings, the appropriate-item intercept exception, excerpt interactions, visual chronology and the limits of causal/application claims survive across sections. Preserve correct prose and existing rules; optional details are not missing premises. The completed model review remains undisclosed and unadjudicated while human preference is pending. The portable observation retains anonymous raw outputs and a hash-bound private snapshot reference; the key, raw automatic judgments and indirect identity mapping in recovered paths are withheld. The private snapshot retains all three complete runs for disclosure after feedback.
The X/Y anonymous comparison is issued with fresh whole-manuscript labels. This time trailing whitespace is normalized before presentation, so the repository display remains byte-identical to the questioned packet. The user has not yet supplied a preference. Do not infer it from earlier B choices, choose a combined draft, or claim human/model acceptance. Integrate the completed source/observation work locally; the pending question remains available for a later response and does not gate independent local development.
Validation covers source blocks and table cells against publisher XML, frozen inputs, prompt difference, exact delivered prompts, output lengths/locators, comparison hashes, current packet recovery, secret/identity omission and cleanup. All seven program tests and generated-index freshness pass; the artifact audit retains all 249 tasks and 198 populated acceptance fields. Final diff review and the frozen-source guard accompany local fast-forward integration into 2.x. Canonical content, pack, native and helper code are unchanged, so existing checks for those inputs are reused. Only CLI-405 progress and the generated index change; task states, dependencies and accepted-evidence fields remain unchanged. No push, publication or acceptance promotion. Raw evidence is under /tmp/qiongli-zh-crosssection-20261106-s5aeza9x.
Next bind actual feedback to the issued comparison, then inspect/adjudicate the sealed model review and make any source-backed selection. These passages become regression material. A general guidance effect, English, full-manuscript, disciplinary and installed-Host judgments remain outside this increment.
Human feedback and unchanged Y selection
The later human response resolves the preference that remained pending at local integration a738675f. The user considers both descriptions to have no very large problems and prefers Y for conciseness and fluency, recognizing that individual preferences may differ. The exact response is bound to the unchanged comparison before unsealing the key and model review. The key and fresh model judgments had not appeared in visible output or the committed record; coordinator source-check summaries were visible. Do not turn that scoped feedback into source/expert verification, exact phrase scores, editing-time measurements or publication approval.
The original model review gives both versions passes on eight content dimensions, all seven paragraph transitions and all five traced cross-section claims. Its five comparisons tie and its issue list is empty. The coordinator agrees after source comparison and literal-span checks, without overrides. These judgments remain separate from the human preference. The key reveals X as current guidance and Y as the earlier baseline; retain that result without claiming a candidate win or inferring a general guidance effect. X/Y body counts are 3338/3368, so the human's conciseness preference is not a claim that Y contains fewer characters.
The selected text retains Y's two sections and eight paragraphs with zero wording, citation or ordering changes. Only trailing whitespace and the terminal newline are normalized. No optional X detail is added: no missing premise or meaning error justifies it. The original comparison, pre-feedback snapshot/digest, exact feedback, raw review, identity key and post-feedback adjudication remain separately traceable. This completes the pending judgment/selection follow-up without rerunning unchanged writer or reviewer inputs or changing canonical guidance, pack, native or helpers.
Focused checks cover feedback/comparison hashes, the private snapshot commitment, exact restoration of the key/review/recovery data, source locators, all quoted cross-section spans, unchanged Y wording/anchors and the 3368-character count. All seven program tests, generated-index freshness and artifact/ledger audits pass. Final diff review and the frozen-source guard accompany local fast-forward integration into 2.x. Only CLI-405 progress and its generated index change; all task states, dependencies and accepted-evidence fields remain. No push, publication or acceptance promotion. Retain Y as regression material; future held-out work needs new sources, and broader language/manuscript and disciplinary judgments remain outside this observation.
November 6 — Selectable writing styles
The user additionally asks to retain or refine X and save several writing styles in Qiongli. The style observation retains original X, a separate three-sentence refinement and unchanged selected Y. Canonical writing-styles.md, routed conditionally from scholarly-voice.md, offers concise/explanatory choices and scoped custom samples. Meaning integrity remains shared across F/G4/J2. A local choice does not replace the project default; several saved choices do not all become active. Requested persistence uses the existing context/handoff preview/approval/CAS owner, not a new setting or store.
One isolated run preserves the configured gpt-6-astra/xhigh and completes in 166.8 seconds. The four bilingual style outputs preserve population/groups, scalar-invariance reporting and its intercept exception, and strict-invariance non-retention. Three supplied-context preference cases and an overclaim negative case behave as requested. The fresh model review accepts the three X refinements while retaining the validity of original X; coordinator source comparison agrees, with no required repair or override. The exact 98,915-byte prompt, read-only no-tool turn, input/config/helper preservation and auth cleanup are verified. This reused source is regression material, not a new held-out or human judgment; supplied handoff reasoning is not real project save/restart evidence.
Strict research-standard validation passes 6210/6210 with no warnings; 11 portable routing checks, Skill quick validation and two native embedded-pack tests pass. The supported pack owner regenerates 447 entries from canonical commit 09b9e5fa. The cache-budget check passes with about 1.75 GB of caches and 62.1 GB free. Unqualified Python initially lacks PyYAML before tests/model launch; the existing system interpreter resolves this without an install. The first commit attempt lacks Git identity; per-command use of the existing Codex author identity resolves it without configuration changes. Actual raw execution, notes and bindings are retained at /tmp/qiongli-writing-styles-20261106-5p4gkxzq; focused logs are /tmp/qiongli-writing-styles-{standard,pack,native-content,native-app}.log.
All seven program tests, generated-index freshness and artifact/ledger preservation checks pass. Final diff review and the fast frozen-source guard accompany local fast-forward integration into 2.x. Only CLI-405 progress and the generated index change; task states, dependencies and accepted evidence remain unchanged. No push, release, installed-profile update or acceptance promotion. Next verify saved-preference recovery with an actually requested project save; use a new source for further held-out quality assessment.
November 6 — Writing release closeout and 2.6.0 preparation
The user requests completion of the three writing evidence gaps, preparation of new release content and cleanup of regenerable build caches. The closeout observation binds a real isolated native save, two fresh configured-model recoveries, a Host-labelled Antigravity return and a complete anonymous bilingual example. The existing owners remain responsible for source review, project writes and release qualification; local preparation does not authorize push or publication.
Actual preview/approval/CAS saves retain the public Tarlao2022 source, both complete writing styles and the concise project preference at revision 3. Missing academic or filesystem approval and changed handoff bytes under an old digest refuse with unchanged project/config state. The first real read-only recovery reveals that Graph snapshot discovery rebuilds a derived portfolio catalog and cannot serve this read-only continuation. Native fix 5fa20e32 exposes the existing registered artifact reader as project context read, restricted to research state and stage handoff. It retains before/after semantic/revision checks and safe paths, without new persistence, Graph writes, MCP tools or model defaults. Canonical guidance and 2.6.0 version sources are 1062203c; the supported pack owner regenerates 447 entries from that commit.
Fresh gpt-6-astra/xhigh sessions complete in 115.7/119.5 seconds: recover the concise project default, retain both versions, and apply an explanatory paragraph override without changing the default. Each acknowledges one initial outer-output truncation and completes separate/paged rereads. Saved summary/source bytes, actual prompt delivery, project/config preservation and temporary-auth cleanup are verified. Coordinator source review finds no required meaning repair in the two continuations. Preserve the first failed recovery and exclude the original override attempt, whose preservation check was confounded by a concurrent coordinator Graph diagnostic. These are isolated native CLI observations, not installed-Plugin or general writing-quality acceptance.
Antigravity 1.5.2 completes an actual frozen bilingual-article polishing turn in 73.1 seconds; its runtime log confirms Gemini 4 Argon (Medium), with no supplied model/effort override and unchanged settings. The complete stream has no external tool calls. The Doshi/Hauser public-source example contains four sections in both languages and is reused material, not a new held-out or private manuscript. M/N are randomized once. A fresh blinded source-text model review completes, but its judgments and identity key stay sealed pending the actual human response. Reading/editing time, reviewed languages and reviewer role are unknown; elapsed message time and model review cannot substitute for these facts. No returned manuscript is adopted. The private packet/digest preserves original, return, source, task, comparison, key and review for later verified unsealing.
Strict content validation passes 6211/6211 with no warnings; 11 portable routing, one context-parser, two native save/resume, two embedded-pack and 53 helper/version checks pass. Format passes. Initial failures remain recorded: changed content correctly refuses a stale lock; ambient umask 002 makes fixture files group-writable and is resolved with private fixture umask 077; release-note verification naming is corrected. No native permission check or validation requirement is relaxed.
The 2.6.0 release notes summarize changes since 2.5.3 and retain rollout/rollback limits. Program/index preservation checks and final diff review accompany local fast-forward integration into 2.x. CLI-405/410 progress changes only; all states, dependencies and accepted-evidence fields remain. Current-target release-owner qualification and explicit cache cleanup follow on the clean merged candidate. The final receipt will identify those exact bytes. Human feedback/adjudication, four-target remote distribution and publication remain separate pending work. Raw evidence: /tmp/qiongli-writing-closeout-20261106-fmpzj1jt.
Release preflight repairs and environment qualification
The first clean 2.6.0 candidate 54ce148a stops at strict Clippy under Rust 1.99.1. Source 62800842 makes equivalent fixed-size slice grouping changes across the hex decoders, CLI parsers and release examples, retaining length/remainder and signature guards. e0f3d329 bounds only a cancellation-test handshake that could otherwise wait forever after an early fixture failure. Production update and process-inspection behavior is unchanged.
The preflight record retains the original hung attempt, a completed 231-pass/37-fail/3-ignored run, the failed narrow permission repair, and the exact same-source private checkout. The original workspace has group-writable ancestors; approved materialization correctly refuses that chain. Seven identified generated cache/test directories are tightened without deleting contents, but parent permissions remain unchanged. The private checkout under a secure home chain passes 264 cases, leaving four process-visibility cases and the three existing manual skips. Four same-UID host executable links are unreadable; the guard correctly fails closed. A controlled PID/user namespace with one proc mount and a proper device mount passes all four remaining cases plus the original ambiguous-process negative case. This is combined scoped evidence, not a single full-suite pass or permission to replace executables on this shared host.
The first private-cache transfer was moved before its asynchronous copy completed. It is retained as a coordinator failure, with no qualification claim: the private build was stopped, its incomplete cache removed, and a completed copy verified before the same-source retry. No original source, research record or released binary was removed. Final strict workspace/current-target Clippy and all 138 platform unit tests pass; format passes. The regenerated content pack is unchanged. Local fast-forward integration retains these results and the pending human review. A new current-target release-owner run must use the clean private 2.x checkout; its source, assets and cache cleanup will be recorded separately. No publication, remote synchronization or acceptance promotion occurs.
The next release-mode CLI run on 38219e48 passes 46 cases and fails the legacy inventory count: the isolated fixture inherits the live CODEX_HOME. Removing only the inherited Host roots makes that unchanged case pass. The shared test helpers now clear CODEX_HOME and CLAUDE_CONFIG_DIR; explicit custom-root tests still set their own overrides. The complete release CLI and MCP suites then pass 47/47 and 9/9 with the actual parent environment retained. Format passes. This is a test isolation repair; production discovery and custom Host paths are unchanged. The previous release build was terminated (exit 143) before test results or assets; its log records no compiler error and does not establish the termination cause.
Local 2.6.0 candidate and cache cleanup
Clean source 1a1b6164 passes the supported release owner for Linux ARM64: format, strict Clippy, 47 CLI and 9 MCP tests, extracted archive smoke, clean npm/wheel installs and both Host Plugin packages. The five artifacts, manifest and checksum list agree. The same extracted binary additionally passes both existing saved-handoff/summary recovery journeys, including current-context reads and stale-revision/semantic-drift refusal. Exact details are in release-qualification.json.
The first packaging attempt lacks auditwheel; the system Python also lacks ensurepip. These environment failures remain recorded. The final retry uses the existing Python and task-local auditwheel/patchelf/PyYAML tools. The host build then correctly fails the glibc 2.35 audit because of two versioned glibc 2.39 symbols. The successful candidate uses an isolated Ubuntu 22.04/glibc 2.35 environment with CI Rust 1.97, no network or credentials, and its own target cache. Host system packages and project dependencies remain unchanged.
After builders stop, cleanup removes only ignored debug dependency/incremental directories in the original and private checkout: 8,816,647,564 logical bytes, with 8,545,734,656 bytes of observed disk space recovered. All 45 retained release, executable, project and evaluation files match their pre-cleanup hashes. Other target trees and user configuration remain intact. The read-only cache-budget check passes afterward.
This is an unpublished current-target candidate. Human bilingual review, actual reading/editing time and reviewer role are still pending; model judgments and the anonymous key remain sealed. The next increment is to adjudicate that real feedback, then qualify the exact release source across the advertised targets under the requested publication workflow. No program acceptance, remote push, tag, publication or announcement is implied. Later bookkeeping changes do not change the named artifact source or reuse its evidence for different bytes.
Ordinary-reader feedback and verified unsealing
The reader chooses the public-source complete example, then reports a small overall difference with a slight preference for N before identity disclosure. After disclosure, the reader confirms reading Chinese and English as an ordinary reader and describes M's English as slightly more formal, N's as relatively more informal. Actual reading/editing time is unreported; it remains unknown.
The original packet and all seven file bindings verify. N is the original; M is the Host-confirmed Antigravity return. The human review retains the verbatim feedback, disclosure order, unsealed model review and coordinator source-text adjudication. No required scientific repair is found. Mechanical checks separately expose M's 2458 Chinese code points against a 2400 maximum; the original failure is retained. A separate M refinement reduces this to 2395 while retaining English byte-for-byte. N receives three optional local expression improvements, with 2105 Chinese code points and 1096 English words. Both revised candidates preserve numbers, citations, headings and consequential reasoning/qualifications, and pass the original section/length contract.
The reviewed originals and anonymous comparison remain unchanged. The revisions are review candidates, not newly human-approved texts or project saves. Existing writing/style rules already cover this case, so canonical guidance, model settings and package inputs are unchanged. The Linux ARM64 qualification remains bound to 1a1b6164; this evidence-only update needs no binary rebuild or new cache. Seven program tests, input/hash preservation, length/citation/number/heading checks, final diff review and the local boundary guard cover integration. All task states, dependencies and accepted evidence stay unchanged. Next: review any requested local refinement and qualify the exact release source across the advertised targets under appropriate release authority. No push, publication, general model ranking, expert acceptance or measured efficiency improvement is claimed.
November 13 — CI scheduling and 2.6.0 release preparation
The maintainer requests lower CI usage, especially macOS, before considering the next release. The bounded outcome is local scheduling and artifact-retention changes; keep hosted platform coverage, exact-source publication checks and the existing five required status names. This retains ADRs 0220/0221/0231/0232 rather than returning to local-only macOS acceptance. No remote rules, push, workflow dispatch, tag or publication is authorized by this increment.
Read-only GitHub inspection confirms a public repository. Standard hosted runner compute is free for public repositories under the current GitHub billing documentation. Runtime totals below are measured job durations, not billing amounts. Artifact and cache storage are separate usage categories; no account invoice was inspected.
The last published 2.5.3 source, 2081a0335d3784dd00708ecc8223fea4a0127b42, ran the full distribution both on main push and immutable-tag dispatch. The push also ran Cargo qualification. Removing that push-triggered copy would avoid 13 successful jobs in this historical example: 3,761 aggregate runner-seconds (62m41s), including 950 macOS seconds (15m50s). This is a bounded counterfactual from one source, not measured savings from the unpushed changes or a forecast of monthly costs.
Changes:
- Distribution runs only by explicit dispatch; Release Automation already dispatches the immutable tag. Cargo retains manual qualification and published release entry points, plus its pre-publication and public-install target matrices.
- Runtime PRs still test Linux/macOS/Windows. Documentation-only and failed-boundary native contexts run lightweight reporting on Linux without allocating macOS or Windows runners. The boundary failure itself remains required and blocking.
- Manual Native CI defaults to
profile=cli.profile=fullexplicitly enables desktop consumers on all platforms, capacity, desktop packaging, candidate lifecycle, packaged-product acceptance and the existing Community Alpha chain. PR-scoped Linux desktop checks remain unchanged. - Temporary distribution/Cargo artifacts retain seven days; published release assets and valid build caches are untouched. No cache deletion or new large cache is introduced. Candidate installation has a 20-minute limit.
- Evaluation Truth runs the inexpensive routing/publication/target policy tests on PRs. Canonical product/content/model settings and frozen legacy code are unchanged. Contributor commands and the pending 2.6.0 notes describe the new scheduling; no additional version bump is needed for an unpublished candidate.
Focused validation:
- Actionlint 1.7.12 validates the four edited workflows, including expression and job/output references. Its official Linux ARM64 archive checksum is verified; optional ShellCheck/Pyflakes integrations are not installed or claimed.
- The actual command extracted from Evaluation Truth's new policy step passes 36 tests. Release automation/version checks pass 59; the separate asset checks pass three and program-ledger checks pass seven: 105 distinct Python tests in total, including wrong-main/tag/source, failed-CI/assets, local-publication refusal, frozen paths, unknown changes and complete target rosters.
- An initial test command cannot import PyYAML in the default Python. Reusing system Python 3.12.3/PyYAML 6.0.1 resolves that environment issue without changing project dependencies. CI retains its pinned Python 3.12/PyYAML 6.0.3 setup.
- The broader release check exposes a pre-existing failure: two Alpha-only Rust tests introduced in
ecbf55e42use the historical2.0.0-alpha.1literal, which the active-release scanner correctly refuses. Use a synthetic2.0.0-alpha.999fixture instead; retain Alpha behavior, assertions and the unchanged scanner. Both complete examples pass (8 + 2 tests) under CI Rust 1.97 in the existing offline Ubuntu 22.04 container with current source mounted read-only. Cache reuse completes compilation and tests in 90.1 seconds; no release artifact is rebuilt or overwritten. - Rust format, the old-literal scan, 2.6.0 version/channel/content agreement and final diff checks pass. The read-only cache-budget check passes with about 50.7 GB free before compilation. The 249 task identities/states/dependencies and accepted evidence remain unchanged; only CLI-410 progress/date and its generated projection change.
Release readiness: Not ready for publication. The earlier Linux ARM64 packet remains qualified at 1a1b6164; it does not stand in for a new final-source run. This increment completes local CI optimization and release-note preparation. After local fast-forward integration, the next increment is authorized remote synchronization followed by final-source hosted checks and the existing immutable-tag four-target distribution/publication workflow. No hosted run was started, so the revised scheduling and aggregate savings still need observation on GitHub. Published bytes, user data, models and remote protection are unchanged.
Authorized 2.6.0 publication handoff
The maintainer now explicitly authorizes remote push and publication, then no further release-progress tracking. This covers reviewed stable-main fast-forward, the new immutable v2.6.0 tag and the existing post-mode Release Automation dispatch. End the task as soon as that dispatch is accepted; do not poll release runs, uploads or registries afterward, or claim completion from dispatch alone.
Remote inspection finds main at 2081a033 with no divergent commits and no existing v2.6.0 tag/release. Use the established stable-main path; no protected 2.x rewrite, ruleset change or unrelated branch push is needed. ADR 0242 now explicitly supersedes ADR 0227's old main-push build scheduling while preserving its stable-source and publication gates. Historical ADRs remain unchanged.
Qualify the clean local candidate with the existing Linux ARM64/glibc 2.35 release owner, reusing the offline CI Rust 1.97 environment and cache. Review the actual artifacts, extracted installs and source/checksum bindings before pushing. The final tag's four-target distribution, public-download and registry gates remain delegated to the existing workflow. Record the local result below without promoting program acceptance or claiming unobserved hosted/publication outcomes.
Local qualification before the authorized push
Clean candidate 1b3cc16ec8ecb6e71f3fe26a05ac3baa5d178eb1 passes release_ready.sh --cli-github --version 2.6.0 on Linux ARM64/glibc 2.35, using the retained offline Ubuntu 22.04 environment and CI Rust 1.97 cache. The 182.6-second run passes version/channel/content alignment, format, strict Clippy, 47 release CLI tests and nine MCP tests, extracted empty-PATH execution, clean npm/wheel installation and both native Host Plugin checks. Independent inspection verifies all five asset sizes/hashes and the checksum list. The highest required GLIBC symbol is 2.34, within the advertised 2.35 baseline.
The evidence root is /tmp/qiongli-260-publication-20261113-cfinceas, with the complete qualification.log, result.json and independent artifact-audit.json. The binary SHA-256 is 7b5f84454d926271f3c82079466c0c99bca2055143a6e4334a8f89008b5a57c3; the release manifest is 76a4714ce1144836ed5517cca8e6771bc7928c0146f2a1cd914a2b2c482ec386; SHA256SUMS is b99708e8e458a66b254761d02ef4bdcc3f7dd640b965077bb9110b1814c4cce2. The content pack remains b73a4c0349ef98b3d1fc02a330effdcf9a6b54b947dafd238dc8ccd0b9fb04c1. Thirty affected ADR/frozen-baseline/program tests pass, the generated index is current, and final diff and frozen-source checks pass. A bounded scan of the 213 changed files finds no private-key or credential-token pattern matches; it is not a comprehensive security audit.
The final bookkeeping changes only this plan and CLI-410's progress projection; reuse the unchanged local checks. Atomically push the reviewed main fast-forward and immutable v2.6.0, then dispatch the existing post-mode Release Automation at that tag. The workflow rebuilds and qualifies the exact tag across all four targets before publishing; this local packet does not replace that gate. This is ready for the authorized handoff, not evidence of completed publication. Stop on accepted dispatch with no subsequent run, release or registry polling.
November 13 — repair retired macOS release runners
The maintainer reports failed release CI and requests diagnosis and repair, reopening inspection of the preceding handoff. Continue the already authorized publication through the existing owner; preserve immutable tags and full target gates. The repair is scoped to the failed macOS path, not ongoing registry progress tracking or a new program acceptance claim.
Failure and repair
Release Automation 43413326499 fails when distribution 43413369010 returns cancelled for source a8ea20bed24b805b766b784679e1b4bd405f205f / v2.6.0. The macOS ARM64 job 131845128303 is cancelled before any steps. Its check annotation says: The configuration 'macos-14-arm64-us-default' is not supported. Windows x64 and Linux x64/ARM64 builds succeed, while assembly and combined installs are skipped. Release Automation stops before release creation or registry dispatch; the API still lists v2.5.3 as the latest published release.
GitHub's official retirement notice removes macOS 14 runners on November 2, 2026 and lists macos-15 as an ARM64 replacement. Update all four affected matrix entries: CLI build, combined install, Cargo qualification and public Cargo install. Retain target-native execution, all four targets, Linux glibc baseline, upgrade checks, credential environments and exact-source publication gates. No other workflow scheduling changes.
The existing target-roster test now requires the supported macOS build image, matches the combined installer roster to builders, and checks both Cargo stages. It fails against the retired configuration and passes after the repair. This is a regression check for the known retirement, not automatic discovery of future GitHub image retirements.
Preserve v2.6.0; a rerun at that immutable tag would retain the broken workflow. Use the version synchronization owner for 2.6.1 and regenerate the embedded pack from canonical source 30749f75b3507fa20489536cb7a66b99bf5e4a02. The nine metadata files differ only in Qiongli versions; dependency versions and writing rules are unchanged. The pack has 447 entries and SHA-256 8d9c74c592b8a9fcc9245a5d6229f13e8f5f0fc1ea4de36f6c7fcb08e859ee00.
Validation and recovery handoff
Ninety distinct Python tests pass: branch policy, release publisher, registry packages, Marketplace Plugins, release assets, CLI packaging, version contract, program ledger and native change boundary. Actionlint 1.7.12 passes both changed workflows (without ShellCheck/Pyflakes integrations). The v2.6.1 version guard, diff checks and frozen-source boundary pass. All 249 task states, dependencies, accepted evidence and commit/run bindings remain unchanged; only CLI-410 progress and the generated index change.
The clean Linux ARM64/glibc 2.35 candidate is 0e49c6886749be18f7d63b1f0c02b9189dc47156. Its canonical release qualification passes in 488.7 seconds in the retained offline Ubuntu 22.04 / Rust 1.97 environment with existing build caches. The owner passes format, strict Clippy, 47 release CLI tests and nine MCP tests, extracted empty-PATH execution, isolated npm/wheel installs and native Codex/Claude Plugin checks. Independent audit matches all five asset sizes/hashes and SHA256SUMS; the highest required GLIBC symbol remains 2.34.
Evidence root: /tmp/qiongli-261-publication-20261113-m08fuhno, including qualification.log, result.json and artifact-audit.json. Binary SHA-256: 4ad953995af03861dcf3c40d08bbf91973a0645c7ef4b6e96dc12bbda559c82d; manifest SHA-256: 326f0e643cf4fb84de03db16ac1e7ce2e434fde9d9cf1213936339f9e6838371; SHA256SUMS SHA-256: 1365fc0583205eba923a5dd9f42c011e651defd48b962588da8ffc75f59e65ac.
Final bookkeeping changes only the roadmap, this plan and CLI-410's progress projection; qualification inputs are unchanged. Integrate locally into 2.x, fast-forward stable main and push the new immutable v2.6.1 tag atomically, then dispatch post-mode Release Automation at that tag. Verify that the replacement macOS runner starts the previously blocked build. Exact-tag four-target, public download and registry gates remain with that workflow; no local result or accepted dispatch is reported as completed publication.
Observed recovery dispatch
Reviewed source 25b6bf36f06b2f2ddb1b2395a88bb5dcd9b9cdb3 is merged locally into 2.x and stable main, then atomically pushed to remote main with new tag v2.6.1. Remote v2.6.0 remains bound to a8ea20be; protected remote 2.x and remote rules are unchanged. The final source differs from qualified 0e49c688 only in the four roadmap/plan/ledger/index files.
Release Automation 43420568339 accepts the post-mode dispatch and starts distribution 43420598962 at the exact v2.6.1 source. At 11:53 UTC, macOS job 131869330081 has a macos-15 runner and successful setup, checkout, Python, Node, Rust 1.97 and cache steps. Its native build/package/install step is in progress. This directly resolves the original unsupported-runner startup failure; it does not yet prove the full macOS build, combined installs or publication successful.
Stop further remote tracking after this bounded failure-path check, preserving the maintainer's prior handoff preference. The existing workflow owns complete four-target qualification, public-download verification and registry dispatch. This final local evidence update does not move the tagged source or any tag.
November 13 — published installation entry consistency
The maintainer supplies the external v2.6.1 review and requests the next round. The first bounded outcome is a consistent route to the published stable CLI. Start from local 2.x at cd980b11a116646339d7eef03c65c637849a2db0; retain existing models, runtime behavior, historical observations and acceptance gates.
Diagnosis and change
The native release path delegates before the legacy download updater runs; native version synchronization updates package inputs but not these pages. Both README and install guides still recommend 2.5.1, while both documentation home pages describe 2.3.0. npm's floating latest also differs from the pinned pip/Cargo recommendations. The legacy updater targets retired page headings and Desktop/MCPB structure and cannot maintain the current native installation path.
On November 13, read-only public API inspection directly observes v2.6.1, published at 12:04:35 UTC with 20 assets. The local immutable tag resolves to 25b6bf36f06b2f2ddb1b2395a88bb5dcd9b9cdb3. This updates the publication fact without rewriting earlier records that stopped at runner startup.
Align all six entry pages to 2.6.1, including notes, four platform archives, SHA256SUMS and pinned npm/pip/Cargo examples. The new read-only tooling/scripts/check_native_install_docs.py checks against published stable metadata, independently of the development Cargo version. It validates official asset URLs, positive sizes, published digests, the checksum file's own digest, archive coverage and platform-to-link mapping. No binaries are downloaded or executed. Missing metadata, stale pages and mismatches fail explicitly.
Expose the check through npm run docs:check-install and the existing Evaluation Truth job with its read-only GitHub token; no remote rule or runtime CI changes. Saved release API JSON plus original SHA256SUMS allow an explicitly labelled offline replay, which cannot establish that the snapshot is still latest. CONTRIBUTING documents stable-versus-candidate ownership. The bilingual publisher guides use explicit candidate/staging placeholders rather than another stale hardcoded version.
Validation and remaining work
The live checker first rejects the original pages, then passes all six corrected pages against public v2.6.1 metadata and checksum bytes. Seventy-six distinct Python tests pass across installation docs, distribution docs, branch policy, native change boundary, native release publisher, version contract and version sync. Installation cases cover stale agreeing pages, individual language drift, wrong/missing/duplicate assets, swapped platforms, unpinned commands, unpublished releases, checksum changes, network failure and read-only offline replay. Actionlint 1.7.12 passes the changed workflow without ShellCheck/Pyflakes integrations. npm run docs:build passes with dead-link checking enabled.
Initial checks exposed two existing publisher-guide subtest failures from 2.3.0 examples and 19 site-external observation links in this plan. Correct the examples and use immutable v2.6.1 GitHub links for those observations; every target exists in that tag. Preserve observation bodies and original results. The site retains nonfatal syntax-highlighting fallbacks and a bundle-size warning.
Update only CLI-410 progress and regenerate the current index; retain all 249 task states, dependencies and accepted evidence/commit/run bindings. All seven ledger tests and the generated-index check pass; a direct baseline comparison confirms those bindings are unchanged. Local checks and integration do not establish installed-Host readiness, registry installation, minimum macOS runtime compatibility or improved academic quality. No product schema, project data, credentials, model settings, release tags or assets change.
The next bounded increment should clarify existing installation/session/provider states in task terms, preserving unknown and unchecked results. Then capture one current-package long-material/save/fresh-session journey before adding a targeted reader or adapter fix. A frozen same-Host/same-model three-arm protocol follows separately; do not relabel old observations or launch a large experiment as part of this documentation repair. Local integration is authorized; push and publication remain outside this round.
November 13 — task readiness display
The maintainer requests the next step after the installation-page repair at 50a6b326e4358b1d241092852397b46726523579. The bounded outcome is an understandable account of local capabilities and untested research tasks, using the existing CLI presentation owner. No new probe, health database or schema is needed.
doctor already receives the reason local-host-registered-session-unchecked and a session-check remediation, but its text renderer hides both when the local check is ready. A focused regression first fails on the missing reason, then passes after retaining actionable remediation on ready checks. Installation inventory, local MCP checking and provider status already contain the required underlying distinctions; their structured results remain unchanged.
The terminal/--text summaries now explain retrieval and saving before diagnostic details. Local Full MCP installation is distinct from saving in the active Host; Lite lacks project saving, and an unknown profile does not imply Full. Current, refresh-required, conflicting and unavailable installation observations retain their existing states and version/reason details. Refresh guidance asks users to compare CLI and Plugin versions before updating. Missing keys, missing public settings, disabled providers and unsupported credential storage stay distinct. Configured providers retain untested credential/connectivity status; failed online results preserve their reason and exit code. Installation completion keeps Hook trust/session checks pending and retains exact source/cache locations.
The native runtime contract and bilingual installation guide explain these boundaries. Redirected JSON, approval previews, project preview/approval/CAS, credential ownership, models, client settings and all write paths are unchanged.
Validation and remaining work
Nine presentation tests, four affected CLI integration tests, 27 installation/ distribution documentation tests and seven ledger tests pass. Strict Clippy for the CLI library, binary and integration test passes, as do formatting, diff and generated-index checks. The documentation site builds with dead-link checks enabled; its existing highlighting fallbacks and bundle-size warning remain. A baseline comparison preserves all 249 task states, dependencies and accepted evidence/commit/run bindings; only CLI-410 progress and its index projection change.
Native validation uses the existing offline Linux ARM64/Rust 1.97 container and build cache. The first CLI batch passes three tests but the Plugin lifecycle fixture refuses before JSON output. Independent reproduction reports insecure-materialization-parent for the group-writable checkout path. A byte-identical private source copy with directory mode 700 passes the remaining test in 21.79 seconds, retaining approval rejection, drift detection and user-file preservation. No product guard is weakened. The initial failed regression, three-pass/one-failure batch, diagnosis and private retry remain in /tmp/qiongli-readiness-20261113. Temporary driver corrections for image lookup and the minimal container's missing Python preceded actual test/diagnosis execution; neither is counted as a product test result.
The next increment should capture one long-material/save/fresh-session journey using an identified current package and the user's configured Host/model. These presentation checks do not establish live Host/session readiness, successful online research, macOS Keychain access or academic-quality gains. Keep CLI-410 progress separate from accepted evidence; local integration does not authorize remote synchronization or publication.
November 13 — long-material delivery and fresh-session recovery
The maintainer requests the next step after readiness presentation. Starting from 29573774, reproduce one actual Codex reading/save/recovery journey and repair only demonstrated friction. Downloaded public v2.6.1 Linux ARM64 CLI and Codex Plugin archives match their GitHub asset digests and the same SHA256SUMS. The release manifest binds native source 25b6bf36f06b2f2ddb1b2395a88bb5dcd9b9cdb3; the embedded content digest is 8d9c74c592b8a9fcc9245a5d6229f13e8f5f0fc1ea4de36f6c7fcb08e859ee00. Do not substitute the retained pre-publication 2.6.1 candidate.
The canonical observation is evals/research_journey/long-material/observations/2026-11-13/README.md. It retains frozen synthetic source/criteria, both tasks and full answers, sanitized actual tool calls/results, policy/preservation records, preview/apply receipts and a byte-level delivered-coverage audit. Raw captures and setup/check logs remain under /tmp/qiongli-long-recovery-20261113; exported evidence is hash-bound and excludes rollout reasoning and credentials. This reuses the existing research-journey execution/delivery owners and leaves historical three-case baseline scoring unchanged.
Codex 0.167.0 retains configured gpt-6-astra / xhigh in two fresh isolated read-only, tool-network-disabled profiles, with effective app-server readback. The 39,667-byte invented source places important limitations after long Chinese and escaped-JSON appendices. Drafting completes in 97.47 seconds: 12 native/shell calls, two failed help requests, no outer truncation. All three source pages are actually delivered; the coordinator source review retains the candidate unchanged. The coordinator then reviews and approves its revision-3 summary/handoff save through the existing native owners. A fresh project-ID-only continuation receives no previous prose/preferences inline and completes in 216.95 seconds: 34 calls, four failed help requests and one outer truncation, with no wrapper script failure.
Recovery correctly distinguishes the saved original's historical revision-2 text from its revision-3 receipt, recovers the concise default and next-paragraph-only explanatory override, and preserves unresolved pretest, unaided/retention and F1 image limitations. The 23,351-byte handoff first truncates at the native 16 KiB window; increasing the limit and batching long guidance then truncates the outer return. A separate tail read overlaps the original prefix and completes delivery. The 3,014-byte summary and required source fields are delivered. Other appendix bodies are parsed inside the wrapper but not all returned for model review; the answer preserves that distinction. Successful sibling outputs survive failed help requests. Both turns preserve project/config/input/package bytes and require no Graph rebuild or coordinator intervention during the turn. Human time and actual billing are unknown; token usage is retained without converting it to cost.
Repair, checks and next increment
Both actual sessions expose missing project document help routes. The existing cli_help.rs owner now lists document commands and serves scoped list/read/search help, reusing the saved-document syntax and including it in help all. Two CLI integration tests pass, including an unusable config root, all help aliases, unknown-topic refusal and incomplete-read errors. Strict Rust 1.97 Clippy, format, diff checks, four delivery-helper tests and seven ledger tests pass. The documentation site builds in 51.37 seconds with its existing highlighting/bundle-size warnings. Negative native checks reject stale revision, wrong source hash, missing save approvals, wrong preview digest and a changed source between pages without accepting writes or mixed versions. The synthetic source is restored byte-for-byte after the last negative check. Reader/MCP/schema/model/write authority is unchanged.
Setup/audit failures are retained: public web-cache/DNS access, missing PyYAML in the default Python, nested sandbox socket-mode refusal, initial formatting, and a coverage-audit field-name assumption. System Python, a host-context preflight with the same inner read-only/no-network policy, formatting, and actual context artifact field names resolve those attempts. The two model turns are not rerun or replaced. The small help repair has local CLI evidence, not a new model comparison.
This is one synthetic direct CLI journey with extracted release guidance; it does not qualify an installed Plugin/MCP, real-paper quality, online providers, other platforms or net benefit. Next verify an isolated installed Codex Plugin's actual tool discovery and current-context recovery path on an identified candidate, retaining native CLI fallback and the observed two-layer delivery limits. Keep the three-arm quality experiment separate. All 249 task states/dependencies and accepted evidence/commit/run bindings remain unchanged; only CLI-410 progress advances. Integrate locally into 2.x; no remote synchronization or publication is authorized.
November 13 — installed Plugin recovery and default directory repair
The maintainer continues from 775b94aa. The bounded outcome is actual discovery and fresh-session recovery through an isolated installed Codex Plugin, retaining the existing CLI context fallback. The preceding synthetic revision-3 project is copied byte-for-byte and registered without replacing its manifest. No private research is accessed. The exact public v2.6.1 Linux ARM64 binary from source 25b6bf36f06b2f2ddb1b2395a88bb5dcd9b9cdb3 exports a Full local Plugin through reviewed native preview/apply; the official Codex manager installs qiongli@qiongli-cli-local. Source/cache receipts and binary hashes match. This is not the separately downloaded Lite marketplace archive.
The canonical observation is evals/research_journey/long-material/observations/2026-11-13-installed-plugin/README.md. It retains installation previews/receipts, effective policy, actual tool discovery, task/criteria, the complete answer, tool-only rollout export, received byte-coverage proof, fingerprint preservation, setup failures and focused repair checks. Raw captures and scratch drivers remain in /tmp/qiongli-installed-recovery-20261113; the persistent isolated source/profile live under the private /home/hermes/qiongli-installed-recovery-20261113 root. Published evidence replaces these paths with placeholders and excludes credentials, reasoning and unrelated configuration. The temporary authentication link is removed after the turn.
Codex 0.167.0 preserves the configured gpt-6-astra / xhigh. App-server policy readback confirms three approved installed project read tools, no direct MCP override, and a read-only, tool-network-disabled shell profile. Actual discovery binds those tools to the installed Plugin and has no tool error. The request gives the project ID and routing constraints, with no saved preferences, prose, revision or source hash. Explicit guidance/routing cues limit any discovery claim.
The fresh turn finishes in 182.75 seconds: 7 successful MCP and 13 successful shell calls, zero outer truncations and zero wrapper failures. It recovers the concise default, next-paragraph-only explanatory override, preserved original and missing pretest, unaided/retention and F1 checks. MCP delivers the 3,014-byte summary and 39,667-byte source in four contiguous UTF-8 ranges. CLI context reads deliver research state and the 23,351-byte handoff. The first 16,384-byte handoff window truncates; a larger native read verifies the prefix and sends only the remaining 6,967 bytes to the model. The archive verifies the actual received prefix plus tail, not merely the successful inner read. Project/config/source/cache/input fingerprints remain equal; no Graph rebuild or mutation occurs. Coordinator source review finds no substantive repair necessary. Human minutes and billed cost remain unknown, and one synthetic run establishes no net quality or efficiency gain.
Demonstrated repair and validation
The release and current tree accept qiongli-codex in an install preview, and the guided installer selects that default, but the bundle composer rejects apply as codex-plugin-bundle-target-invalid. Claude has the same CLI/composer mismatch. The two existing platform bundle owners now accept their matching -codex or -claude stable/prerelease names for local exports. Legacy directory reuse, receipt-selected Plugin identity, signed naming and security checks remain. The released observation succeeds through the supported legacy qiongli leaf; the fixed candidate is separately applied at the originally rejected path and reports source-current, without being substituted into the observed Plugin.
The CLI lifecycle regression passes across six Host/directory combinations, retaining missing-approval, tampered-plan, update/remove, drift, linked/reserved path and user-file negative checks. Four focused Codex/Claude signed/local bundle tests pass; signed composition explicitly refuses the new local-only names. Rust 1.97 strict Clippy passes for the platform library and CLI library/binary/test, as do format/diff checks and seven ledger tests. The documentation site builds with its existing env/gitignore highlighting and bundle-size warnings. The offline private build snapshot is byte-identical to tracked sources; no product directory guard is weakened.
Setup failures remain distinct: persistent exports and managed HOME under /tmp are refused; private ancestors resolve these. The observation driver initially uses the wrong marketplace ID and an unnecessary standalone search-tool name; manager/live-tool readback supplies the declared ID and actual three-tool policy before the model turn. The export audit initially expects a complete handoff in one outer result, then correctly accounts for its explicit tail-only delivery. A scratch build-copy attempt names a nonexistent directory before switching to the actual tracked-file list. These attempts do not replace any model run.
The next increment freezes the same-Host/model direct-use / guidance / full-tooling protocol and calibration inputs, including normal Host read/write capabilities, shared outcome metrics and independent quality-review gaps. Keep this used fixture as regression evidence and preserve historical three-case scoring. No new MCP context endpoint, research store, Host/model setting or write authority is needed for this increment. All 249 task states, dependencies and accepted bindings stay unchanged; only CLI-410 progress advances. Integrate locally into 2.x, without push, publication or a claim of other-platform/Host or program acceptance.
November 13 — three-arm protocol and calibration preparation
The maintainer continues from 581fbe9c. The bounded outcome is a frozen same-Host, same-configured-model comparison design and reproducible calibration preparation. Canonical materials live in evals/research_journey/three-arm/; the parent journey README links them. A retains normal Host tools, files and persistence; B adds frozen research guidance; C adds native tools/state and their necessary routing. B/C receive the same available research-guidance bytes. C-specific source wrappers, ingestion, schemas and coordinator work are recorded rather than hidden from cost. Common outcomes never require A/B to use Qiongli files, receipts or calls.
Two new explicitly fictional calibration tasks cover quantitative multi-report reasoning and faithful bilingual editing followed by a source correction in a fresh session. Each runs once per arm: six units, nine sessions, with dependent continuity sessions kept together. Original/candidate/source versions and local style decisions remain distinct. Review criteria and later checkpoint inputs are separate from producer inputs. Blind IDs use a different private key from the public run-order seed; actual isolation must be checked before model execution.
The protocol separates facts, coverage, citation support, reasoning, meaning, expression, recovery, human effort and actual execution cost. It retains failed units, initial attempts and limited environment retries, and distinguishes coordinator/model review from independent expertise. No combined quality score is defined. The six-task, three-repeat main cohort is still unselected: its actual sources, reviewer assignments, cost ceiling and worthwhile-benefit thresholds must be frozen before main outputs. Used calibration/regression material cannot become unseen evidence through renaming. The historical three-case baseline and scoring owners are unchanged.
comparison.py checks the explicit 15-file frozen selection, copies it to a new external directory and creates the schedule and unready preparation record. It reuses existing selected-file binding and writing-packet freeze/recovery owners; it adds no runner, model call, scorer, research store or project-write authority. Changed/missing inputs, checkpoint leakage, path escapes, links, duplicate selection, invalid seeds and overwrite attempts are refused. It does not enforce Host permissions: exposing the whole preparation directory would leak review criteria.
An actual offline preparation at /tmp/qiongli-three-arm-calibration-20261113 uses seed 20261113 and recovers all 18 bound files. Its packet SHA-256 is 665677b067ef940218dc23aaf16214336ea3047dd2a639df924f5091cb9e9e97. All six units and nine sessions remain not started; model calls are zero, runtime identity unknown, and runtime/main-cohort readiness false. The preparation root has mode 0700. This verifies input identity and scheduling, not model delivery or academic outcomes.
Validation: seven new preparation tests, 31 existing writing/journey tests, 24 historical Plugin baseline tests and seven ledger tests pass (69 total). Frozen-material check, ledger/index freshness and whitespace checks pass; the documentation site builds in 51.03 seconds with its existing env/gitignore highlighting and bundle-size warnings. Final review finds no blocking issue in this preparation scope. No live calibration or independent quality review ran.
Next bind actual installed guidance, configured runtime, effective policy and per-arm permitted files, then execute this calibration in its retained order. Record raw attempts, actual delivered material, timing and interventions; preserve unknown human minutes/billing and independent-review gaps. Main-study selection and effect claims follow calibration, not preparation. No user model/configuration, research data or public package changes. Only CLI-410 blocker progress advances; all 249 task states, dependencies and accepted bindings stay unchanged. Integrate locally into 2.x without push or publication.
November 18 — DeepSeek npm install under pnpm script policy
The maintainer reports that the Desktop manager returns ERR_PNPM_IGNORED_BUILDS at step 8 for [email protected], while Desktop's Versions panel reports 2.6.1. The CLI never reached its language preference write.
Verify the public npm tarball against registry integrity. In a fresh Linux workspace with pnpm 11.7.0 and strictDepBuilds: true, an offline add returns the same error while leaving the package and its DSH entry on disk. The package declares postinstall: node bin/install.mjs, which only starts the optional terminal migration review. The package already includes the Plugin entry and prebuilt executables. The official manager owns registration.
Remove the automatic launcher from new native npm outputs and document the existing explicit migration command. The verifier still recognizes the exact historical hook through 2.6.1. Keep the official DSH command and script policy. After a nonzero package exit, reuse the existing profile, exact-version and content checks with no writes. A verified existing state gets a distinct diagnostic alongside the original manager failure. A missing or damaged bundle keeps the original failure, and interruption keeps its existing behavior.
Repack the same four published binaries and DSH files with the canonical packer for a local A/B check. The native/DSH payload remains byte-identical. The same pnpm version and policy install the repack successfully, with both CLI shims, 22 Skill entries and 35 Full MCP tools observed on Linux ARM64. The released tarball, pnpm logs and provider check are in /tmp/qiongli-dsh-pnpm.xklHbY. This local repack isolates the packaging change. The macOS Desktop session still needs a live check after a future version ships.
The original workspace test run hit group-writable ancestor and loopback restrictions. A private source snapshot with Rust 1.97 and loopback passes 26 Host tests. The read-only recovery fixture covers a verified existing bundle, a damaged receipt and interruption, keeping the language file untouched on failure. Two batch tests pass. The real repack passes the Rust content check and the terminal fixture passes under a real PTY, for 30 distinct Rust passes. Packaging/release tests pass 52 checks. Preserve the current v2.6.1 tag and package. Integrate the fix locally for future releases.
Full five-Host installation log
The maintainer supplies the complete macOS qiongli update all output. Codex times out before any source preview or conflict listing, narrowing the observed failure to plugin marketplace list --json or plugin list --json. The old installer omits the specific failed probe. The two probes and configuration read pass on isolated Linux Codex CLI 0.167.0. The user's CLI version, failing command and underlying wait on macOS still require a same-profile observation.
Show the failing read-only inventory command, reason and limit without replaying captured output. Report the specific Codex migration request and remove a separate unbounded I/O thread join after the app-server timeout. The fixture holds a helper's inherited pipe open and checks that installation returns by its deadline. A delayed initialization cannot start a configuration request after the deadline. If an approved write was already sent, inspect enabled entries before retrying. Keep existing approvals and the 30-second limit.
Claude Code's exact conflict is qiongli-next@qiongli-local. Report enabled conflicts with their scope, and print a manual disable command only for known user entries. Claude Code 2.1.318 verifies the scoped command on a synthetic plugin with the same ID in an isolated profile. Readback confirms it is disabled and its original installation path remains. The maintainer's scope is unknown.
The log confirms DeepSeek upgraded its package files from 2.5.1 to 2.6.1 before pnpm 11.28.5 rejected the optional script. With the exact pnpm version in an isolated Linux reproduction, the published tarball exits 1 and still contains 2.6.1. The preceding script-free repack exits 0 under the same strict policy. Antigravity and Pi pass registration in the supplied log. Session readiness remains a separate check for all five Hosts.
Rust 1.97 passes 29 Host tests with two existing opt-in tests skipped. A first attempt using the shell's default group-writable umask is refused by the private profile/cache guards. The same binary passes with umask 077. The focused tests cover timed-out inventory without raw output, inherited pipe timeout and scoped Claude remediation. Integrate locally into 2.x; record the remaining macOS evidence gap without changing program acceptance or publishing a new version.
Codex 0.169.0 inventory deadline
The maintainer's later shell output identifies Codex CLI 0.169.0. Both manual commands return JSON for seven marketplaces and 26 installed entries. The enabled Qiongli entry is qiongli@qiongli-cli-local 2.5.1. The output includes remote account entries and no timings. It confirms that the existing registration remains available and does not identify the earlier Mac command's elapsed time.
Codex v0.169.0's CLI source shows the full list waiting on remote inventory. The remote client allows 60 seconds across installed pages. An isolated official Linux ARM64 0.169.0 binary with synthetic credentials and a loopback service returns two installed pages at 17 seconds each. The marketplace list completes in 0.12 seconds and makes no mock requests. The full list times out at 30.10 seconds under the old bound and returns valid JSON at 34.06 seconds under 75 seconds. The published Qiongli 2.6.1 installer produces host-command-timeout before preview in the same delayed scenario at 31.07 seconds.
Allow 75 seconds for the full Codex list in interactive installation and use the same limit for approval rechecks and registration verification. Keep all returned entries for conflict checks. The market list, Claude, registration mutations, Codex configuration RPC and fast status probes keep their existing limits. Five focused Rust tests pass, including a delayed list that retains a remote Qiongli conflict and a timeout that identifies the failed command without captured text.
The fixed installer reaches the file approval prompt in the same terminal fixture, exits successfully after the explicit decline, and creates no Plugin source. The full test takes 55.93 seconds including local plan generation. A first run with an unstripped 285 MB debug binary exceeds the outer test harness deadline while generating the plan. Strip debug sections only from the temporary fixture copy for the successful retry. This does not establish a completed Mac upgrade or live session readiness. Integrate into local 2.x for a future release.
November 18 — v2.6.2 release qualification
The maintainer authorizes preflight, stable-main push, immutable v2.6.2 and the existing release task. Stop after dispatch. The maintainer owns the follow-up macOS upgrade checks. Use the reviewed integrated 2.x tree for the stable cutover. The release notes cover the three Host fixes, the default Codex and Claude source directories, and the already integrated CLI status and help fixes. The accompanying evaluation changes document synthetic or public-source trials and prepare calibration, without promoting program acceptance.
The stable target roster remains macOS ARM64, Windows x64 and Linux x64/ARM64. Publication uses the exact-tag workflow and existing npm, PyPI and Cargo gates. Six public install pages still pin published v2.6.1 and pass against its release API metadata and checksum list. The published-link check requires publication before those pins advance. Rollback uses the prior CLI in its original package channel and the Host's Plugin controls. Retain research files, settings and source backups when changing CLI or Plugin versions.
The canonical version owner synchronizes nine metadata files and the content generator rebuilds all 447 entries. The locked content pack SHA-256 is 848391102ca4464664269f062bd8865a63ffe4e15f71f1fde2b62b361de3ca49. Focused validation passes 135 Python tests across release contracts, package projection, install documentation, CI policy, program index and evaluation fixtures. A bounded scan of 130 release-change files finds no private-key, known credential token, JWT or personal attachment pattern. The pre-existing synthetic URL credential in an output redaction test is excluded from the count. This scan is limited to the checked patterns.
The first Ubuntu 22.04/Rust 1.97 preflight at 26a4750e stops under strict Clippy on manual Option::unwrap_or in Claude's scope display. Preserve allowlisted scope labels by filtering before fallback. The targeted regression checks that unknown scope text stays out of the output. The corrected clean candidate is 25b096dd6a2d93e7c8b955dc237c73a692287eef. Keep the original failure log alongside the retry in /tmp/qiongli-262-release.upVpA6.
The corrected 25b096dd candidate passes the canonical release preflight in 807.3 seconds on offline Ubuntu 22.04 / Rust 1.97 / Linux ARM64. Format, strict Clippy, 49 release CLI and nine MCP tests pass. Extracted empty-PATH execution, isolated npm/wheel installation and Codex/Claude Plugin checks pass. Nine focused Host regressions also pass, including the unknown-scope negative case. Independent audit verifies sizes and hashes for all five packaged assets plus the manifest and SHA256SUMS coverage. The highest required GLIBC symbol is 2.34.
The official published 2.6.1 npm and PyPI packages both upgrade to the candidate and retain all three research/settings fixtures byte for byte. Under pnpm 11.28.5 with strictDepBuilds: true, the actual candidate installs in a fresh workspace and upgrades a workspace left by the 2.6.1 script refusal. Both qiongli and ql report 2.6.2 and the Linux DeepSeek Plugin exposes 22 Skills and 35 Full MCP tools. The candidate package contains no install scripts, review launcher or implicit node-gyp input. Evidence is in qualification.log, artifact-audit.json, upgrade-from-261/registry-upgrade-check.json and strict-pnpm-check.json under the release evidence root above.
- Binary SHA-256:
231cd53c828d363d9363f69979f96497d7ab9a96bba7a8df0cf9979a116fac2a. - npm SHA-256:
67b71413c4084f2407df358e6e78eeff39aa92a135fb20195b491343cec96301. - Manifest SHA-256:
7b3812d82f4b6eb85e2fff62d80503fd939fb5df9615b19e623fa2b60a61efdb. SHA256SUMSSHA-256:c589af6faac0c6f8c674aed3bde8950b2f58833b0e84cd88bba66800820a3479.
The final commit records evidence in the plan, roadmap, ledger and derived index only. Merge locally into 2.x and stable main, push reviewed main and the new immutable tag atomically, then dispatch Release Automation in post mode. Stop at the dispatch acknowledgement. Hosted tests and publication remain owned by the workflow. The maintainer will verify macOS upgrades after publication.